🥯30% OFF NYC BAGEL SALE ENDS TONIGHT!🥯
Ess-a-Bagel, Utopia, Sadelle's & More! Shop Now
Favorite
New York Cheesecake
95%Read ReviewsFreezer FriendlyFreezes beautifully, so you can enjoy it fresh or stock up for later.
Ships to U.S. & Canada
Some restrictions applyNew York Cheesecake
This delectable New York-style cheesecake is a Little Pie Company best-seller that may cause them to reconsider their name. They make it with a slightly dense combination of fresh cream cheese and pure vanilla, and bake it in a sublime graham cracker crust.
What started out as a side business for Broadway actor Arnold Wilkerson has since become a bona fide smash hit. This small pie shop first opened in NYC’s Theater District in 1985, but his baked goods were soon recognized as among the best in New York City.
This package serves 8-10 people and includes 1 New York Cheesecake
- Each pie measures 10"
- Product price includes additional labor + packaging costs that go into nationwide shipping
- Cheesecake ships frozen with ice packs, may thaw during transit.
- Upon arrival, store cheesecake in the refrigerator for up to 1 week or in the freezer for up to 1 month.
- Defrost overnight in the refrigerator.
To Serve
- If frozen, defrost overnight in the refrigerator.
- Serve chilled. Delicious topped with fresh fruit or fruit glazes.
- Enjoy!
- Cake – Cream Cheese, Granulated Sugar, Eggs, Pure Vanilla Extract, Lemon Juice, Salt.
- Crust – Graham Cracker, Butter
"Best Mail Order Pie in America" - Rachael Ray
The Little Pie Company has been called the "Best Mail Order Pie in America" by Better Hones & Gardens, Insider, and Rachael Ray; the "Best Pie in NYC" by Time Out Magazine; and the "Best Apple Pie in New York" by the Daily News. It has also been featured in the New York Times, Oprah Magazine, New York Magazine, on the cover of Time Magazine, on The Food Network, and in Bon Appetit, where Sarah Jessica Parker called their pie one of her "non-negotiable Thanksgiving dishes."
"Best Mail Order Pie in America" - Rachael Ray
Little Pie Company
95% love this shopStar Shipper
New York, NYWhat started out as a side business for Broadway actor Arnold Wilkerson in 1985 became a bona fide smash hit over the years. The world-class pie shop first opened in the Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood, but their baked goods were soon recognized citywide for baking up one of the best pies in New York City. Decades later, pastry chefs continue to bake away in their storefront window and seductive aromas waft out the front door, tempting every passerby. It's easy to see why Little Pie Company's mythic scratch-made pies continue to satisfy pie lovers with unparalleled renditions of classics and fresh originals.
Limited-Time Indulgences
Prices that won’t last
HOLIDAYS & OCCASIONS
Gifts for Every Celebration
PURIM
ST. PATRICK'S DAY
BIRTHDAY
TOP 100 GIFTS
CORPORATE GIFTS
SYMPATHY GIFT
PASSOVER
GET WELL
THANK YOU
CARE PACKAGES
NEW BABY
EASTER
MOTHER'S DAY
MEMORIAL DAY
FATHER'S DAY
PRIDE
GRADUATION
JULY 4TH
LABOR DAY
JEWISH HOLIDAYS
MID-AUTUMN FEST
DIWALI
HALLOWEEN
THANKSGIVING
HANUKKAH
CHRISTMAS
NEW YEAR'S
GAME DAY
VALENTINES DAY
MARDI GRAS
LUNAR NEW YEAR