The State of the Pie
America’s Official Pie Index
Published every ThanksgivingAnalysis by Founder Joe Ariel
Key Findings
Apple is the real winner of the Thanksgiving table.
Apple outsells pumpkin
more than three to one.
What America Sends to the People it Loves
On Goldbelly. Shipped nationwide.
5,064 miles
The longest Thanksgiving pie delivery.Honolulu, Hawaii to Lowell, Massachusetts.
0
States where pumpkin ranks No. 1.
250 to 1
November pumpkin pie orders for every one in July.
The top 10 individual pies by Thanksgiving orders on Goldbelly.
01Wisconsin
Apple Pie Baked
in a Paper Bag
The Elegant Farmer
Baked in a paper bag. Ranked No. 1 nationwide.
02New York
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Buttery caramel. Flaky sea salt. The apple pie New York argues about.
03New York
Little Pie Company
The Broadway bakery’s mythic signature. Scratch-made since ’85.
04Texas
Goode Co.
Five pounds. Brazos River pecans. Texas-sized by design.
05Florida
Joe’s Stone Crab
A Miami institution’s signature finish.
06Massachusetts
Omni Parker House
Born in 1856. Technically cake.
07Missouri
Blue Owl Bakery
Eighteen apples. Hand-peeled. Piled sky-high.
08Michigan
Grand Traverse Pie Company
Michigan’s signature cherries. Their bestselling pie.
09Massachusetts
Signature Homestyle
Chicken Pot Pie
Centerville Pie Co.
THE Chicken Pie. The only savory pie in the top 10.
10Minnesota
Betty’s Pies
Granny Smith apples. Oatmeal crunch. Caramel inside and out.
The top-selling savory pies by Thanksgiving orders on Goldbelly.
01Massachusetts
Centerville Pie Co.
The top-selling savory pie in America at Thanksgiving.
02Indiana
Pots & Pans Pie Company
A full Thanksgiving dinner in one pie: turkey, mashed potatoes, gravy and cornbread stuffing.
03Illinois
Chicago Pizza & Oven Grinder Co.
Baked upside down and served right side up. On the menu in Chicago since 1972.
04Maine
Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co.
Maine lobster in a pot pie.
The top-selling pie–cake hybrids by Thanksgiving orders on Goldbelly.
01New York
PieCaken Bakeshop
Pecan pie, pumpkin pie and spice cake in one dessert, topped with apple pie filling.
02Texas
Nikki J’s Cakes
Sweet potato pie on a graham cracker crust, baked in a 9-by-13 pan.
03Massachusetts
Omni Parker House
Called a pie since 1856. It’s a cake.
04Tennessee
Cootie Brown’s
A cheesecake that won first place at the national pie championships.
On Goldbelly. Shipped nationwide.
From The 250 Dishes That Made America, by Joe Ariel
It’s free to subscribe.
Apple Pie
“Crusty outside, snotty inside, just like America.”
Apple pie is about as American as Christopher Columbus. The recipe is English. The apple is from Kazakhstan. And “As American as apple pie” was first used for some strange reason in 1924 to sell men’s suits.Read the essay →
Key Lime Pie
“A good key lime pie should come at you hard enough to make you respect it.”
The first bite lands on the side of your jaw before your brain has agreed to anything. The lime wins for a second. Then the cream gets to make peace. If all you get is a polite pucker, it ain’t key lime pie.Read the essay →
Coming soonPumpkin Pie
“Nobody craves pumpkin pie. They crave November.”
Words I’ve never heard before: “God, I could really go for some pumpkin pie.” Not in July. Not in February. Not ever. People say it in November because the calendar tells them to.Read the 250 Dishes →
For 250 years this country has been saying I love you through food.
No one kept the record. Goldbelly has. Over thirteen years we have shipped tens of millions of America’s most iconic foods, from the kitchens that made them famous to every state in the country. It is the largest record ever built of what Americans crave.
It knows where New York’s bagels go when New Yorkers move away. It knows which state orders the most barbecue from its rival. It knows what America sends when a baby is born, and what it sends when someone dies. Grocery data measures what is nearby. This measures what is loved.
On the 250th anniversary of the United States, we are opening that record to the public for the first time. We begin with Thanksgiving, the country’s greatest food holiday, and with pie, the dish every table argues about.
This is Volume I of the definitive account of how America eats.

Joe Ariel
Founder of Goldbelly
Official Food Curator of America’s 250th Anniversary
Read Joe’s Substack → It’s free to subscribe.
On Goldbelly. Shipped nationwide.
Source: Goldbelly. One full Thanksgiving season of Goldbelly orders, using the most recent data for each day. Shares and rankings count orders of pies shipped through Goldbelly.