New Haven-Style Pizza - 6 Pack (Choose Your Own)

Arrives after Halloween
Product not eligible for additional discounts or promotions

New Haven-style pizza, or “apizza” as the locals call it, is widely recognized as one of the best styles of pizza. Zuppardi’s Apizza has specialized in this regional delicacy since 1934, and is now run by sister’s Lori and Cheryl Zuppardi. To them, the pizzeria, opened by their grandfather, Dominic, is a more than 80-year-old family heirloom to be treasured.

Dig into six apizza pies of your choosing with this pack! The sausage pie Vice declared “a thing of wonder.”? Or the Traditional Plain which consists of a deliciously chewy and perfectly charred crust, oregano, and tomato sauce. This pie does not include Mozzarella, just a bit of pecorino romano sprinkled on top – sound’s simple, but its the real classic and an absolute must try! You are the master of your tastebuds’ fate.

Please Note: Pizzas May Arrive Thawed. Thawed Pizzas Are Safe to Eat and Refreeze

More Details

This pack serves 10-12 people and includes your choice of 6 New Haven-Style Apizza Pies (10" each)

Apizza Flavors Include

  • Traditional Plain – No Mozzarella
  • Special – Mozzarella, Sausage, & Mushroom
  • Mozzarella
  • Mozzarella & Sausage
  • Mozzarella & Pepperoni
  • Mozzarella & Fresh Tomato (White)

This product is not eligible for discounts or promotions unless otherwise noted. Also, it cannot be purchased with promotional gift cards or referral credits


Allergies Include: Gluten, Dairy, Garlic, Soy, Shellfish, Pork

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies ship with dry ice
  • Dry ice may dissipate in transit and pies may arrive thawed
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Store pies in the freezer until ready to serve and may be frozen for up to 6 months

To serve

  • Preheat oven to 425
  • Place pizza directly on center oven rack, bake pizza for 10-12 minutes.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Zuppardi’s Apizza ships Tuesday and Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Connecticut


For all of you that love New Haven Apizza, Zuppardi's is a must try. I no longer can drop by and pick up a Zuppardi's pie..but this is the next best thing for those of us who live far away!!!!!!! Enjoy!

Kelly B. - Maui, HI
Fast efficient shipping. The best New Haven Style pizza (apizza to Connecticut aficionados). 
When these are gone another order will be on the way. We love Zuppardi's ❤️
Robert R. - The Villages, FL
Sent it out to my daughter and son-in-law in San Diego. They can't wait to come back East to get more at Zuppardi's.
jennifer/mark m. - Cardiff by the Sea, CA
Tasty and packaged well.
Courtney Y. - Atlanta, GA
I loved the crust, everything was awesome.
Peter W. - Bluffton, SC
Fresh and tasted great.
Courtenay M. - St Petersburg, FL
Excellent, tasty and fresh!!!!
Karen B. - Williams, AZ
Goldbelly kept me arrived on time no issues!
Lawrence A. - Shreveport, LA
Delicious pizza and fast delivery.
Susan K. - Plymouth Meeting, PA
Pizza was well packed and in good shape when it arrived. Excellent product and easy transaction. A tasty gift!
Kelly M. - Knoxville, TN
Gift for my uncle in Florida he loved it!!!!
Henry M. - North Fort Myers, FL
Ordering Zuppardi's was a convenient way to contribute to a holiday dinner.
Carol A. - Beavercreek, OH
Excellent pizza and great service
Dec G. - Ashland, MA
Fantastic gift for long distance family that misses great pizza
Katie A. - Irmo, SC
The pizzas were well packaged and arrived in good condition. The flavor on the Fresh tomato is surprisingly fresh. Be careful not to overcook the pie as the crust can get really hard (still delicious).
Tammy F. - Danville, VA
Gave the pizzas for gifts. The recipient loved them.
Thea B. - Spotsylvania, VA
Living away from CT we missed great pizza from Zuppardi's. This is a wonderful thing for us. The size is just perfect. We had friends over to share your great pizza with, they loved it. Thank you.
Mary W. - Lakeland, FL
The pizza from zuppardi’s was delicious. Wish they were available in a larger size. The 10” disappears quickly it is soooo good
Nancy L. - Staunton, IL
The pizza was delicious. The pies were just a bit smaller than I expected. But, they arrived in great condition and were absolutely as I remembered them when we used to live in CT.
Lisa O. - Charlotte, NC
Shipping was fast and accurate. Product was still frozen when I received it. And it is delicious!
Mary L. - Brunswick, OH
Grew up in Connecticut. Was so nice to have Zuppardi's Pizza deliver here in Minnesota after so many years missing it. It was very good and will order again.
Rob R. - Eden Prairie, MN
Delicious New Haven pizza delivered to college student in Alabama who missed good pizza!
Connor M. - Tuscaloosa, AL
I ordered the pizza for my grandson who is a Marine and he was thrilled.
Jesse G. - Knoxville, TN
I feel like I’m home again every time I have a pizza from Zuppardi's
Claudia O. - Pearland, TX
Zuppardi’s pizza is the best. Nice to now be able to get it more quickly.
David W. - Hallowell, ME
I love that I can send a piece of home to my brother in law and his wife in Florida for their birthdays and Christmas!
Stash Z. - Ocoee, FL
They arrived right when you said they were going to. cooked one that night it was the most delicious thing I ever ate. I ate a whole one myself. I have told numerous people about Goldbelly.
Donna G. - Fort Myers, FL
I liked the price of these 6 pizzas. Very reasonable. The pizzas are delicious! We love, love pizza and have been wanting to try New Haven style for a while, and we were not disappointed! We haven't eaten them all yet, but they all look wonderful. The mozz and sausage was very good, with the sausage perfectly spiced. I'm sure we may order Zuppardi's Apizza from Goldbelly again.
Victoria L. - Canton, NC
Best CT pizza I’ve had. Crispy crust and authentic New England flavor. Will definitely buy again!
John H. - Alexandria, VA
Ordering was easy. Items arrived as expected. Pizzas were just as delicious as I remembered. Will be ordering again.
Donna L. - Springfield, OR
Great value, delicious pizza, will order from Zuppardi's again!
Amanda B. - Keller, TX
Arrived promptly and packaged well.
Steve A. - Derby, CT
Absolutely fantastic! This is by far the best New Haven Style Pizza you can get on the on the Internet. We can't wait to order some different toppings on our next order.
Kim A. - The Villages, FL
Great taste and quick delivery. We’ll definitely be ordering again. The tomato pie was extremely good.
Shawn M. - Merced, CA
We used to live in Connecticut and would go to Zuppardi’s, so we were so excited to see it listed! I use Goldbelly all of the time for gifts, everyone loves it and has started using Goldbelly too!
Lenny D. - Rising Sun, IN
Best pie I've had the pleasure of eating. From the crust to the sauce and the cheese. Hands down best pie. Will definitely be a repeat customer.
Vincenzo C. - Salyer, CA
The apizza was just as I remembered from my childhood. I’ve been in Florida for 36 years and have never come close to the amazing flavor and perfect crust! I spent many last days of school celebrating promotion to the next day as well more than 1 birthday party. Thank you for bringing back such wonderful memories.
Alisa B. - Clearwater, FL
Easy to order, New Haven pizza is the best in the world!
George G. - Southern Pines, NC
My friend in Atlanta was so very, very happy with Zuppardi's pizza. Hope to surprise her again soon. We grew up on Zuppardi's here in West Haven.
Bonnie J. - Atlanta, GA