Black and White Cookies

Chocolate or vanilla? With the nation's best black & white cookies, you don't have to pick a side. Goldbelly ships these iconic soft, cakey cookies straight from top NYC bakeries and Jewish delis, each one half fudgy chocolate and half sweet vanilla fondant. It's a New York staple, with gluten-free, nut-free, and kosher options so everyone can dig in.

Black & white cookies make a crowd-pleasing gift for a birthday, a celebration, or just because. Treat the whole office to a corporate gift that always disappears fast, or send a box to a homesick New Yorker who deserves a taste of home.

Craving more from the bakery? Round out the spread with swirled babka, tri-color rainbow cookies, and more New York food gifts, or explore the full lineup of cookies and desserts. However you slice it, Goldbelly delivers America's best black & white cookies to all 50 states. 🖤🤍🍪