• Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell
  • Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 1
  • Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 2
  • Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 3
  • Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 4
  • Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 5
  • Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 6
2 Pizzas
Favorite
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell
2 Pizzas
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 1
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 2
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 3
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 4
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 5
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack by Arcaro & Genell - Alternate image 6

Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack

94%Read Reviews

Ships to U.S. & Canada

Some restrictions apply
Old Forge Pizza Combo - 2 Pack

Arcaro & Genell ships its legendary pizza nationwide on Goldbelly Using homemade dough that’s baked until light and crispy and topped with fresh tomato sauce (red-style) or black pepper and rosemary (white-style), try this old school style of pizza that’s somewhere between New York thin crust and Chicago-style.

The charm of Arcaro & Genell’s pizza comes from its birthplace of Old Forge, Pennsylvania. Nestled in the southwest corner of Lackawanna County, the miners of this tiny town would leave late at night and go to the local taverns for some down time. There, the wives and daughters of the miners would make dough on baking pans and top it with tomatoes and spices from their gardens. This regional style of pizza is so popular that the city’s residents have dubbed Old Forge “The Pizza Capital of America!” Opened in 1962, Arcaro & Genell has been featured in Pizza Magazine and declared one of the Top 10 pizzas in the country by USA Today.

This package serves 8-10 people and includes

  • 1 “RED” Style Pizza – A square, thick crust pizza made with tomato sauce and cheese
  • 1 “WHITE” Style Pizza – A square, double crust cheese only pizza with olive oil and rosemary sprinkled on top
  • Each pizza tray is approx. 12″ × 14″
  • Pizzas are made-to-order and promptly frozen.
  • Although each box is carefully packed with ice packs and picked up for immediate shipment, it is normal for the pizza and ice packs to partially or fully thaw during shipment.
  • Upon receipt, please, cook, refrigerate or place in the freezer.
  • Pizzas will stay fresh in the refrigerator for up to 1-2 days or in the freezer for up to 2 months.
  • This product only ships overnight in the summer
View Full Instructions

Home of the Famous Old Forge Pizza

Arcaro & Genell
Arcaro & Genell
94% love this shop
Old Forge, PA
Old Forge-style pizza has reinvented everything we know about pizza. What really throws us is the crust, which is thick, but amazingly light and airy. Top that with a generous amount of a special cheese blend and we’ve become converts. Half of the charm of Arcaro & Genell’s pizza, though, comes from its birthplace, Old Forge. Nestled in the southwest corner of Lackawanna County, the miners of this tiny town would leave late at night and go to the local taverns for some down time. There, the wives and daughters of the miners would make dough on baking pans and top it with tomatoes and spices from their gardens. This regional style of pizza is so popular that the city’s residents have dubbed Old Forge “The Pizza Capital of the World!”
Arcaro & Genell

Limited-Time Indulgences

Prices that won’t last