Choose Your Own Knishes (Kosher) - 18 Pack

Yonah Schimmel Knishes ships its famous knishes nationwide on Goldbelly! Yonah Schimmel Knishes has been a neighborhood fixture on the Lower East Side since the 1890s. Today, they still make these classic Jewish specialty foods the traditional way — hand wrapping a filling of potatoes or kasha (buckwheat grain) with a thin layer of dough before sending it to the oven to bake. Mix and match your favorite flavors in this Choose Your Own Knishes 18 Pack!

Ever since the 1890s, when rabbi Yonah Schimmel began selling knishes from a pushcart and then a storefront, Yonah Schimmel Knishes has been a neighborhood fixture on New York City’s Lower East Side. The Oldest Knishery in America still makes knishes the old-fashioned way — hand wrapping a filling of potatoes or kasha (buckwheat grain) with a thin layer of dough before sending it to the oven to bake. In addition to the traditional potato and kasha knishes, this Jewish bakery makes modern flavors as well, like sweet potato, mushroom, broccoli, and sweet cheese.

More Details

This package includes 18 knishes

  • Choose six of your favorite knish flavors from the options below
  • Each knish is approximately 4"
  • Yonah Schimmel Knish is Kosher Cup certified

This product ships overnight during the summer.

Flavors Include

  • Potato – The original and quintessential knish with fresh potatoes baked to perfection
  • Kasha – Yonah Schimmel’s delicious family recipe with buckwheat, one of a kind savory flavor. So healthy and delicious
  • Sweet Potato – What a mouth watering super delight. A combination of sweet and salty
  • Mushroom – An exciting flavor combination of mushrooms mixed with potatoes
  • Spinach – A delicious mixture of potato and spinach, an irresistible combination
  • Broccoli – Yonah Schimmel’s amazing potato Knish filled with delicious broccoli
  • Red Cabbage – An absolutely wonderful and tasteful Knish featuring fresh delicious red cabbage
  • Mixed Vegetable – Potatoes with peas, corn, carrots and string beans. A delicious flavor to ravish
  • Apple Cheese – Scrumptious combination of apples and cheese
  • Cherry Cheese – Sweet and tart cherries with creamy cheese, what a perfect combination
  • Blueberry Cheese – If you like blueberries, you’ll love this knish
  • Chocolate Cheese – Chocolate lovers delight
  • Plain Cheese – This may sound simple, but it’s just absolutely yummy
  • Apple Strudel – Better than apple pie
  • Jalapeño and Mozzarella Knish – A delicious potato knish mixed with jalapeños and covered with mozzarella cheese
  • Jalapeño with Cheddar Knish – A delicious potato knish mixed with jalapeños and covered with cheddar cheese
  • Pizza Knish – A delicious potato knish topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese


Potato Knish – Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Kasha Knish – Buckwheat, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Sweet Potato Knish – Sweet Potato, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Mushroom Knish – Mushroom, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Spinach Knish – Spinach, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Mixed Vegetable Knish – String Beans, Carrots, Corn, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Red Cabbage Knish – Red Cabbage, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free.
Broccoli Knish – Broccoli, Potato, Onions, Spices, And Dough. Vegan & Nut Free
Apple Cheese Knish – Cream Cheese, Bakers Cheese, Sugar, Dough And Apple Filling. No Nuts Or Eggs. Vegetarian.
Cherry Cheese Knish – Cream Cheese, Bakers Cheese, Sugar, Dough And Cherry Filling. No Nuts Or Eggs. Vegetarian.
Blueberry Cheese Knish – Cream Cheese, Bakers Cheese, Sugar, Dough And Blueberry Filling. No Nuts Or Eggs. Vegetarian.
Chocolate Cheese Knish – Cream Cheese, Bakers Cheese, Sugar, Dough And Chocolate Filling. No Nuts Or Eggs. Vegetarian.
Plain Cheese Knish – Cream Cheese, Bakers Cheese, Sugar, And Dough. No Nuts Or Eggs. Vegetarian.
Apple Strudel – Apples, Breadcrumbs, Sugar, Cinnamon, And Dough. It Is The Only Sweet Knish Made Without Cheese. Vegan And Nut Free.
Jalapeno and Mozzarella – Potato, Onions, Spices, Dough, Jalapeños, and Mozzarella Cheese
Jalapeno and Cheddar – Potato, Onions, Spices, Dough, Jalapeños, and Cheddar Cheese
Pizza – Potato, Onions, Spices, Dough, Tomato Sauce, and Mozzarella Cheese

Instructions / Storage

  • Knishes ship fresh not frozen with ice packs that may thaw partially or fully during transit
  • Upon arrival, place the knishes in the refrigerator
  • To serve, heat knishes in a microwave for 2 minutes or in a 350F oven covered with foil for 10 minutes or until warm. Remove the foil for the last few minutes for a crispy knish. Best enjoyed with some deli mustard!
  • To store, wrap the knishes individually with plastic wrap and store in the refrigerator for up to 5 days or freezer for up to 3 months. To serve after frozen, heat the knish as noted above. There is no need to thaw the knish before heating
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Yonah Schimmel Knishes ships Monday through Thursday of each week
  • Knishes ship fresh not frozen with ice packs that may thaw partially or fully during transit
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


The knishes were FANTASTIC!!!! 
Merril A. - Philadelphia, PA
"Everything arrived in time for Chanukah gift giving! Well packaged and all the ex New Yorkers were thrilled that you exist! Thanks for making everyone happy!"
Myrna K. - Sherman Oaks, CA
Knishes were fantastic. I ordered for a specific datev & the food arrived exactly on that date. Well packed too.
Victoria P. - Walpole, MA
Very delicious, efficient, fair price.
Dr. W. - Carmel, IN
The knishes remind of my mother's so many years agp.
Hanan R. - Minneapolis, MN
The product (knishes) was great and packaged perfectly. We enjoyed the knishes so much---almost the same as when we had purchased & ate them at the knishery itself!!
Martin S. - Reston, VA
The Yonah Schimmel Knishes are wonderful!!. They came well wrapped in an insulated container so were fine even thou they sat outside our house all day. Can't wait to taste them all and to share some with our friends. Great to be able to have authentic New York knishes
Robert J. - Voorhees, NJ
The food was great and very fresh, It was shipped fast and packed very well.
Jay S. - North Potomac, MD
All of the knishes taste awesome!! First time to order the pretzels with cheese!! They are amazing!!
Heike W. - Niceville, FL
Best knishes. Remind me of my days growing up in Brooklyn.
Joseph S. - Wantagh, NY
Goldbelly is awesome and convenient and Yonah Schimmels has the best knishes on Earth. You can’t put a price on the quality delivered to you, so even though it’s not cheap, it’s well worth it.
David F. - Superior, CO
They always arrive fresh - when you heat them up in the oven, they taste as if you were just at Yonah's and picked them up.
Alexandra P. - Edgewood, NM
Being that they have been in business for so long, I felt confident in the quality of their product. But I didn't know how well it would stand up to my dad's memory of having knishes in New York when he was young. Well, they were an amazing and perfect surprise for my parents' 50th anniversary party.
Ralph R. - Coral Springs, FL
This purchase was a remedy for a bad experience I had this winter where an expensive cake was lost in transit for days, defrosted and delivered to me unusable for the holidays. I was about to write your company off when a customer service rep intervened and offered a refund back for the cake (which had to be thrown away) in the form of a credit. This experience went much better with the product arriving close to the expected time and in good shape.
Arlene H. - Darien, CT
Yummy Knishes arrived and were as delicious as childhood memory hoped they would be.
Florence H. - McKinney, TX
From placing the order, to the final delivery, everything went very smoothly! My brother in law is from New York and was craving a "good New York knish." We just had to get some for his surprise 60th birthday party! IT WAS A BIG, BIG HIT!
Bob W. - Canyon Lake, TX
Everything was seamless. The ordering experience was great, the shipping was fast and the food arrived perfectly packaged and most importantly, it was delicious!!
Charles K. - Lake Worth, FL
The knishes we sent our daughter were devoured with great joy. They were the perfect gift for a dinner in her new home.
Mallorie B. - Eden, UT
Knishes were perfect, just like always! Arrived on time and delicious!
Erynn S. - Burien, WA
Everything was shipped well and came to the house on time and in perfect condition. The Knishes were delicious and helped my husband relive his youth in NY.
Lisa K. - San Francisco, CA
Shipping, packaging and of course, the consistently delicious knishes.
Deborah Z. - Bay Harbor Islands, FL
Everything went well. Shipment was right on time, perfectly packaged, food was fresh, delicious and delightful.
Wendy M. - Bronx, NY
Everything. Ease of ordering, promptness of delivery, and quality that I remember.
Jason H. - Pike Road, AL
Knishes arrived in perfect condition and very quickly!! I highly recommend Goldbelly!
Gerald B. - Charlottesville, VA
The items arrived when you said they would & my grandfather loved his present!
Irving K. - Margate, FL
The knishes were outstanding, just like I remember over 50 years ago. I am in Florida and not one deli here has the exceptional quality of a Yonah Schimmel knish. The blueberry cheese knish was the best. Also, great service, packaged very well and still chilled.
Roy S. - Stuart, FL
Delivered as promised,order was perfect. I look forward to trying more iconic eateries from around the country.
Leslie C. - Woodside, CA
Delivered on time in perfect condition. They were delicious.
Katie T. - La Mesa, CA
Fast delivery and outstanding food!
Randi L. - Oro Valley, AZ
The package was still cold when it reached Arizona.
Irla I. - Avondale, AZ
Knishes arrived fresh!
The O. - San Francisco, CA
The recipient loved the gift which was knishes!
Rebecca E. - Monterey, MA
Delivered on time and knishes were awesome!!
R R. - Pittsburgh, PA
Absolutely delicious baked goods reminded me of my childhood growing up in Brooklyn with wonderful bakeries.
Susan S. - Palo Alto, CA
Delivery was spot on. Product was exactly what I was expecting.
Ellen B. - Hesperus, CO
I get exactly what I order & by the date I expect it! Plus I am able to get some of my favorite bagels from my former hometown.
Reva M. - Hamden, CT
Everything. Delivery was on time, well packaged, delicious knishes, everything was perfect. It made for a great Father’s Day gift.
martin G. - Orange, CA
The knishes were received promptly and in good condition!
Michael R. - Plano, TX
Gift I ordered arrived on time and in great condition. The recipient said they were delicious too!
Erik J. - Boulder, CO
Knishes arrived on time & in perfect condition.
Ira S. - Spring Valley, CA
Everything was delivered with care and items were packaged perfectly. No issues with delivery. Everything was delicious...thanks again!
Arlene H. - Bronx, NY
Shipped quickly and on time. Packaged well.
Sue I. - San Diego, CA
Arrived in two days. Packing was excellent. Food was fresh.
Rick T. - Glendora, CA
Delivered what I ordered & on time. Yonah Schimmel also appreciated that I am a return customer.
Reva M. - Hamden, CT
Delivered on the exact date as requested. As an x New Yorker who frequented Yonah Shimel on the lower east side, I can say they are the best knishes except for what I can remember my Granny made 60+ years ago. Now as a Floridian, it is great to be able to have them delivered to my door. They are a treat for sure.
Sherrie R. - Ponte Vedra, FL
Quick and easy to order. Food arrived when promised and very fresh.
Eloise A. - New York, NY
Everything. Great Service & Great Food!!!
Sally M. - San Antonio, TX
Product was delivered on time as scheduled and in excellent condition
AJ P. - Plantation, FL
Everything. Ordering was easy, and communication regarding shipment was timely and accurate.
Barbara S. - Sandy Springs, GA
Our package arrived as promised. Everything was well packed & fresh. Will certainly order from you again. Thank you for heat service!
Stephen K. - Mahwah, NJ
Delivered from NYC to Phoenix, AZ 48 hours after order was placed on a weekend. Order came packed cold and food was delicious.
C S. - Avondale, AZ
Delivery was on time and packaged exceptionally well
Esther M. - Brooklyn, NY
Delivered on time, as expected. And delicious! A fabulous last minute addition to our Yom Kippur breakfast.
Pamela G. - Sonoma, CA
Easy to order, quick delivery and food was delicious.
Tom B. - Davis, CA
I am a foodie living rural, and Goldbelly brings the world of food to me! Everything arrived fresh and delicious!
Rosalyn M. - Mifflinburg, PA
Delivered on time as quoted. Quality of product was excellent
Sandy V. - Lake Worth, FL
The food was delivered the day listed. It was cold and the ice packs held up great and it was also wrapped in insulation. I questioned customer service about when the items get shipped because it was my first time, and I got an answer in less than 24 hours which eased my concern.
Iarry S. - Moraga, CA
Knishes arrived fresh and they were delicious!
Gail W. - West Linn, OR
The delivery experience was excellent. The package arrived at my condo in record time. The icepacks were mostly frozen and the Knishes were protected. I live in a gated complex that sometimes is hard to navigate and delivery drivers unexperienced with my complex get lost and that causes a delay. That didn't happen. No delay. Knishes were in excellent shape. The Knishes went across the country from NYC to northern CA.
Carrie S. - Sacramento, CA
Fast shipping, excellent packing, good communication
Kristin W. - Austin, TX
The food was great, special and not available where we live. The gift was a great surprise.
Bruce B. - Hadley, MA
The ordering process is easy. The packaging and shipping of my order was excellent.
GAIL R. - Burlington, NJ
The knishes were delicious and beautifully packed. Yonah Schimmel was always a favorite of ours.
Debra S. - Mineola, NY
My first order on Goldbelly went extremely well. The knishes arrived in perfect condition, and are delicious! I look forward to making more purchases through Goldbelly, with there being so many options.
Beverly H. - Centennial, CO
Delivery on time with lots of ice to prevent spoiling. Tracking was accurate and delivery rang our bell. Yonah Schimmel's Knishes were as delicious as I remembered growing up in NYC.
Karen C. - Brentwood, CA