Famous Giant Black & White Cookies
(Customer Reviews)William Greenberg Desserts ships its famous black & white cookies nationwide on Goldbelly! If you didn’t grow up in New York, chances are you’ve never tasted this cake-like cookie topped with half dark chocolate half vanilla icing. Half chocolate, half vanilla, all delicious.
Beloved bakery William Greenberg Bakery has delighted New Yorkers since 1946. On his way back to New York after serving in World War II, Greenberg acquired the funds needed to open his eponymous Manhattan bakery during a card game. The rest is delicious history. The New York bakery makes all the classics, including black & white cookies, rugelah, and brownies.
More Details
This package includes 12 Black and White Cookies
- Each cookie is Approximately 5" in diameter
- Cookies are individually wrapped and impeccably packaged in a William Greenberg gift box.
Instructions / Storage
- Cookies can be stored at room temperature for up to 5 days or in the refrigerator for up to 8 days
- Cookies may be frozen for up to 6 months
Shipping Details
- William Greenberg Desserts ships Monday-Thursday of each week
- Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
- Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
- Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Corporate Gift Orders
You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.
Recommended for you
More from New York
William Greenberg Desserts REVIEWS
The cookies were thick, soft and tasty!! The frosting was smooth and flavorful. They were sweet, but not too sweet. My entire family loved them!
Carla Q. - Union, SC
01/08/20
I received the cookies the packaging was well packed. Cookies are wonderful.
Kimberly M. - Citrus Heights, CA
01/21/20
The gift to my son was fresh and perfect!! I made black and white cookies for years( born and bred New Yorker) !! My son lives in the PNW so this gift was a terrific find!!!
Levi H. - Milwaukie, OR
12/03/19
Speedy delivery, product was fresh and delicious and was exactly as described with the taste.
Louis K. - Flower Mound, TX
12/09/19
The cookies were packaged perfect. Fresh. Couldn’t be more satisfied.
Carol P. - De Kalb, MS
12/10/19
Delivered fresh and sooo good. The black and white cookies were so thick, it was almost a cake. Will definitely order these again for gifts.
Michelle K. - Chillicothe, MO
12/10/19
Arrived well packed and very fresh! Delicious- gluten free treats!!!
Sara T. - Fairfield, CT
02/03/20
There was no doubt the cookies were baked fresh and shipped. My dad is from Paterson, NJ and was talking about the things he missed about “home”. These cookies made him grin and brought back a flood of memories from childhood. Would order again! Thanks!!!
Robert C. - Virginia Beach, VA
01/13/20
Outstanding Black and White cookies! I haven't had them in over 40 years. Difficult to share with my NYC friends here in California, but after they pinned me to the floor I had no choice but to share! I can't say enough about how good they were!
Thomas M. - Chula Vista, CA
01/13/20
The cookies arrived on time. Wrapped perfectly. The Black and White cookies were fantastic!!!
Ate some, shared some and froze the rest.
Karina O. - Cedar Rapids, IA
02/13/20
The cookies were well packaged and arrived in great condition..
Linda W. - Carlsbad, NM
02/18/20
Very fresh and tasty
Gary P. - Phoenix, AZ
02/18/20
Everything! They arrived on the date I ask for them to be delivered. They were fresh and delicious!
Diane B. - Camp Hill, PA
02/18/20
The black and white cookies were delicious! Can't find anything like that in New England. Brought back memories of growing up in NY. Thank you.
Linda A. - Springfield, MA
02/24/20
I have been looking all over Denver for Black and White Cookies and now that I know Goldbelly and William Goldberg has them this is where I can get them if I have cravings.
Linda H. - Aurora, CO
02/26/20
The cookies arrived very well packed and in perfect condition
Rachel W. - Killeen, TX
03/02/20
Delivery right on time! Ordered Treats for my son’s birthday sent to college. He loves real NYC bagels and black&whites. Super treat for his day while studying for midterms. Will definitely use your services again!
John M. - Winston Salem, NC
03/03/20
Delivery was right on time. Cookies were delicious and were in a very attractive box
Julie A. - Phoenix, AZ
03/09/20
Received the package in good condition upon opening it a very big cake box with a pretty pink ribbon greeted me packed inside I was very pleased with the way my BLACK AND WHITE COOKIES WERE WRAPPED SO CAREFUL THANKFUL NONE WERE BROKEN I DEFINITELY WILL BE ORDERING FROM YOUR COMPANY AGAIN
Mary F. - Hauppauge, NY
03/16/20
The cookies were exactly as if I got them myself in NY. They came individually wrapped in the box! So yummy!!!
Tammy M. - Flower Mound, TX
03/16/20
The item, blackout layer cake arrived well packaged in a timely manner. Great taste!
Daryle W. - New Port Richey, FL
04/10/21
It was delivered on time and everything was delicious!
Celie H. - Kingwood, TX
04/11/21
right on time an delish! William Greenberg made my college student granddaughter very happy :)
EMILY L. - Nashville, TN
03/28/21
Everything went it has since we began using the site for Greenberg’s bakery Black and Whites and Rugaluch and Russ and Daughter’s for the best selection of Lox and scallion cream cheese. The best of the best from my childhood brought to our home in Minnesota!
Glenn D. - Shoreview, MN
03/27/21
Cookies were awesome! Delivery time was short! Love your products!
Camille B. - Jonesboro, AR
03/27/21
Items arrived in a timely manner and in excellent condition. A mistake was made with one item and Goldbelly immediately sent a replacement-fabulous customer service and integrity!
Debra F. - Charlotte, NC
03/13/21
The cookies were fresh and delicious. Also easy to freeze and thaw later.
Deborah W. - Saint Paul, MN
03/11/21
The cookies were wonderful !! The cookies arrived in a way that made me happy. Thank you so much!! I am sure we will do business again.
Barbara W. - Allegany, NY
03/09/21
cookies came on time! the bakeries are very generous with the size and amount of cookies 🤩
Adelyn C. - Mountain View, CA
02/21/21
Loved my black and white cookies! The best in NYC!
Barbara E. - Forked River, NJ
02/18/21
Utterly delicious!
Maurice J. - Tucson, AZ
05/23/21
Everything!!
The items that I ordered are outstanding, and arrived well packed. This was my first experience with Goldbelly and I am thoroughly impressed and pleased. Thank you!
Nancy C. - Terre Haute, IN
05/16/21
Everything— the treats were delicious and came on time. Couldn’t ask for more!!
Connie G. - Trail Creek, IN
05/10/21
Delivery time was perfect for a birthday. The Black and Whites are the best in the world.
Mark S. - Bradenton, FL
07/18/21
The pastries were delicious and arrived on time.
Elise W. - Phoenix, AZ
07/12/21
Very easy to order, and arrived just as promised.
Barbara S. - Fort Myers, FL
07/05/21
Delivery was on time in good condition...can't ask for more than that
Olga E. - San Francisco, CA
06/27/21
Delivery was fast, arrived in a timely fashion, and my dad loved the father's day surprise. No complaints!
Michael R. - Yorba Linda, CA
06/22/21
Good all arrived on time and was great!
Amanda P. - Bend, OR
06/21/21
Food was delivered on expected date, and was delicious.
Noreen K. - Fairfield, CT
05/31/21
Delivery,
Schedule,
Delicious,
Kathleen D. - Dix Hills, NY
09/20/21
Fresh, perfectly wrapped and on time!
Kelly S. - Columbia, SC
09/19/21
The rugelah was the best we've had and the delivery was perfect.
Constance S. - Port Jefferson, NY
09/17/21
I sent these pastries as a gift and was told by the recipient that these were the best he ever had.
Zachary M. - Buffalo, NY
09/12/21
Delivery was exactly like I was told. The gifts were well received and everybody raved about the taste!
Scott S. - Atlanta, GA
09/12/21
Shipment received exactly on time; recipient enjoyed the contents.
Albert F. - Easton, PA
09/11/21
Easy to order. Food was high quality.
Kim T. - Highlands Ranch, CO
09/05/21
From ordering to delivery PERFECT !!!!!
Isabella O. - Norfolk, VA
08/29/21
On time delivery, cookies, as always, were delicious.
Morgan W. - Saint Louis, MO
08/29/21
Quality and freshness of the black and white cookies purchased.
Rick B. - Rochester, NY
08/24/21
Order was received accurately and on the date requested. And I got to have a fresh Black and White Cookie with my coffee!
Dakota O. - Chanhassen, MN
08/22/21
Delivery perfectly as promised. Great selection. Gift card was accepted without any trouble. I will use your service again!
Eric A. - Grand Island, NY
08/22/21
Cake is excellent. Looks just like the photo. Beautiful. And tasted superb!
Roberta H. - Brant Lake, NY
08/16/21
Food and shipment went great. It will make my party a success.
Nancy P. - Camp Verde, AZ
08/15/21
I have tried to find these in Chicago and have not been successful. These were EXACTLY the way I remember them as a kid. They were perfect!
marcia c. - Evanston, IL
01/16/22
THE COOKIES WERE SO DELICIOUS I HAD TO SEND THEM AGAIN.
Alex - ,
01/11/22
The food is familiar and fresh.
Jo C. - Carpinteria, CA
12/10/21
The black & white cookies are delicious! Love being able to order foods from so many bakeries and restaurants.
Holly S. - Long Beach, IN
11/29/21
Everything - these cookies were amazing. Especially the gluten-free. I have been gluten-free for 10 years and these are the best gluten-free dessert I've ever had! Not a single one was damaged either.
Stephanie P. - Osprey, FL
11/18/21
The order of Black & White cookies brought a little bit of NYC home to Indiana. These are my husband's absolute favorite cookies in the world. Thanks for helping to make his birthday perfect!
Miranda F. - Edinburgh, IN
10/26/21
REAL Black n Whites like we remember! Excellent flavor! I got my brother hooked!
Suzanne M. - Sale Creek, TN
10/02/21
Everything went well I will order again very fresh and Delicious
Margaret W. - Denver, NC
04/13/22
Arrived on time, packed well, and is absolutely delicious!
Karen O. - Saint Augustine, FL
04/12/22
Fast shipping. Fresh. As described.
Donna G. - Greenwood, MS
04/05/22
Everything. Great food, delivered in a timely manner, on ice and my husband loved his 53rd anniversary present🥳
SELA M. - Brooklyn, NY
04/02/22
I sent this as a gift and my friend was impressed with quality of dessert and intact arrival of same.
Terry T. - Paoli, PA
04/02/22
All went well! Every time we order - easy to order, always arrives on scheduled day, goods are well packed and fresh!
Wendy M. - Otis, OR
03/28/22
Delivered as promised. VERY well packaged. Outstanding product.
SaritaAnn R. - Sumter, SC
03/28/22
Easy to use website, fast delivery, and, most importantly, great tasting food that arrives undamaged and fresh!
Norm W. - Henderson, NV
03/27/22
The shipment was on time. The cookies were beautifully boxed in fresh… So fresh and yummy! Thank you for doing what you’re doing to support Ukraine. I will definitely order from you again. Peace
Deb C. - Aurora, IL
03/27/22
Delivery on time and well packaged and food looked and tasted as pictured
Carrie H. - Short Hills, NJ
03/27/22
Black and White Cookies from William Greenberg Desserts arrived on time (FedEx Standard Overnight) and were delicious.
Matthew S. - Rocklin, CA
03/21/22
Top quality and excellent packaging. This was my first order but I'm now a loyal customer. You can't go wrong. This is customer service and quality like the good old days!
Barry H. - Nolensville, TN
03/19/22
Taste. Freshness. Ease of order. Delivery.
Mark G. - Chicago, IL
03/16/22
Delivery was on time. Cookies were nicely packed with no squishing or crumbling. Black & whites are superb.
Marion G. - Falls Church, VA
03/13/22
Everything went well, it was a perfect experience. The Giant Black/White Cookies from William Greenberg were bigger than we ever expected. My husband and I had to split 1 cookie, they were so big we couldn't eat one ourselves. Delivery was quick and the cookie was delicious.
Susan M. - Lisbon, NY
03/07/22
The delivery was expeditious. Cookies arrived beautifully packaged and intact. I can't wait to try them.
Maria M. - Port Chester, NY
03/06/22