Choose Your Own Classic Pickles - 1 Gallon

The Pickle Guys ships its famous pickles nationwide on Goldbelly! Choose your favorite pickle in this 1-Gallon Classic Pickle Pack! Choose from sour, 3/4 sour, and 1/2 sour pickles, hot sour pickles, horseradish pickles, pickled tomatoes, and Sour Kraut. The Pickle Guys pickles are Kosher-certified, Vegan, and Gluten-Free.

Founded by Alan Kaufman on New York’s Lower East Side, The Pickle Guys have been making sweet and sour pickles with an old Eastern European recipe “just the way mom used to make them” since 2000. Pickles are cured in a barrel with a salt brine with garlic and spices for as long as six months. The Pickle Guys’ pickles are kosher and have the perfect snap. If you’re ever in a pickle for pickles, you know where to get them!

More Details

  • This package includes 1 gallon of pickles of your choosing
  • This arrives in a 1-gallon container
  • Kosher-certified, Vegan & Gluten Free

Pickle Options Included

  • Half Sour Pickle – Pickle Guys 1/2 sour pickles are wonderfully crisp and thoroughly delicious. Made in the traditional way, allowing as much flavor as possible. The freshest cucumbers are placed in a large barrel filled with a unique mix of spices. The cucumbers are left in brine until pickled just right to give you that perfect 1/2 sour taste. The first bite will have you instantly hooked. Great eaten as a side dish or simply as a snack. Offering you a taste of happiness that will have you coming back for more!
  • Sour Pickle – These full sour pickles are prepared using a traditional method. Healthy pickles are picked and add into a large barrel, along with a special spice mix. They’re mixed and allowed to sit in spices so the flavor runs deeply through each and every one of them. Packing the flavor inside, till they reach your hands.
  • Hot New Pickles – These juicy and crunchy pickles are for those who love a little touch of spice on everything. If you live your life on the spicy side then you will love the hot new pickles, as they can easily be added to almost any dish you are eating. The perfect blend is brought together using a fresh batch of quality pickles.
  • New Pickle – These delicious new pickles are brined just enough to ensure they are perfectly crunchy. Packing a savory and sour flavor into every bite. So you can truly enjoy new pickles as they are meant to be. Bringing a smile on your face that can only be achieved by authentic new pickles.
  • 3/4 Sour Pickle – Pickle Guys’ 3/4 sour pickles offer a juicy bite that is packed with rich taste and sour twist. This tangy bite is exactly what has been missing from your life! Offering you a taste of happiness that will have you coming back for more!
  • Horseradish Pickle – These horseradish pickles is the perfect marriage between 1/2 sour and spicy that will just melt your taste buds. Crafted beautifully using traditional methods, topped with a secret spice mix that makes these pickles stand out. So when you open the jar and take take a bite, you can feel the joy and happiness taking over you.
  • Hot Sour Pickle – The infamous hot sour pickles bring forward the perfect collaboration between two powerful flavors. For long you have been wishing for a pickle that packs both heat and sourness. Giving your tongue a zestful taste like no other. Finally, you have the hot and sour pickles that make for a delicious and crunchy pairing with savory foods. When you open the lid you get access to freshly picked hot sour pickles that will make your day.


Pickles – Cucumbers, Water, Salt, Pickling Spices, Garlic.
Hot Pickles – Cucumbers, Water, Salt, Pickling Spices, Garlic, Hot Pepper
Horseradish Pickles – Cucumbers, Water, Salt, Pickling Spices, Garlic, Horseradish, and Pickles

Instructions / Storage

  • Pickles arrive ready to serve
  • Upon arrival, remove packaging and place the pickles in the refrigerator
  • Pickles can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 1 month
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • The Pickle Guys ships Monday – Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


I am addicted to these pickles. Just like from my childhood in NYC.
B F. - San Jose, CA
The Pickle Guys need to give classes on how to wrap food for delivery! It took me 20 minutes to "break-in" to the packed container of pickles, lol. This was NOT an annoying experience due to my receipt of damaged shipping containers from another vendor. Rather, I very much appreciated the care with which the container was secured to ensure it survived the shipping process. The pickles are excellent! I am tickled with the purchase.
Patricia B. - Cheverly, MD
The pickles arrived on the date promised - all the way to the west coast-and were perfectly”half-sour”. I was able to track the order and was contacted when it was delivered. It couldn’t have gone better!
Andrew B. - San Diego, CA
The second time I’ve ordered from gold belly through the pickle guys everything came perfectly wrapped came on time. What could be better?
Sandi S. - Jupiter, FL
The Horseradish pickles are phenomenal!
Frank C. - Coral Gables, FL
All of the pickles we got from The Pickle Guys were absolutely superb! Well, not "were," because we're still enjoying them. We're making them last for as long as we can. Good, good, good!!!
Steven H. - Eastsound, WA
Excellent pickles with simple, quick delivery.
Michael H. - Vero Beach, FL
The pickles are great, they were packaged really well in environmentally friendly packaging.
Carli M. - Flagstaff, AZ
the pickles from the pickle guy were fabulous! I ordered the new pickles
jorge d. - Glendale, CA
The marinated peppers, celery and pepper rings were amazing! Best ever! Fresh, gorgeous produce. Packaged beautifully.
sc b. - Sedona, AZ
Awesome tasting half sours and tomatoes!
Brian D. - Omaha, NE
Pickles are amazing best pickles I’ve had outside of an actual deli. The Pickle Guys take care in their packing and the pickles arrive sealed and on time. I have bought the 4 quarts in the past and found the sour and sour hot are amazing. This time I got the gallon of sour and they are delicious. I will be back!
Bradford A. - Culver City, CA
the best pickles in the world
jorge d. - Glendale, CA
Great product. Fast delivery.
Keith S. - Lake Elsinore, CA
On time,packaged well and love the pickles!!!!!
Allen G. - Liberty, TX
Everything went smoothly. Got my items on time - all good!
Tony F. - Evanston, IL
Delivery, notification, and product was outstanding!
Monica L. - Flower Mound, TX
Delivery was on time. Food was in perfect condition. I was well notified of status every step of the way.
Daniel S. - Pineville, NC