

Cafe's Buttermilk Pie
92%Read ReviewsReady To Eat
Freezer Friendly
This pie is a great old southern recipe & is often called the “poor man’s pie.” This HANDMADE PIE is like a chess pie or dense custard & is best served chilled right out of the ’frig. We suggest that you keep it frozen and then pull it out to thaw in the ’frig a couple of hours before you want to serve it.
Royer’s and Goldbelly are proud to support local charitable organizations and 5% of your pie’s purchase price will be donated to the local Texas charity of your choosing. Please select one of the below organizations when placing your order:
- The Lone Survivor Foundation – Restores, empowers, and renews hop for wounded service members, veterans and their families through health, wellness and therapeutic support.
- Boot Campaign- Provides financial assistance to service members, veterans and their families with housing needs, career and education costs, PTSD/TBI treatment, and health and wellness programs.
- Brookwood Community – A God-centered educational, residential, and entrepreneurial community for adults with functional disabilities.
- Camp Pine Cove – An interdenominational camp focused on meeting the spiritual and recreational needs of families, youth, church groups, and other Christian organizations.
Watch Goldbelly Video
This package serves 8-10 people and includes a Cafe’s Buttermilk Pie
- This arrives in a branded pie box. It’s the perfect gift from Texas!
- Choose to add a bag of coffee!
- Pies ship frozen with ice packs, may thaw during transit.
- Upon arrival, store items in the refrigerator or freezer.
- Pies last up to 4-5 days in the refrigerator or up to 3 months in the freezer.
To Serve
Reheating Instructions (Optional)
Oven
- If Frozen, thaw on counter for a few hours until pie reaches room temperature.
- Preheat oven to 250° F.
- Heat pie for 15-20 minutes or just until the middle is nice and gooey!
- Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Not included
- Serve and enjoy!
Microwave
- If Frozen, thaw on counter for a few hours until pie reaches room temperature.
- Heat for 15-30 seconds or just until the middle is nice and gooey!
- Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Not included
- Serve and enjoy!
May Contain Nuts

Texas's Legendary Pie Heaven
Texas's Legendary Pie Heaven

Since 1987, Royer's Round Top Café has been serving up legendary handmade pies and Texas comfort food, thanks to Bud “The Pieman” Royer and his family. Today, son J.B. Royer and wife Jamie-Len proudly carry on the family legacy, keeping those famously gooey, generously filled pies at the heart of this beloved Texas institution.
But there's more than pie on the menu! Royer’s American Classics include buttermilk fried chicken, tender braised short ribs, creamy mashed potatoes and old-fashioned creamed corn, with select family-style dinners and pies shipped nationwide through Goldbelly. All this from a tiny, 40-seat café in Round Top, halfway between Austin and Houston. Either the Royer's have built one mighty loyal following, or everyone in town eats pie for breakfast, lunch and dinner


































