Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie

Nick’s Kitchen ships its famous Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! Introduced by Quaker homesteaders in the early 1800s, this humble Midwestern standard is made with heavy cream, flour, sugar, vanilla, and milk never fails to satisfy. One taste of owner Jean Anne Bailey’s family recipe and you’ll see why Sugar Cream Pie is the state favorite of Hoosier’s everywhere.

While many claim to have kickstarted the Midwest’s pork tenderloin sandwich trend, most agree that Nick’s Kitchen founder Nick Frienstein sold the first pork tenderloin sandwiches from a cart in Huntington, Indiana, in 1904. Since moving into a black-and-red diner in 1908, the town has changed, but not this sandwich, with each giant tenderloin tenderized by hand, soaked in buttermilk, and then coated in cracker crumbs before being fried and placed on a bun. Nick’s Kitchen is also famous for its Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie, a vanilla custard-y filling topped with cinnamon and sugar.

More Details

This package serves 6-8 people and includes a Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie.

Ingredients

Crust, Crisco, Flour, Corn Syrup, Water, White Sugar, Brown Sugar, Flour, Whipping Cream, Milk, Butter, Vanilla, Cinnamon

Instructions / Storage

Hoosier Sugar Cream Pies are made-to-order and promptly frozen. Although each box is carefully packed with ice packs and picked up for immediate shipment, it is normal for the pie and ice packs to partially or fully thaw during shipment. Upon receipt, please refrigerate or place in the freezer.

Hoosier Sugar Cream Pies will stay fresh in the fridge for up to 7days. If you wish to keep them longer, you can store them in the freezer for up to 3 months.

Detailed storage instructions are included in the box.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Pies ship Tuesday and Wednesday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Indiana

REVIEWS

The gift recipients said it was the most delicious Hoosier pie they ever had.
Ken C. - Villa Rica, GA
12/26/19
The Indiana cream pie was delicious.
Ann T. - Silver Spring, MD
03/03/20
Pork loin is delicious! Will order again!!
Francis C. - Pittsburgh, PA
03/17/20
The Hoosier sugar pie is great from nicks kitchen got to tell you it’s one of my favorite desserts at the country of course I scrape off all the sugar from the top otherwise it’s just too sweet.
James S. - Johnstown, CO
09/20/20
The pie arrived exactly when it was supposed to. The recipients said the pie was the best of its kind they have had. Pleased with my purchase in every regard.
Jane W. - Raleigh, NC
12/01/20
Package arrived when it was supposed to be here. The pies were still fresh frozen we couldn’t be happier. Thank You Goldbelly.
Thomas K. - Bel Air, MD
12/01/20
Food was packed really well, arrived cold and in a timely manner. Breaded tenderloin was excellent and spot on with curing my crave for food from home. Definitely order again!
Deb S. - Alpharetta, GA
08/12/20
Delicious and loved that you send everything you need to enjoy the tenderloins, condiments, buns etc.. love them
Kelley H. - Lone Tree, CO
08/01/20
Delivery was as promised, pies tasted amazing and this time around my package came undamaged.
Gia S. - Niles, IL
08/17/20
Food was good as expected. This is a repeat order with Nick's. I will say . But ultimately the food was great, pork was just as good as the first time and we were happy.
Marianne C. - Hurdle Mills, NC
07/14/20
2 day delivery, excellent packaging, great taste, condiments safely unspillab!e !---like our peoria Illinois home town
Georgia G. - Baldwinsville, NY
06/30/20
Easy delivery. Quick, simple instructions. High quality food. Overall great experience.
Mike S. - Aldie, VA
07/21/20
Delivery was quick. Items packed to arrive fresh and cold. The pork tenderloin sandwiches are yummy. Very close to what he remembers as a kid in Illinois.
Rich R. - West Bloomfield, MI
06/24/20
Delivered on time, food was great and we had a fun time letting our friends get a taste of the huge Indiana tenderloins! It was like "back home again in Indiana."
elizabeth o. - Virginia Beach, VA
06/03/20
The breaded and flattened pork loins are tremendous. Can eat them in a sandwich, or as an entree with a side of your choice of vegetables.
Victor F. - Billerica, MA
06/02/20
The Hoosier pie was excellent! It was shipped exactly as specified! It was delicious! The best pie I have ever had! It came frozen and was the great!! I will definitely purchase again!!
Liz M. - Sparks, NV
05/26/20
I ordered the pork tenderloins for my sister’s birthday! It was delivered to Florida and arrived on time, well packaged with the amenities! I’m very happy and will use you again! Thanks you! P.S. my sister said the tenderloins were delicious!
Gwen K. - Sarasota, FL
05/07/20
Nick's Kitchen was amazing! Order went out on time and my 90 year old grandfather said the pie was yummy.
Richard B. - Panama City, FL
12/03/20
They are the best sandwiches. I've ordered them twice and plan on it again. Fast delivery.
trent l. - Byron, MN
04/11/21
Delivery was great, especially given how deliveries are going these days. Food was as great as it appeared it would be.
Dennis B. - Evergreen, CO
03/26/21
We love the pork from Nick's Kitchen. Price isn’t bad considering overnight perishable shipping cost.
Letta S. - Corona de Tucson, AZ
03/18/21
Loved the Pork Cutlet sandwiches from Nicks Kitchen!! Ordering was easy...on sale with free shipping was a plus!
Mary D. - Boston, MA
03/06/21
Pork tenderloin sandwiches were absolutely fantastic!!! What more could I say?
David C. - Los Lunas, NM
02/20/21
The food arrived in perfect condition and quickly. It brought a taste of Indiana to our son who moved to Texas
Brian D. - Austin, TX
02/19/21
Much to my surprise, buns were included along with ketchup, mustard, mayo, and the best pickles ever. Shipping was impressive.
ronda s. - Oxford, MI
01/30/21
Ordering was easy. Received and receivers were thrilled as breaded tenderloin is his favorite sandwich and can’t find it in Texas.
E.J. E. - San Antonio, TX
12/28/20
The food quality was excellent. It was delivered on time, and instructions made having a Hoosier Tenderloin sandwich easy and a special treat.
John M. - Hudson, FL
01/15/21
If you ask about the pie sent us, it was as delicious as any that we have had in person at Nick's. If you're asking about the one we sent, it arrived as promised. Ironically, both arrived the same day.
Kate T. - Hobart, IN
01/16/21
The pie arrived on time, in perfect condition, and the person I sent it to said it is delicious! Thanks!
Amy M. - Gillespie, IL
05/18/21
Quality was good. Packaging was excellent. I’m quite impressed!
Ann P. - Encinitas, CA
07/12/21
Everything was wonderful from ordering to delivery. The pork tenderloin sandwiches from Nick's Kitchen were just delicious. Actually the best tasting I've ever eaten and preparation was easy. Would not hesitate to order again. Go Nick's!
Julianne S. - Highlands Ranch, CO
07/04/21
Order was delivered on time and packed very well. Nick's tenderloin sandwiches are delicious! My husband and I grew-up in the Midwest, but now live out East. The sandwiches are just as we remember and a delicious treat from the Midwest!
Curtis P. - New Hartford, NY
06/27/21
Everything went well!!!! My Dad grew up in Indiana on breaded tenderloins and has now lived in Maryland for 56 years and never stops talking about Indiana breaded tenderloins. I found Nick's several years ago and sent him a gift package every Father's Day. To make it even better, my Dad grew up in Huntington, IN. Which is where Nick's is located and he remembers it fondly. Nick's, I am so happy I found you!!! He is extremely happy!!!
Carlton S. - Annapolis, MD
06/21/21
EVERYTHING...a totally perfect experience
janice p. - Bloomfield Hills, MI
06/19/21
It was a gift for a friend who was from Indiana they loved it!
Christopher L. - Desert Hot Springs, CA
06/18/21
The order was well packaged and both the pork tenderloins and the sugar cream pie were delicious. Will definitely order again!
CAROL T. - Morgantown, WV
05/29/21
Ordering was easy, tracking number provided quickly. Product arrived safe and cold.
Harold G. - Covina, CA
05/12/21
Delivered right on time and came in perfect condition. Delicious!!
Jan H. - Crestview, FL
05/10/21