Butter-ly Delicious - 6 Butters

(Customer Reviews)

Minerva Dairy ships its insanely delicious Amish butter nationwide on Goldbelly! For 125 years, Minerva Dairy has used cream from pasture-raised cows on American family farms to produce its award-winning and famous 85% butterfat butter. This Butter-ly Delicious 85% butterfat pack features Minerva Dairy’s Salted, Unsalted, and Garlic Herb butters.

Back in 1894, 21-year-old Max Radloff founded a dairy operation at Hustiford Creamery in Wisconsin. Throughout the early 1900s, he continually expanded his business before consolidating it to two—Hustiford, Wisconsin, and Minerva Dairy’s present location in Minerva, Ohio. For the last 120-plus years, Minerva Dairy, America’s oldest family-owned creamery, has relied on farm-fresh milk, old-fashioned churns, and wholesome ingredients to produce their award-winning cheeses and famous 85% Batch Churned Amish Butter. Today, fifth-generation siblings Adam Mueller and Venae Watts run the show, having worked at the dairy since they were 12. Their 12 kids are also beginning to learn the ropes.

More Details

This package serves 35-40 people and includes

  • 2 Salted Butters (8 oz. each) – 85% butterfat and churned by the batch using naturally-cultured cream. Minerva Dairy’s five-generation churning technique gives this butter its authentic thick texture.
  • 2 Garlic Herb Butters (8 oz. each) – Elevates the 85% butterfat butter with a blend of garlic and fresh herbs. Perfect as a potato topper!
  • 2 Unsalted Butters (8 oz. each ) – 85% butterfat and churned by the batch using naturally cultured cream. Minerva Dairy’s five-generation churning technique gives this butter its authentic thick texture.
  • Each item arrives individually sealed


Salted Amish Butter – Pasteurized Cream, Sea Salt
Garlic Butter – Pasteurized Cream, Lactic Acid, Garlic Powder, Parsley Flakes, Sea Salt
Amish Butter – Pasteurized Cream, Lactic Acid

Instructions / Storage

  • Butter ships with ice packs, may thaw during transit.
  • Upon arrival, store butter in the refrigerator or in the freezer.
  • Butter can be stored in the refrigerator up until the “best by” date or in the freezer for up to 1 year (to protect against freezer burn, use a ziploc or plastic bag for extra protection).

To Serve

  • If frozen, allow butter to thaw at room temperature.
  • Spread, serve, and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Minerva Dairy ships Monday through Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Ohio


Everything. I love the fact there are so many ways for me to get the items I love that are not available in my area. Thanks!
Tangela S. - Jamestown, NC
Everything. The experience. The products. The tracking and promptness. And the amazing wonderful customer service.
Amy H. - Pitcairn, PA
Excellent packing. Fast Shipping. Butter was still solid. But most of all it taste great! THANK YOU.
Diane C. - Foley, AL
The taste of Minerva’s Amish Butter is scrumptious. Creamy, rich but delicate flavor.
Cassandra B. - Woodland Park, CO
Awesome... could not have been better from ordering, paying, notification of shipment, delivery and best of all the product.
Diane c. - Foley, AL
I am so happy that I discovered your business. Especially in these times while I avoid the grocery store, it is the perfect addition to the vegetables I am able to grow organically and my homemade bread. Thanks so much!
Sylvia T. - Greenwood, AR
The order process was easy. Tracking information was very helpful. It was as described. I was happy with my purchase. It was packaged well, and delivered in a timely manner. It had informative directions. Besides, it is delicious!
Deborah E. - Jefferson, TX
Where else can you get high quality butter shipped to your home? So glad I found this resource in a time like this. Thank you.
Brice S. - Saint Johnsbury, VT
Delivery service was great, very fast. And the Butter is AWESOME.
Cindy M. - Swansea, SC
The quality of the product, speed of arrival and ease of placing the order were tops.
Jane M. - Northfield, MN
I ordered Minerva butter gift sets for 2 families. They were delivered quickly and the recipients love them.
Alex f. - Arlington, VA
So happy I came across this Company! This is Delicious Butter! Such a “Fresh” taste! Only using with my Home Baked breads, bagels etc. to enhance the “comfort” taste. Thank you!
Colleen C. - La Vista, NE
This is my third order for Minerva. The butter is so fresh and clean (no junk in it) that it is very likely that I will order from the again.
CARLA H. - Albuquerque, NM
Delivery was fast and the food was kept cold with high quality packaging. I have enjoyed what I had ordered as well as my family. I ordered this for each family member to receive something unique at Thanksgiving since I would not be able to be there. It was a wonderful experience and will definitely use this service again to share a memory with my family and friends.
Kylee E. - Johnstown, OH
The butter from Minerva is delicious! It arrived frozen and was very well packed. It will be my new favorite butter, I'm stoked!
CARLA H. - Albuquerque, NM
All good for this order. We received the three 2 lb. blocks of baker's butter unsalted. These are huge, delciously creamy, and fresh - great for sweet or savory dishes. Thank you!
Susann L. - Caswell, ME
Timely delivery. Packaged so well that my order did not defrost on the porch in the 92 degree Texas Christmas weather.
Thorne G. - Brady, TX
Everything went well. Excellent job on shipping and the product is wonderful. Love it!
Elrita L. - Baltimore, MD