Shoofly Pie

From Miller's Bakery (Customer Reviews)

Miller’s Bakery ships its famous Shoofly Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! Shoofly Pie (or Melassichriwwelkuche, for all of you Pennsylvania Dutch speakers out there) is a classic dessert dating back to 1876 when it was created in honor of the American Centennial. It all starts with a made-from-scratch rich and buttery flaky crust, molasses filling, and cinnamon-brown sugar topping. It’s a gooey, moist bottom pie made even more delicious with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Miller’s Bakery has been making some of the best scratch-made breads, pies, and cakes in Pennsylvania since 1929. Miller’s Bakery was born when Anna Miller started serving pies and basic meals to truckers while her husband fixed their rigs in his automotive shop. Her cooking was simple but delicious, and it wasn’t long before folks started coming by for the food instead of repairs! From these humble origins, Miller’s grew into a Lancaster County institution with a whole host of businesses, including a smorgasbord restaurant, a quilt shop, a winery, and a Bible museum. At its heart, though, Miller’s is still a simple scratch bakery, serving up Pennsylvania Dutch staples like shoofly pie in a dining room with views of working Amish farm fields.

More Details

This package serves 8-10 people and includes a 9" Shoofly Pie

  • Each pie weighs approximately 2.5 lbs.

Ingredients

Flour, Sugar, Shortening, Corn Syrup, Whole Egg, Milk Powder, Butter, Salt, Vanilla, Molasses, Water

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies arrive fresh and ready to enjoy!
  • Each pie may be stored at room temperature for up to 5 days
  • Pies may also be store refrigerated for up to 2 weeks, or frozen for up to 4 months
  • To Serve, Pies may be briefly warmed in a microwave and served with a scoop of ice cream
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Miller’s Bakery ships Tuesday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     

More from Pennsylvania

  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     

REVIEWS

Delivery was perfect. Bread is delicious
Lois B. - Port Washington, NY
04/19/21
Packed well. Product was even better than expected.
Pat E. - Florence, OR
04/13/21
Product (Hot Cross Buns) were spectacular! Thank you.
nikki S. - Hagerstown, MD
04/12/21
It was as advertised and tasted very good.
Diana S. - Durango, CO
04/08/21
The hot cross buns we ordered we’re excellent! Arrived like they were fresh out of the oven! Will definitely order from Goldbelly again!
Lori M. - Scottsdale, AZ
04/06/21
The package arrived exactly on-time, the hot cross buns were absolutely delicious.
Mark G. - Knoxville, TN
04/06/21
The Food came exactly when it was supposed to. The hot crossed buns were fresh and very delicious. Reminded us of Easters past, wonderful!
Katherine M. - Hillsboro, OR
04/06/21
The order went smoothly and delivery and the hit cross buns were so delicious
Alvin J. - Rochester, NY
04/06/21
Everything was easy from the ordering process to the delivery arriving when promised
Robert P. - Chagrin Falls, OH
04/05/21
The hot cross buns were absolutely delicious and made our Easter dinner perfect! We'll definitely be ordering again.
Lynda F. - Lakewood, CO
04/05/21
It arrived on time. My mother in law was thrilled with the gift.
Laura D. - Huntington, WV
04/05/21
Everything! Delivery, Exceptional dessert// order, Complimented greatly by recipient!
Dr. S. - Lusby, MD
04/05/21
The hot cross buns are DELICIOUS! I'm going to order a pizza next.
Mary S. - San Bruno, CA
04/04/21
Fresh, yummy. These remind me of the old fashioned ones my grandmother used to make
Karen R. - Owenton, KY
04/03/21
The shoofly pie that I ordered arrived on time and in good condition. I loved it. I live in Florida now. I previously lived near Amish country in Lancaster county, PA.
christine s. - Cape Canaveral, FL
04/03/21
Once shipped it came quickly and items received were outstanding
Stephanie L. - Tipp City, OH
04/03/21
The hot cross buns are so fresh and absolutely delicious. We love the little bottles of icing that came with them to squirt on the buns.
Susan P. - Nellysford, VA
03/27/21
Fabulous food and reminded my mom of her favorite treat growing up in Pennsylvania. Thank you!
Fredda M. - San Diego, CA
03/09/21
The Hot Cross Buns exceeded expectations!!!
Herb B. - De Pere, WI
03/27/21
Cinnamon Buns were awesome! Delivery on day that was desired :)
S. C. - Ann Arbor, MI
02/20/21
These sticky buns remind me of the ones my grandmother used to buy. They are so good full of raisins and everything about them is just perfect.
Karen R. - Owenton, KY
02/15/21
Shipment notifications as well as timeliness of shipping and shipping containers were all great! Food was great!
Melinda H. - New Vienna, OH
02/14/21
Cinnamon buns were great. Traditional Philly treat.
Lance S. - Vienna, VA
02/13/21
Everything ....from your packing to arriving on time to the deliciousness of the food ! Thank you ...we are grateful, and will be ordering from you again !
James N. - Waunakee, WI
01/30/21
Received very fresh and delicious pastries
Hilary G. - Princeton, NJ
05/18/21
These were gifts sent to relatives. They indicated that they immensely enjoyed the products. Fresh and tasty. Great way to learn about other foods in this country. The shoofly pie even came with a little sheet with some historical facts.
Marian K. - San Diego, CA
05/11/21
Great product delivered fresh and fast!
Kathy W. - Maple Grove, MN
05/10/21
Just like I was at Miller's except I could walk away and still move. Miss the smorgasbord but the shoe fly made it 2,200 mi and is being enjoyed. It was my 64th birthday cake.
Chuck S. - Sammamish, WA
04/27/21
I have placed at least five orders in the last year and I've been happy every time
Sandra D. - Sebastian, FL
04/26/21
Arrived on time. Fresh and VERY tasty!
Joe G. - Massena, NY
08/03/21
Package arrived on time. Tracking was accurate. Pie was packed well and in excellent condition.
Marylou B. - Lombard, IL
08/02/21
Product excellent. Delivery on schedule.
Anne F. - West Chester, PA
07/26/21
Products arrived on time and are absolutely delicious
Kathy S. - Somers, CT
07/20/21
The buns were fresh & delicious. Put 1 pkg in the freezer & kept the other in the refrigerator. Microwaved less than a minute to freshen up when I wanted one. I would not hesitate to purchase again. If you really like raisins you surely will love these buns.
Laurie G. - Schenectady, NY
07/13/21
shipped perfectly. My mom enjoyed her cinnamon rolls. I received communication throughout my ordering process. Always a great experience
Diane J. - Woodbury, NJ
07/18/21
Order arrived on time, fresh and tasty.
Chuck C. - Vacaville, CA
06/21/21
So so so delicious!!! So fresh and tasty
Jane S. - Gladstone, OR
06/06/21
Order arrived on time and product was a good as its description.
Paul A. - Tampa, FL
06/22/21