Michele’s Pies ships its famous Maple Pumpkin Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! There’s no canned pumpkin here, which is what we like right off the bat with this pie. Michele’s Pies purées fresh pumpkin and adds Vermont maple syrup and cream to give the filling a rich and creamy texture. Michele’s Pies then pours everything into a super flaky pie crust made using an old-fashioned recipe. On top is a generous layer of pecans dusted with brown sugar and cinnamon for the perfect crunch to this perfect pumpkin pie.

Every pie at Michele’s Pies is made by hand at Michele Stuart’s eponymous gourmet pie shop in Norwalk, Connecticut. Since opening in 2007, Michele’s Pies has won 33 National Pie Championship awards for pies like Chocolate Pecan Bourbon Pie, Apple Crumb Pie, and Maple Pumpkin Pie with Pecan Streusel. Whether the small Connecticut bakery’s team is steaming fresh pumpkins to go into their heavenly pumpkin pies, hand-crimping each pie crust, or sprinkling pie tops with roasted nuts and streusel, every Michele’s pie is perfect. Michele’s Pies have been featured on “Throwdown with Bobby Flay” and were featured in the 63rd Primetime Emmy Awards gift bags.

More Details

This package serves 8 people and includes a Maple Pumpkin Pie Streusel

  • Each pie measures 9"


Crust – Flour, Vegetable Shortening, Water, Salt.
Filling – Pumpkin, Heavy Cream, Maple Syrup, Eggs, Brown Sugar, Cinnamon, Nutmeg, Salt.
Streusel – Pecans, Brown Sugar, Butter, Flour, Cinnamon.

Instructions / Storage

  • Each pie ships frozen with an ice pack, may thaw in transit
  • Keep at room temperature overnight or in the refigerator for up to 4 days
  • Freeze for up to 2 weeks

To Serve

  • They are best served cold or at room temperature.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Pies ship Tuesday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Connecticut


This is the second time I've ordered this pie it is so good. I highly recommend it!
John S. - Atlantic City, NJ
Delivered on time, safely and beyond delicious.
Donna S. - Bogota, NJ
Dense, nice pie with good tasting top crumble crust.
Cindra K. - Livermore, CO
My wife was surprised and loved every bite!!
Calvin M. - Simpsonville, SC
Communication was good. One of the best pies I've ever had.
Joseph L. - Loudonville, NY
I bought this pie to help celebrate the birthday of a friend who considers pecan pie his absolute favorite. He, and everyone else, loved it. Outstanding product.
David L. - Placitas, NM
The pies were delicious and shipped perfectly protected.
Justin C. - Beaver Dams, NY
Got apple pie with a crumb topping. I loved it - as did everyone in the family. We shared and had enough pie for dessert for two nights.
Stephanie B. - San Luis Obispo, CA
F’n amazing pie!!!!!!
Paul W. - Highland Park, IL
Excellent flavor and texture. Would buy again!
Cecilia B. - Russellville, AR
It was incredibly delicious !! Even friends who tried it were absolutely wowed by this dessert!
Kristin B. - Glen Ellyn, IL
Everything was packed great!!!! Pies were fresh and delicious. Directions for heating the pies was clear and easy to follow.
Catalina P. - Brooklyn, NY
Pie was delicious.
June B. - Sheridan, WY
On time delivery and worthy product! My husband was delighted we had top scale dessert three nights in a row.
JD D. - State College, PA
The Apple pie, sent as a gift was reported to be the best ever eaten!
Arturo V. - New York, NY
That pie was awesome. Packaged well, arrived in mint condition. Easy to prepare and it was still delicious a week later.
Chris B. - Belmont, CA
Everything. Michele's pies are incredible. The pie arrived in excellent condition ready to eat. :)
nicholas c. - Calera, OK
Michele’s strawberry-rhubarb pie was one of the best pies that I have ever eaten.
MICHAEL L. - Delray Beach, FL
The pie was delicious!
Kellie S. - Silver Spring, MD
Process was smooth, pie was as advertised (choc pecan bourbon) and delivery was prompt. The pie arrived safely, well packaged and my parents and their friends said it was delicious!
George K. - Mount Arlington, NJ
Fast delivery and the pies arrived in good shape and we ate thee Butterscotch Pecan Pie and it was delicious.
Carolyn W. - Shenandoah Junction, WV
The pie arrived on time and was absolutely delicious my girlfriend says it was the best pie she's ever had in her entire life. We will definitely be ordering another one thank you Goldbelly and Michele's Pies.
Michael B. - Stateline, NV
Pecan chocolate bourbon pie was delicious. Packed well. Fresh. Delivered quickly. Communication on delivery status was great.
Shelley G. - Golden, CO
easy to order. order arrived as scheduled. food (pie) was excellent.
Justin O. - Boston, MA
Product arrived in excellent condition with superb packaging. Food was of highest quality for taste and freshness!! So Yummy!!
Cynthia H. - Black Mountain, NC
It was a gift, arrived on time in perfect condition. Yummy !
David T. - Erie, CO
Great experience. I ordered multiple gifts. I was informed the pies were all delicious and they delivered in time for the holiday.
Monica C. - Malverne, NY
the food you sell is perfect. Comes frozen with instructions that are easy to follow. The Food is super good and always a treat.
sue T. - Gainesville, FL
Good food, quick shipping and delivery. Great taste
Stephanie B. - San Luis Obispo, CA
The delivery time and the food was excellent.
Kimani H. - San Antonio, TX
Arrived early. From what the recipient said, it was amazing.
John T. - Buffalo, OK
timely delivery and a very good product
Madeline H. - Dallas, TX
Delivery 🚚 was good and timely It was delicious
Sandra S. - Berkley, MA
The pie’s were still cold from the ice packs!
Chase B. - Dallas, TX
Apple pie was delicious.
Gail C. - Palm Desert, CA
All great!
Tannis W. - Spokane, WA
The pie was delicious and the bakery was wonderful.
Anne G. - Dunwoody, GA
Jennifer N. - New York, NY
The pie was amazing and delivery was perfect!
Yvette D. - Irvine, CA
Great product as always! The ease of ordering, secure packaging of item & shipping all well done.
Lisa B. - Bonita Springs, FL
They loved the chocolate bourbon pecan pie. Will order again.
Peter B. - Oakland, CA
Terrific pie...well packaged. delivered on time.
John C. - Southern Pines, NC
Good quality. Accurate description On time delivery
Brooke B. - Edmond, OK
Quick timely delivery and easy to order. The recipients say that the pie looks scrumptious. Instructions for saving it were clear and doable. Nice surprise to also get a discount.
Anne C. - Allen, TX
The ordering process and delivery was exactly what was stated. Product arrived in good condition.
Janet E. - Delray Beach, FL
Delivered on time and in great shape. Packaged well and still cold.
Jaya N. - Boca Raton, FL
Loved the Bourbon chocolate pecan pie and delivered on time. Next year I’ll send two!
Kimberly M. - Kinnelon, NJ
Everything went perfect and my grandson said it was the best pie he's ever had.
Dylan H. - Buffalo, NY
Delivery was on time and Pie was delicious.
Corazon G. - Englewood, NJ
We gave it as a gift and they loved it!
Nate L. - Brooklyn, NY
Food was delicious and customer service was exceptional.
Steve D. - Visalia, CA
Ordering was a breeze. Getting the package on the day expected was awesome!
Carissa W. - Green Valley, AZ
Delivery, pie condition perfect, taste incredible.
Sandra Q. - Studio City, CA
Quality of the pie was outstanding.
Mike W. - Plant City, FL
Shipping was perfect the pie was perfect.
Judy S. - Bethel Park, PA
The pie was delicious!!! Package arrived at the perfect temperature still cool almost frozen and packaged very well
Maya A. - Miami, FL
Easy to order. Delivered on time. Tasted great!!!
Keith W. - Carlisle, PA
Pie was delicious !!!
Paul B. - Lafayette, LA
Good Pie.
Linda N. - Laurel, MD
This pie was delicious!
Christine S. - Santa Barbara, CA
It was great, everything went well. I will be ordering again from you.
LINDA F. - Columbus, OH
Communication from Goldbelly. Prompt delivery.
Linda D. - Topeka, KS
Everything was great!
Lisa S. - Amherst, MA