Mac Pie - Choose Your Own 2 Pack

Mac Pie ships its famous Mac Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! Each mac pie is made with macadamia nuts, Maui raw sugar, fresh Hawaiian eggs, local creamery butter, pure double fold vanilla, and a light dusting of macaroon coconut, cradled in a crave-worthy macadamia nut crust. With the Choose Your Own 2 Pack, you’ll receive your pick of two 8" mac pies in your favorite flavors.

When Sheila Everitt’s friends tasted her delicious macadamia nut pie, they insisted that she drop everything and go into the pie business. Reluctantly, she started catering small parties in her hometown of Kona, Hawaii. Word spread about her signature Mac Pies, a twist on her grandmother’s traditional Southern chess pies, and before long, Sheila was baking around the clock, supplying famous Big Island hotels and restaurants with her handmade dessert sensations. In 1996, she opened a shop in Kona, and Mac Pie was born. Food Network has declared Mac Pie "Hawaii’s Best Pie.”

More Details

This package serves 12-20 people and includes your choice of 2 Mac Pies

  • Each Mac Pie measures 8" and serves 6-10

Flavor Options Include

  • Original Vanilla Mac Pie
  • Original Vanilla Mac Pie with Chocolate Chips
  • Coconut Mac Pie
  • Coconut Mac Pie with Chocolate Chips
  • Kona Coffee Mac Pie
  • Kona Coffee Mac Pie with Chocolate Chips
  • Butterscotch Mac Pie

Instructions / Storage

  • Mac Pie arrives ready to serve. Remove packaging, slice, and enjoy!
  • For neater slices, try chilling the pie before slicing.
  • Pie can be eaten chilled or at room temp.
  • Can be stored in a sealed container at room temperature for 7 days, or in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.
  • Can be frozen immediately in original packaging for up to 1 year.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Hawaii


Everything! Packed & shipped perfectly. Both pies are absolutely delicious!
Audrea L. - Eden Prairie, MN
Everything was amazing! I'm new to goldbelly and I love it!!
deborah m. - Pawtucket, RI
The choices are great, and all the food arrived in great condition.
Tommy T. - Philadelphia, PA
The delivery was great, all the way from Hawaii to Ohio!
Angela P. - Gahanna, OH
Good product choices, product was available, product arrived at the right time.
Matt s. - Somerville, MA
Pie was yummy and arrived in good condition.
Crystal C. - Princeville, HI
Pie tasted great and follow ups on eta was tops
Vince F. - Woodway, TX
The delivery wasn't perfect. Love Mac Pie.
Ana S. - Bronx, NY
Package arrived in tact. Receiver was very happy with the packaging .
Crystal B. - Henderson, NV
Arrived on time and was delish!
JULIE S. - Northglenn, CO
The macadamia pie, was amazing! Can’t wait to try the coconut version.
Tom E. - Wilmington, NC
Delivery right on time! Fantastic surprise for my brothers holiday dinner.
Joseph D. - Temple, TX
Great pies from Hawaii!!
Paul K. - Latham, NY
Order process was very smooth and product delivered as promised.
Michael E. - Portland, OR
Great gift!
Walt A. - Fern Park, FL
Thank you for shipping to Alaska!
Jane A. - Anchorage, AK
Was very easy and simple to order considering this was my first time. Great communication every step of the way.
Kurt L. - Honolulu, HI