New York Pizza Best Seller - 2 Pack

Joe’s Pizza ships its New York Pizza nationwide on Goldbelly! Joe’s Pizza is the authentic New York pizza beloved by native New Yorkers and visitors alike. These beautiful pizzas feature that classic New York-style ultra-thin crust that folds perfectly in one hand. Joe’s cheese pizza is naked, yet oh so delicious, just as nature intended. Joe’s pepperoni pizza is topped with spicy pepperoni made for meat lovers.

After immigrating to the US from Naples, Italy, the birthplace of pizza, Pino “Joe” Pozzuoli opened a little pizza joint in New York. Since its opening in 1975, Joe’s Pizza has become a Greenwich Village institution. Joe’s Pizza serves the quintessential New York street slice (GQ Magazine listed Joe’s Pizza as one the "Best 25 Pizzas on Earth”). Joe’s Pizza is the real deal.

More Details

This package serves 4-6 people and includes:

  • 1 Cheese Pizza
  • 1 Pepperoni Pizza
  • Each pizza is 14" and serves 2-3 people

This product is not eligible for discounts or promotions, unless otherwise noted. Also, it cannot be purchased with promotional gift cards or referral credits.


Mozzarella cheese, Italian Tomatoes, EVO, Bakers Flour, Yeast, Pepperoni

Instructions / Storage

  • Pizzas are handmade-to-order and promptly frozen.
  • Although each box is carefully packed with dry ice and shipped immediately, it is normal for the pizza to partially or fully thaw in-transit.
  • Upon arrival, place pizza in the freezer. Do not removed pizza from vacuum sealed bag. Do not thaw.

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 425 degrees
  • Remove pie from freezer and discard bag (reserve cardboard tray for cutting the pizza after heating if you want)
  • Do not let pie thaw for more than 7-10 minutes prior to placing in the oven, it should still feel pretty frozen when it goes in.
  • Heat 1 pie at a time by placing directly on middle rack (lower rack for extra crispy) and baking for 10-13 minutes or until cheese is bubbling all around.
  • Enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Joe’s Pizza ships Monday – Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


The shipment coming on time!! It was my sisters birthday and last year we were in NY so this year I wanted to bring NY to us. We planned on dinner at 3pm and the package arrived @ noon!!!!!!!!!!
BRIDGET H. - Sacramento, CA
the entire experience. Enjoyed choosing the product, then delivery was as promised and frozen pizza was in great condition. Best part was enjoying the pizza with friends.
Louise M. - Bradenton, FL
Great pizza! Baked fast and easy. Great sauce, chewy crust. A real treat.
Linda O. - Portland, OR
Wow. Pizza was awesome . I’m ordering again
Art L. - Palmdale, CA
Package arrived on time and still frozen. Also chatted to an associate just to be sure it would be on time and she was awesome, assured me it would be and it made me and my wife's day. Wish I could remember her name...but she was awesome.
Eric E. - Hilliard, OH
Easy order process. Delivery and packaging was amazing! Orders were gifts and the complements were outstanding!
Jenn I. - Tampa, FL
Arrived on time, with great preparation instructions. The recipient recognized right away that this wasn't just any birthday dinner of NY-style Pizza he'd been jonesing for, it was from the place we last dined with his late uncle. His co-workers appreciated that I thought to do this and had a way to do it (maybe they will also turn into goldbelly customers?).
Howie R. - Woburn, MA
The quality of the food ordered, the care taken by the businesses in their packaging. The shipping being exactly as projected and arriving on time in spite of it being a very busy time of year.
Gina C. - Marietta, GA
My boyfriend is originally from Philly and relocated to CA for his job. He's been missing home recently, so I ordered him some NY pizza to lift his spirits. Ordered it to get here December 23rd as one of his Christmas presents. I was a little worried about the Christmas postal rush, but it got here ON TIME. I was so happy! Not only was delivery excellent, but he LOVED it! Said he can tell it's authentic NY pizza. We will definitely be ordering again. Thanks Joe's Pizza!
Laura R. - Elk Grove, CA
Awesome experience of shipping a item all the way to hawaii. We had doubts it might be thawing out by the time we got it but that wasnt the case. There was even still some dry ice left in the bottom of the container and the pizzas were very frozen.
Matthew H. - Kahului, HI
Everything went well. Pizzas arrived perfectly frozen and cooked up just like I was at Joe's. I said, "Ah, there's that New York taste I've been missing so much."
Patricia T. - Mason, OH
Received in excellent condition and tasted great!
Jon K. - Corydon, IN
Pleased with the March Munch Madness Contest and the promotions. This was my third time ordering through Goldbelly, and delivery arrived as promised on the date chosen. The pizza was packed with dry ice and still frozen when it arrived to me in S. Florida. Reheating instructions were accurate.
Erika B. - Pembroke Pines, FL
Everything! On time and tasty...what more can you ask. I have 2 tenants from NY and a friend from NJ (I’m from NJ also) that has been in our Covid bubble. We all got our 2nd shot recently, so to celebrate I ordered the NY pizza from Joe’s (which my tenants had eaten many times when living in NY) and we all reminisced about all the food we missed from the East Coast! It was a great dinner! Wish we could get a pizza here in Hawaii that was even close to EC pizza, but alas not so much.
Jill G. - Paia, HI
I appreciate the updates for delivery. The pizzas arrived still frozen, which made me happy. We enjoyed one the very day we received it.
Roxanne T. - Tampa, FL
Pizzas were delivered in timely fashion and well-packaged.
James B. - Culver City, CA
I got to sample New York Style pizza, which was very good.
Mark E. - Monona, WI
Pizza was still frozen, even though the dry ice had melted.
Dorothy O. - Marysville, WA
Best pizza ever! Cross that off the pizza list. Loved the crust!
Joanie B. - Faison, NC
The packaging was superb! The service, the quality of the food... exceeded my expectations.
Patti L. - Indio, CA
It all went well. The pizzas arrived on time and frozen as they were suppose to be. Really great experience all around.
Ben L. - Paris, KY
Packaged extremely well and arrived right on time! Pizza directions easy to follow and we were really impressed!
Laura J. - Tempe, AZ
Pizza was delivered in great condition.
Lacey S. - Saint Louis, MO
The food was great!!
Nelida W. - Dallas, TX
Delivered when promised and in perfect condition.
Michael S. - Bradenton, FL
Delivered as your estimated date.
Merle R. - Norristown, PA
How easy it was to use the site, find what I wanted, and the checkout process was quick! In this crazy time we are living in it brings a fun date night home to be safe!
Justin B. - Columbia, MO
Great pizza. I ordered it as soon as available.
Marc Z. - El Paso, TX
Great experience delivered prompt even to the Florida keys
jena S. - Summerland Key, FL
Delivery was perfect timing
James C. - Cedar Bluff, AL
Everything! Great pizza and fun experience!
Melita R. - Oakes, ND
Pizza was wonderful
Mary F. - Neenah, WI
Family loved the food!
Laurie A. - San Diego, CA
Delivery was flawless. The pizza was delicious!
Alex c. - Mount Pleasant, SC
Ordering ,delivery and loved Joe 's Pizza
Karen P. - Huntington Beach, CA
Ordering was easy, my pizzas got delivered when promised and packaging was perfect!!!
Helena M. - Ventura, CA
Everything went well! So easy to order and so easy to eat!! :)
Tim S. - Edinburg, TX
It was good to order from Joe's Pizza again.
Rhonda E. - El Paso, TX
Delivery and food
Bruce B. - Doylestown, OH
Glad to see Joe’s Pizza back, please bring back those legendary Sicilian pizzas!
Marchelle D. - Carmichael, CA
Not Much.
Wil B. - Piscataway, NJ
Ease of ordering, taste of food
Daniel O. - Smithfield, VA
I was told the pizza was very good
Thomas B. - Louisville, OH
Product is awesome.
Cathy C. - Lake Oswego, OR
It cooked well!
Sandra R. - Milwaukee, WI