Choose Your Own Fruit Pie - 2 Pack

Grand Traverse Pie Company ships its pies nationwide on Goldbelly! While most people have their eyes set on Grand Traverse Pie Company’s award-winning Michigan Cherry Pies, you really can’t go wrong with any single one of their pies. Now you can try two of these amazing pies in flavors of your choice!

Since 1996, Grand Traverse Pie Co. has been baking up some of the best pies in the U.S. It was founded by Mike and Denise Busley, who hand-roll pie dough to create their signature fruit pies like Cherry Crumb Pie, which is loaded with Northern Michigan Montmorency cherries and has a bubbling ring of berry juice around the crust. Grand Traverse Pie Company has been lauded in Country Living as well as Oprah’s “O” Magazine.

More Details

This package serves 18-20 people and includes 2 Fruit Pies, your chioce

  • Each pie serves 8-10 people and measures 9"

Fruit Pie Options Include

  • Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb
  • Old Mission Cherry
  • Wayne Hill Cherry Ganache
  • West Bay Blueberry Crumb
  • Suttons Bay Blueberry
  • North Bar Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb
  • Fire House Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Peninsula Apple Crumb
  • Key Lime
  • Front Street Apple
  • Michigan ABC: Apples, Blueberries, & Cherries
  • Northport Pumpkin


May Contain: Dairy, Gluten, and Nuts

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies ship frozen without ice packs, may thaw during transit.
  • Upon arrival, place pie at room temperature or in the freezer.
  • Pies last up to 3 days at room temperature or up to 2 months in the freezer, do not refrigerate.
  • Pies can be served at room temperature or warmed.
  • Allow pies to thaw at room temperature for at least 8 hours before serving.

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 225ºF.
  • Remove pie from box and bake for 20-30 minutes.
  • Remove from oven, slice, and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Grand Traverse Pie Company ships Monday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for * Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Michigan


I just had to write and give Major Kudos to the Grand Traverse Pie Company for the superb packaging in which our cheesecake was shipped. My husband and I have ordered food from all over the country, and we have never had anything arrive in such PERFECT condition!!  It is GORGEOUS and we can't wait to serve it to our guests. Please thank the Grand Traverse Pie Company for us and tell them we will definitely be ordering some of their baked goods again soon.
Wendy M. - Irvine, CA
Delicious pies and efficient, convenient delivery!
Jillian M. - Toluca Lake, CA
Mom in law LOVED her gluten free pies! Delicious!
Wendy C. - Bokeelia, FL
Pie was fresh. Loved crust and peanut butter.
Patricia R. - West Hempstead, NY
Very good. It was a little more tart than I like, but it was good.
Chris T. - Fredericktown, MO
Excellent! Food was amazing!! One of my orders didn’t come when expected but your Customer Service person was wonderful and prompt with a response and it came on Friday. It was definitely worth the wait!
Justin S. - Rochester, MN
Everybody loved it. Michigan packaging made me homesick as well.
Jeff K. - West Hollywood, CA
Cherry and blueberry pies were amazing...our new holiday tradition!
Laura C. - The Colony, TX
Bought for a friend that eats gluten free she said it was great!!!
Kim L. - Hilmar, CA
The apple and cherry pies were delectable!
Edward K. - Conway, AR
The Grand Traverse Pie Company has excellent fruit pies - on time every time I’ve ordered and the best crust ever.
Cindy S. - Abilene, TX
The pie was very easy to order and my sister in law loved it!!
Laura R. - Hubbard, IA
Grand Traverse Pie Company pies are fantastic - great taste and of the expected size. Packaged beautifully to prevent them from breakage during the shipment process.
Patrica S. - Metairie, LA
Really delicious cherry pie with a buttery and flaky crust!
Tu T. - Raleigh, NC
This was such an amazing pie! Arrived fresh and perfectly packaged. Everything about this pie worked....flaky crust, tart cherries and a delicious crumb topping. It’s amazing how quickly two people can go through one pie. We need another!
Karin C. - Clayton, CA
Pies were delicious!!! And arrived well packed.....very happy as were a birthday gift for my husband
Sandee H. - Sandy, UT
The pie arrived looking amazing! My husband said it was the best cherry pie he has ever had!
Robyn N. - Burbank, CA
We ordered 6 pies for our Wedding dinner. They looked beautiful when they were delivered and tasted amazing!! Everyone loved them.
Btenda m. - San Diego, CA
The order process, tracking, and delivery was exactly what I expected. very good service and nice selection.
RICHARD G. - Lockport, NY
Cherry and Strawberry Rhubarb pies were delicious. Felt like I was in Traverse City.
Charles J. - Homewood, IL
Delivery was “spot on” and the vendors/ product excellent in taste, packaging, and prep instruction so
Elizabeth S. - Murrells Inlet, SC
Reasonable price, timely delivery, and the recipient loved the cherry pie.
Leighton M. - Houston, TX
Wonderful selections if tempting and tantalizing treats to choose from. Quality foods and service.
Stefanie D. - West Fargo, ND
Delivery was right on time! The pie, I was told was Delicious!! Cant go wrong with a Strawberry Rhubarb! Just like grama use to make! Thank you!!
Patrick A. - Ridgway, IL
Great communication. I ordered three times...two successful and one was delayed. It was not a big issue as there was a great deal of communication in regards to shipping delays.
Kimberly A. - Rock Hill, SC
There was an error in shipping and food was ruined. Customer service helped right away and got a new order out ASAP.
Alissa C. - Collegeville, PA
RUTH A. - Forest Lake, MN
This blueberry crumble pie arrived when promised. We baked it according to the instructions. It was gone in one day.
Marie L. - Tucson, AZ
On time delivery. Best pie I've ever had! I will order it again and I'll try other flavors from this company.
Peggy S. - Bellevue, WA
Pie was great. Delivered exactly as the attacking information stated. Friends raved about the pie. Good job.
Kevin O. - San Jacinto, CA
After placing the order, I realized it needed to be rerouted. GoldBelly Customer Service promptly, graciously, and accurately rerouted the package. The recipient absolutely loved the pie - "best ever!"
Joan M. - Needham, MA
It went very well from ordering to delivery. The pie was delicious. First time ordering & I would recommend ordering again.
Marilyn H. - Mount Airy, MD
Both the purchase process and the condition of the products was excellent. The products were carefully packed and in great condition upon arrival. The shipment was fast to prevent any problems with the food, and a QR code was included to provide storage and preparation instructions with ease. Well done.
David W. - Las Vegas, NV
On time delivery & one of the best strawberry- rhubarb pies I've had. Yummy!
Marianne B. - Visalia, CA
Howard B. - Surfside Beach, SC
Taste, presentation, timeliness all perfection. Can’t wait to get the lobster rolls!
Betty B. - San Antonio, TX
The pie arrived on time as promised. My niece loved it. I have recommended you to my neighbor and she ordered something for her Dad for Father's Day.
Leah B. - Centreville, VA
Pie was delicious and packaged well, will order from this pie place again!
Karen K. - Bay Point, CA
Delivered on time and DELICIOUS!
Joe B. - Maplewood, NJ