Choose Your Own Jumbo Cookies - 6 Pack

Arrives after Halloween

Gooey on the Inside ships its decadent cookies nationwide on Goldbelly! Take your pick from six best-selling Gooey on the Inside cookies: Chocolate Chip Chunk, Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter, Churro & Nutella, Cuppa Joe Exotic, and Dunkaroo. Just pop these big guys into the oven for that fresh-baked gooeyness!

Gooey on the Inside started off in the tiny kitchen of Kafi Dublin’s New York apartment. Crispy on the outside and (literally!) gooey on the inside, these perfectly baked cookies will bring you back to your childhood.

More Details

This package serves 10-12 people and includes 6 Jumbo Cookies, your choice

  • Each cookie serves 1-2 people
  • Each cookie measures 3" and weighs approx. 5.5 oz
  • Cookies are made to order and packed in a resealable bag

Cookie Flavor Options Include:

  • Chocolate Chip Chunk – Chewy Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.
  • Birthday Cake – Now it can be your birthday every day! This birthday cake cookie includes imported French white chocolate chunks, real pieces of birthday cake, and colorful sprinkles. You’ll enjoy every last bite.
  • Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter – Peanut butter chips, rich dark, and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.
  • Churro & Nutella – White Chocolate, Cinnamon cookie with Nutella filling.
  • Cuppa Joe Exotic – Dark Chocolate Espresso cookie with Caramel.
  • Dunkaroo – White chocolate cookie with graham crackers crumbs vanilla frosting and vanilla frosting.
  • Biscoff & Cream – Golden white chocolate cookies filled with Biscoff spread, topped with caramel buttercream and Biscoff crumbs.
  • Chocolate Dunkaroo – Milk chocolate cookies with graham cracker crumbs, and decadent chocolate frosting.
  • Bueno Bueno – Cookies with hazelnut cream filling, milk & dark chocolate, and kinder Bueno pieces.
  • Straight Out of Chocoton – Triple dark chocolate-glazed cookies, topped with chocolate crumbs.

All Flavors Subject to Availability

Ingredients

  • Chocolate Chip Chunk: Bread Flour, Brown Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Semisweet Chocolate Chips, Milk Chocolate Chips, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract
  • Birthday Cake: Bread Flour, Granulated Sugar, Butter, Eggs, White Chocolate, Rainbow Sprinkles, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract
  • Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter: Bread Flour, Brown Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Semisweet Chocolate Chips, Milk Chocolate Chips, Peanut Butter Chips, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract
  • Dunkaroo: Bread Flour, Fine granulated Sugar, Butter, Eggs, White Chocolate, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract, Egg Whites, Vanilla frosting, graham crackers and rainbow sprinkles
  • Cuppa Joe Exotic: Bread Flour, Fine granulated Sugar, Brown sugar, Butter, Eggs, Dark Chocolate, Milk Chocolate, Coffee, Caramel, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract,
  • Churro & Nutella: Bread Flour, Fine granulated Sugar, Brown sugar, Butter, Eggs, White Chocolate, Nutella, Cinnamon, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract
  • Biscoff & Cream: Bread Flour, Fine Granulated Sugar, Brown sugar, Butter, Eggs, White Chocolate, Biscoff, Caramel, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract.
  • Chocolate Dunkaroo: Bread Flour, Fine Graulated Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Milk Chocolate, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract, Egg Whites, Chocolate Frosting, Graham Crackers And Rainbow Sprinkles
  • Bueno Bueno: Bread Flour, Fine Granulated Sugar, Brown sugar, Butter, Eggs, Dark Chocolate, Milk Chocolate, Hazelnut Chocolate Pieces, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract.
  • Straight Out of Chocoton – Bread Flour, Fine Granulated Sugar, Brown Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Semi-Sweet Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, 80% Dark Chocolate, Salt, Cornstarch, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Natural Vanilla Extract.

Instructions / Storage

  • Cookies arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, store cookies at room temperature or in the freezer.
  • Cookies last up to 3 days at room temperature or up to 3 months in the freezer.
  • Cookies may be reheated if desired (recommended).

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 350°F.
  • Remove cookies from packaging and heat in oven for 5-7 minutes or until warmed through and gooey.
  • Remove from oven and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Gooey on the Inside ships Monday through Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

REVIEWS

All of it was great. Great price for amazing cookies!
Orlando R. - Bristol, CT
11/05/19
Very high quality ingredients and extremely moist. Just what one would look for in a decadent chocolate chip cookie. I'm a fan!
Orlando M. - Buford, GA
10/22/19
Exactly as described. Only way I like a cookie
Robert S. - Jamesburg, NJ
01/22/20
Delicious! I love these cookies and they taste like fresh baked cookies after cooking them in the oven.
Jessica H. - Fairmont, WV
12/12/19
The perfect gift. Our son loves chocolate chip cookies and we were able to ship him some great ones for his birthday!
Jude O. - Orlando, FL
03/05/20
My gift was a true success!...Birthday gift for the Aunt that has everything...delivered on her birthday...she ate a whole cookie and shared a bite with her dog, Lola! Excellent...5 inches in diameter and 2 inches thick...she loved it!
Lillian B. - Marianna, PA
03/15/20
The packaging was done perfectly. And the fact that they were par cooked to maintain the texture of the cookies was a great idea. The birthday cake and dunkaroo cookies were absolutely amazing. I wish I got more!
Tammy S. - Dunkirk, NY
01/24/21
I ordered one of each and they were all fantastic. They should be the only cookies sold on this site.
Jason F. - Doylestown, PA
02/25/21
Everything, great selection and the birthday gift that I purchased was/still is fantastic. I will order through Goldbelly again.
Andrea S. - Woonsocket, RI
02/26/21
Fast timely shipping. My mom received her order on the delivery date chosen at checkout and she loved the cookies!
Cynthia P. - Decatur, IL
02/20/21
Everything was perfect. Easy ordering, on time shipping and the cookies were delicious!!
Alexandra B. - Slippery Rock, PA
02/20/21
The site is GREAT. The pictures are very appealing and the site navigation is simple and fun. Over and over I've been drawn to the site to browse.
Amy F. - Rogers, AR
01/16/21
Delivery was on time (even during a snowstorm). The cookies were fresh and yummy. I like the clear descriptions for everything.
Pat H. - Arcadia, FL
12/24/20
I am impressed and amazed at the shipping process! I ordered Pikes Place Chowder and it was amazing as always. I also ordered cookies from Gooey on the Inside. 🎶 Amazing! 🎶 Will be using Goldbelly from now on to try all the delicious foods I dont have access to locally.
Keri W. - Vail, AZ
12/22/20
Fabulous products and great pictures and explanations! So easy to search and purchase. Best of all, everything I have purchased has been delicious! Thank you!!
Rebecca R. - Suwanee, GA
12/10/20
Finding a perfect gift was easy. Order process was straightforward and email notification to the recipient was very useful. Arrived a day earlier than estimated and in perfect condition. We were told they were delicious!
James M. - Brentwood, CA
12/23/20
The order was received on time, instructions for reheating were clear and accurate, boxing and contents were not damaged and company content (business cards, instructions, etc) were relevant and helpful.
Rae W. - Tallahassee, FL
04/05/21
Delicious cookies! Tasty, and they arrived early!
Ariya M. - The Colony, TX
04/11/21
Faster delivery than most in a pandemic.
Hepburn J. - Sherman Oaks, CA
01/22/21
Delivery was great. Even when it was going to be late we were asked when would we like to reschedule.
Shirleen L. - Hercules, CA
01/08/21
Sent these cookies as a birthday gift and she absolutely loved them!
Trinity C. - Louisville, KY
03/20/21
Delicious Gooey on the Inside Cookies! Arrive individually packed and on time and very cold!
Pat A. - Nevada City, CA
07/25/21
Food arrived on time, easy and clear instructions for prep.
Michael K. - Salem, OR
07/23/21
It was easy to find what I wanted and place the order. It arrived quickly & tasted great!
Heidi B. - Taylor, TX
07/19/21
Food was delivered as promised. Food was excellent! Ordering was easy and there were so many great options to choose from.
Stephanie B. - Bradenton, FL
07/18/21
I bought these for my 6th anniversary and my wife loved them!! I most definitely will be buying from you again!
kevin b. - Suffolk, VA
07/12/21
Cookies arrived on time, in good condition, and were delicious!
Jon S. - Irvine, CA
07/11/21
Delivery, packaging, instructions Food delicious...
Sandra W. - Palo Alto, CA
06/28/21
These are phenomenal! The perfect gift idea!
Matt J. - Woodstock, GA
06/20/21
The order placement, shipping experience, and quality of the food!
Chanel F. - Saint Cloud, FL
06/08/21
Easily found what I was looking for and delivery was on time. Bought as a gift and they gave the items rave reviews.
Barry B. - Magnolia, TX
05/31/21
Everything. Easy to search, easy to purchase, items sent as stated.
Anna W. - Silverdale, WA
05/30/21
1. Quick and easy to order 2. When I had to make a change, I received an email within 24hrs accommodating my request. Very nice!
Chris F. - Norfolk, VA
05/23/21
Delivered on time and the recipient loved your cookies
Dan T. - Fort Collins, CO
04/19/21
Great experience all around. Order was not only on time but a day before expected. Best cookies ever!! Soft, fresh, and great tasting. Excellent experience all around. Highly satisfied.
Leigh S. - Mc Dermott, OH
09/19/21
Order was delicious and came faster than expected
Lauren M. - Boardman, OH
08/13/21