Mini Pink and White Cookies

This product is currently sold out.

If you didn’t grow up in New York, chances are you’ve never tasted the cake-like texture topped with matching half moons of dark chocolate and vanilla icing. The black and white cookie is, in fact, not a cookie but a flat, thinly frosted cake. Made especially for Valentine’s Day, these pink and white mini cookies are just like their big brother, only slightly smaller.

More Details

  • Each package includes 18 mini pink and white cookies
  • Each cookie is approximately 2 inches in diameter

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Cookies ship Monday-Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for overnight shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from New York


The cookies were thick, soft and tasty!! The frosting was smooth and flavorful. They were sweet, but not too sweet. My entire family loved them!
Carla Q. - Union, SC
I received the cookies the packaging was well packed. Cookies are wonderful.
Kimberly M. - Citrus Heights, CA
The gift to my son was fresh and perfect!! I made black and white cookies for years( born and bred New Yorker) !! My son lives in the PNW so this gift was a terrific find!!!
Levi H. - Milwaukie, OR
Speedy delivery, product was fresh and delicious and was exactly as described with the taste.
Louis K. - Flower Mound, TX
The cookies were packaged perfect. Fresh. Couldn’t be more satisfied.
Carol P. - De Kalb, MS
Delivered fresh and sooo good. The black and white cookies were so thick, it was almost a cake. Will definitely order these again for gifts.
Michelle K. - Chillicothe, MO
Arrived well packed and very fresh! Delicious- gluten free treats!!!
Sara T. - Fairfield, CT
There was no doubt the cookies were baked fresh and shipped. My dad is from Paterson, NJ and was talking about the things he missed about “home”. These cookies made him grin and brought back a flood of memories from childhood. Would order again! Thanks!!!
Robert C. - Virginia Beach, VA
Outstanding Black and White cookies! I haven't had them in over 40 years. Difficult to share with my NYC friends here in California, but after they pinned me to the floor I had no choice but to share! I can't say enough about how good they were!
Thomas M. - Chula Vista, CA
The cookies arrived on time. Wrapped perfectly. The Black and White cookies were fantastic!!! Ate some, shared some and froze the rest.
Karina O. - Cedar Rapids, IA
The cookies were well packaged and arrived in great condition..
Linda W. - Carlsbad, NM
Very fresh and tasty
Gary P. - Phoenix, AZ
Everything! They arrived on the date I ask for them to be delivered. They were fresh and delicious!
Diane B. - Camp Hill, PA
The black and white cookies were delicious! Can't find anything like that in New England. Brought back memories of growing up in NY. Thank you.
Linda A. - Springfield, MA
I have been looking all over Denver for Black and White Cookies and now that I know Goldbelly and William Goldberg has them this is where I can get them if I have cravings.
Linda H. - Aurora, CO
The cookies arrived very well packed and in perfect condition
Rachel W. - Killeen, TX
Delivery right on time! Ordered Treats for my son’s birthday sent to college. He loves real NYC bagels and black&whites. Super treat for his day while studying for midterms. Will definitely use your services again!
John M. - Winston Salem, NC
Delivery was right on time. Cookies were delicious and were in a very attractive box
Julie A. - Phoenix, AZ
Received the package in good condition upon opening it a very big cake box with a pretty pink ribbon greeted me packed inside I was very pleased with the way my BLACK AND WHITE COOKIES WERE WRAPPED SO CAREFUL THANKFUL NONE WERE BROKEN I DEFINITELY WILL BE ORDERING FROM YOUR COMPANY AGAIN
Mary F. - Hauppauge, NY
The cookies were exactly as if I got them myself in NY. They came individually wrapped in the box! So yummy!!!
Tammy M. - Flower Mound, TX