Favorite Sloppy Joe Sandwich - 2 Pack

Town Hall Deli ships its famous New Jersey Sloppy Joe Sandwich nationwide on Goldbelly! This is no loose meat sandwich. This is a New Jersey-style Sloppy Joe and, for nearly 100 years, no one has done it better than the originators, Town Hall Deli. This baby’s got two types of meat (usually roast beef and turkey), topped with cheese, all smothered in Town Hall’s proprietary coleslaw and Russian dressing; both the original recipes using their homemade mayo. It’s all sandwiched between 3 slices of Pullman rye bread the length of an entire loaf. Go sloppy or go home.

Founded by Fred Joost and Hans Tiedeman, Town Hall Deli opened in 1927 and quickly made a name for itself after creating the original New Jersey Sloppy Joe sandwich. This is no loose meat sandwich; this take on the Sloppy Joe is a hefty thin rye bread sandwich originally made with coleslaw, ham, tongue, Swiss cheese, and dressing. Today, the South Orange, New Jersey, deli is owned by Tony Wonski and creates many two-meat variations of the Sloppy Joe. Go sloppy or go home!

Sandwiches arrive pre-assembled

More Details

This package serves 6 people includes 2 Large New Jersey Sloppy Joe sandwiches

  • Each Sandwich comes with 2 Meat selections, your choice
  • Each Sandwich comes with 1 Cheese selection, your choice
  • Each sandwich is divided into 8 pieces, making easy to share

Instructions / Storage

  • Sandwiches arrive pre-assembled fresh with ice packs, may thaw in transit
  • Upon arrival Sandwiches should be placed in the fridge for up to 2 days (if not going to be eaten immediately)

It is not recommended to freeze these items

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Town Hall Deli ships Monday-Friday
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New Jersey

REVIEWS

Arrived in perfect condition and everyone devoured the Sloppy Joes. One of my friends said, “What’s the big deal, it’s only a sandwich”...followed by “Oh My God!”
Michael L. - Chandler, AZ
10/11/19
On time. delicious. Just as I remembered.
Katharine H. - New York, NY
12/27/19
Excellent 👍
Elizabeth S. - Houston, TX
12/02/19
I LOVE that sandwich!! Sadly, I can't get it around here. So it is a very occasional treat. Thank you for starting this business!!
linda j. - East Haddam, CT
12/27/19
The sandwiches were easy to order. Updates on delivery were sent. Everything came fresh as if we were at the restaurant.
Jen K. - El Portal, FL
12/30/19
Great NJ made sandwich!!!
david h. - Massillon, OH
01/02/20
The sandwiches arrived in perfect condition. The customer communication experience was timely, informative and assuring. It was a thrill to receive our favorite food. Thank you.
Sam G. - Woodland Hills, CA
02/06/20
The packaging was exceptionally well done so the freshness of the Town Hall Sloppy Joes was maintained. Sandwich bread was not at all soggy.
Alfred W. - Longboat Key, FL
02/18/20
Order was perfect, on time and exactly as we expected. Thanks!!
John P. - Mesa, AZ
03/05/20
This is my 10th order since I found you last fall. Living in the south now and I was dying for a hot pastrami with all the fixin's! Everything I have ordered, all kinds of city food, comes beautifully wrapped and cold, on time and I love you guys!!
Jeannine S. - Lexington, VA
03/20/21
Delivered right on time, even though there was a snowstorm. Dry ice packing was excellent.
Randy F. - Hollis, NH
02/26/21
Everything worked well As a rule I do not make recommendations to friends but have already given your name to several people looking to duplicate their New Jersey experiences
Howie R. - Deerfield, IL
02/23/21
My covid birthday wasn't looking very exciting, so we ordered from you. EVERYTHING WAS SPECTACULAR. The food arrived perfectly on time, each item was delicious and so generous. We had our son and his girlfriend and our best friends seated at a very long table and everyone was delighted. You really made our evening. Thanks!
Nancy L. - Davis, CA
02/09/21
The Jersey Sloppy Joes were amazing! I got roast beef and corned beef, it was delicious. I will order again. Honestly it's a toss up between Town Hall and Milburn Deli. I've seen the YouTube video comparing them and I've tried both. Both are great!
Jason D. - Lytle Creek, CA
01/31/21
Fast service, food in good shape, chilled well & protected in good packing. Delivered around 2pm on Inauguration Day in perfect time for our celebration!
Jeff H. - South Wales, NY
01/29/21
Ordering was easy, delivery was on time, packaging great, and best of all the food ordered from Town Hall Deli was wonderful!
Bard S. - Orrtanna, PA
01/09/21
These sandwiches really held up well. Tasted fresh and delicious.
Jason F. - Doylestown, PA
02/25/21
Food was excellent as promised. Delivery was on time correctly wrapped to keep food safe.
Carolyn H. - Royal Oak, MI
01/22/21
Everything--was here at the right hour--and the food was perfect
Sheila K. - Delray Beach, FL
06/01/21
It's great to be able to order this sandwich that I know so well from where I grew up.
Douglas R. - Fairfax, VA
05/31/21
Town Deli delivery was perfect; weather cooperated and food was fresh and delicious.
Natalie R. - Kennebunk, ME
05/29/21
My wife grew up in South Orange and it was her birthday last week. I was very impressed that a couple of sloppy joe sandwiches could be delivered fresh over 2000 miles. They were a big hit. The packaging was superb. We will happily do it again.
Stan T. - Denver, CO
05/25/21
Fast delivery, carefully packaged 📦. Fresh and delicious 😋.
Cynthia W. - Glen Ridge, NJ
05/17/21
Every thing arrived on time and in good condition. It was packed well and still had some ice on it. Very good even the next day. I got two meals out it.
Catherine B. - Fort Wayne, IN
05/11/21
Found what I wanted, delivered on time, sent as a gift, she was thrilled. :-)
Susan W. - Miami, FL
05/01/21
I was able to order my family's favorite sandwich and get it delivered to us!
Mary P. - Poulsbo, WA
07/18/21
The ordering was easy, packaged perfectly! Tasted great !!!
Minda S. - Santa Clara, CA
07/03/21
Food was delivered on schedule. It tasted delicious and it made my husband very happy. He was so surprised.
Melissa R. - Winnetka, CA
06/21/21
Delivered exactly on time and very very fresh! Thank you!
Terry A. - Villa Park, CA
06/13/21
It's a tough call between here and the Milburn, both really good representations. Delivered on time, and happy I tried the corned beef.
Seth M. - La Jolla, CA
05/30/21
Food arrived cold, fresh and very well wrapped.
Suzanne S. - Columbia, MD
05/12/21
Excellent product, and although I had a small issue, beyond excellent customer service!
Jacqueline S. - Orlando, FL
04/17/21
This was a delicious sandwich, it arrived as advertised.
Nancy F. - Lansing, MI
03/18/21
Delivered right on time, even though there was a snowstorm. Dry ice packing was excellent.
Randy F. - Hollis, NH
02/26/21
Unfortunately our shipment was due to arrive on Friday. However, due to the snow storm, it wasn't received until Monday morning. I thought that our food would be ruined. This was not the case. It was packed so well that it was in perfect condition when it arrived.
Evalyn C. - Cornelius, NC
02/16/21