Cream Cheese Not Included

A true neighborhood bagel shop in one of New York’s funkiest neighborhoods, the East Village’s Tompkins Square Bagels is turning out some of the city’s most beloved bagels. These bagels are about as old-fashioned as it gets: proprietor Christopher Pugliese has been making bagels since he was 16 years old, and his contain just five ingredients, are based on a recipe from the 1950s and are and-rolled and boiled in small batches.

But even though these bagels may be traditionally made, Pugliese’s not afraid to think outside the box. Like his French Toast Bagels, an idea he had of hybriding Challah French Toast with a classic NYC bagel.

Without giving too much away, when they batch their bagel dough, they add traditional French Toast ingredients like eggs, butter, cinnamon, maple syrup, etc. Then they add a twist to the baking process. The result is a perfect marriage of French Toast and NYC bagel.

More Details

This package includes 12 French Toast Bagels

Cream Cheese Not Included


Flour, Water, Egg, Yeast, Malt, and Salt

Instructions / Storage

  • Bagels arrive ready to enjoy
  • Upon arrival place in the fridge or freezer
  • May be kept refrigerated for up to 3 days or frozen up to 2 weeks

To Serve

  • Microwave for 15- 30 seconds and then slice and toast
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Tompkins Square Bagels ships Monday – Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


Fabulous fabulous fabulous!!!
Robyn B. - Palmyra, VA
Arrived when you said it would, shipped seamlessly, and the product is divine. Thank you!
barbara b. - Williamsburg, VA
Exactly what I ordered was delivered on time. Each bagel was double wrapped with plastic wraps which helped to keep freshness.
Saeko M. - Orlando, FL
It was perfect. Thank you Tompkin for individually wrapping each bagel. Thank you for the freshness Thank you for the quality. My husband is enjoying every bit.Thank you Gold Belly for prompt delivery and delivered when promised. THANK YOu.
Darlene D. - Hilliard, OH
Super fast delivery time--package was beautifully wrapped as well as each bagel being wrapped individually. Will definitely order again!
Gary S. - Green Cove Springs, FL
Product is delicious and packaged well to maintain freshness of the bagels. Well done!
Patricia R. - Santa Rosa, CA
Fast delivery from Tompkins Square Bagel. And they were fresh and delicious.
Binny S. - Riegelsville, PA
The delivery was on time and the product was fresh and delicious!
Kerri H. - Panama City Beach, FL
I have ordered 3 separate orders from Tompkins Square bagels. The bagels are always fresh and delicious.
Karen L. - San Diego, CA
Everything was fantastic! The bagels were fresh, and packaged well. The receiver loved the gift!
Deborah D. - Prescott, AZ
Individually wrapped and bagged. So fresh and authentic. Toasted up perfectly.
Michael A. - Wilmington, DE
Arrived quickly, well packed. Delicious!
Norman M. - Camp Connell, CA
Delivery was super fast!
Nick B. - Birmingham, AL
Bagels are great! Communication: also great!
Breanne B. - Oakland, CA
Timely delivery— fresh and well packed
Elaine O. - Kennett Square, PA
The bagels arrived super fast and were perfectly preserved!
Natalie L. - Santa Fe, NM
Easy to order and quick delivery
Marsha W. - Saginaw, MI
Everything went very well as usual. I've been extremely happy with my Goldbelly experience and I even used some of my bonus points for this purchase.
Brian T. - Redondo Beach, CA
My order was mishandled by UPS and rather than overnight delivery it was 5 day delivery. When I reported it to Goldbelly they re-sent the order so that I could have my food order as fresh as possible. Goldbelly is very responsive to their customers.
- ,
The bagels were delivered on time and frozen. The receiver was so happy!
Brenda K. - Menasha, WI
Bagels arrived as expected and are very tasty.
Patricia R. - Santa Rosa, CA
The bagels that I found on GoldBelly were exactly what I was looking for. They were package so well and were so fresh. The shipping was fast and came right in time. We thoroughly enjoyed NY bagels on Christmas morning.
Jennifer S. - Pensacola, FL
Everything! The food arrived super-fast, super-fresh, and with super-easy instructions! Kudos to GoldBelly for vendors held to super-high standards!
Collette S. - Issaquah, WA
The Tompkins Square Bagels are the best I've ever tasted!!!!!!!
Arvis F. - Huffman, TX
On time delivery and it made my daughter happy! She visited me in NY for Christmas . She bought bagels to bring back to Illinois but forgot them.
Marissa G. - Berkeley, IL
Food selection is fantastic! Delivery occurred on time with no problems. We live in a remote area so being able to get any of these food items to appear on our dining table is exotic & a treat.
dee h. - Paonia, CO
quick delivery, on time, order was correct, food was absolutely fresh and delicious!
cathy r. - Leander, TX
Everything! Loved that the bagels were individually wrapped.
Scott B. - Park Ridge, IL
Was all perfect and bagels I was told are delicious
The O. - Madeira, OH