• Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's
  • Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's - Alternate image 1
  • Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's - Alternate image 2
  • Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's - Alternate image 3
Favorite
Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's
Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's - Alternate image 1
Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's - Alternate image 2
Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack by Sugaree's - Alternate image 3
Sugaree's
Sugaree's95% love this shop
New Albany, MS
Favorite

Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack

Freezer FriendlyFreezes beautifully, so you can enjoy it fresh or stock up for later.

Ships Nationwide in U.S.

Not eligible for shipping to Canada
Choose Your Own Pie - 2 Pack

Sugaree’s ships its famous pies nationwide on Goldbelly! With this amazing pie pack, the dessert for your holidays and any gathering are taken care of! Choose two of Sugaree’s classic Southern pies, including pecan pie, or sweet potato pie, for the ultimate experience.

Sugaree’s is committed to keeping classic Deep South recipes and baking techniques alive by focusing on small-batch and from-scratch recipes. This New Albany, Mississippi, bakery was founded as a home-based business by Mary Jennifer Russell in 1997 and expanded to a retail shop in 2001. Sugaree’s makes each of its delicious pies and cakes the old-fashioned way in flavors like Italian Cream Cake and Chocolate Meringue.

This package serves 16-20 people and includes 2 Pies of your choice

  • Each Pie serves 8-10 people
  • Each Pie is 9"

Pie Options Include

  • Sweet Potato Pie
  • Pecan Pie
  • Pies ship frozen with dry ice, may thaw in transit
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • To serve, thaw for approximately 4 hours at room temp
  • Pie is best kept at room temperature for 1 week
View Full Instructions

Pecan – Eggs, Sugar, Enriched Wheat Flour, Light and Dark Corn Syrups, Pecans, Butter, Rendered Leaf Lard, Vanilla Extract, Salt

Sweet Potato Pie – Sweetened Condensed Milk, Sweet Potatoes, Sugar, Eggs, Butter, Enriched Wheat Flour, Rendered Leaf Lard, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Cinnamon

Product Image

Mississippi Heritage Bakery Baking the Old-Fashioned Way

Sugaree's has been featured in Southern Living on the "10 Best Southern Pies" list, Local Palate, Oprah Magazine, Taste of the South, Mississippi Magazine, Saveur, and the Washington Post.

Mississippi Heritage Bakery Baking the Old-Fashioned Way

Sugaree's
Sugaree's
95% love this shop
New Albany, MS
If you close your eyes, and taste a Sugaree’s cake, you will be instantly swept back to a time where sugar was carefully browned in a cast iron skillet until it was just the right shade of golden brown needed for a deeply delicious caramel icing. Where hot butter glazes were poured with a lavish hand over thick layers of coconut cake to drench every slice with pure, moist flavor. Where icings were carefully, expertly, slowly cooked on a hot stovetop until they were silky smooth. That’s the way they always did it in the Deep South, that is the way Sugaree’s Bakery, a small batch heritage bakery in Mississippi, does it today. It’s not a fast way. And it is not an easy way. But it is a way that infuses layers and layers of rich, complex, and deeply satisfying flavor in every glorious bite.
Sugaree's

Limited-Time Indulgences
Offers that won’t last