The Original Joe Sandwich
94%Read ReviewsShips Nationwide in U.S.
Not eligible for shipping to CanadaThe Original Joe Sandwich from Town Hall Deli is a hearty, New Jersey–style Sloppy Joe featuring two meats, cheese, Russian dressing and proprietary coleslaw—stacked between three slices of Pullman rye. A generational classic since 1927, this iconic deli favorite arrives fresh, ready to enjoy the authentic taste of South Orange, NJ.
- Serves 3 people
- Made with two meats (typically roast beef and turkey), swiss cheese, and Town Hall’s own coleslaw and Russian dressing made with original homemade mayo, layered between three thin slices of Pullman rye bread
- Ships fresh, pre‑assembled one large sandwich and sliced into 8 shareable pieces, and wrapped with ice packs to ensure safe nationwide delivery
- Pre‑assembled by Town Hall Deli in South Orange, New Jersey
Awards & Media
- Celebrated as “the original Sloppy Joe” by Serious Eats
- Featured in outlets like The New York Times, Food Network, and CNN, solidifying its reputation as a legendary deli sandwich
- Sandwiches arrive pre-assembled fresh with ice packs, may thaw in transit
- Upon arrival Sandwiches should be placed in the fridge for up to 2 days (if not going to be eaten immediately)
It is not recommended to freeze these items
Original Joe Sandwich – Ham, Tongue, Swiss Cheese, Coleslaw and Russian Dressing
The Original New Jersey Sloppy Joe
The Original New Jersey Sloppy Joe
Put away that can of Manwich—this is a real man’s sandwich. Town Hall Deli opened in 1927 and made a name for itself after creating the New Jersey-style Sloppy Joe. The sandwich was named after a bar in Cuba that the original owner visited in the ‘30s. So enlightened by the sandwich that he had in Cuba, he brought the idea back home, and it was an instant hit.
This baby’s got two types of meat (usually roast beef and turkey), topped with cheese, all smothered in Town Hall’s coleslaw and Russian dressing, both using original recipes and homemade mayo. It’s all sandwiched between 3 thin slices of Pullman rye bread the length of an entire loaf. We won't judge if you needed to call up your boys for some backup.
