SERVES
14-16
Favorite
SERVES
14-16
Smith Island Cake Sampler - Choose Your Own
93%Read ReviewsThe Experience
Ready To Eat
Unwrap, dig in
Smith Island Cake Sampler - Choose Your Own
Smith Island Cake Sampler – Choose Your Own allows you to select four different flavors of Maryland’s official state dessert from options like Pumpkin Spice, Red Velvet, and Old Bay Buttercream. These faithful renditions are handcrafted by Smith Island Baking Company using high-quality ingredients to honor a tradition dating back to the 1800s fishing community.
This package serves 14-16 people and includes your choice of 4 quarters of Cake
- Choose to add more!
- Cake quarters are not individually wrapped, therefore, Coconut Flakes may shift in transit.
- Cakes are made from scratch and assembled by hand, so heights may vary.
Flavor Options Include
- Caramel Cream Cake
- Carrot Cake
- Chocolate Birthday Cake
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
- Cooked Coconut Cake
- Double Chocolate Cake
- Double Chocolate Raspberry Cake
- Lemon Cream Cake
- Old Bay Buttercream Cake
- Original Chocolate Cake
- Peppermint Gingerbread Cake
- Pumpkin Spice Cake (Seasonal)
- Red Velvet Cake
- Strawberry Cream Cake
- Vanilla Birthday Cake
- Red, White & Blue (Seasonal)
Add On Options Include
- 12 Birthday Cake Bites – Perfect for birthdays – or any occasion! An irresistible combination of vanilla cake filled with buttercream frosting and coated in festive red and blue crumbs.
- 12 Carrot Cake Bites – Made from scratch with real carrots, comprises moist carrot cake filled with housemade vanilla buttercream frosting.
- 12 Double Chocolate Cake Bites – Like a brownie, only better! Moist chocolate cake, filled with our homemade fudge frosting, and rolled through chocolate cake crumbs.
- 12 Original Cake Bites – Moist, made-from-scratch vanilla cake, filled with housemade fudge frosting and rolled through vanilla cake crumbs.
- 12 Red Velvet Cake Bites – Moist, made-from-scratch red velvet cake, filled with housemade vanilla buttercream frosting, and rolled through red velvet crumbs.
- 12 Pumpkin Cake Bites – Moist, made-from-scratch pumpkin spice cake, filled with housemade vanilla buttercream frosting, rolled through pumpkin cake crumbs.
- 5 Happy Birthday Chocolates (2 oz. Total) – The perfect birthday touch – happy birthday chocolates!
- 36 Birthday Candles
- Each cake bite weighs 1 oz.
- Cakes ship frozen with dry ice.
- Dry ice may dissipate in transit.
- Do not remove dry ice with bare hands.
- Cake may be stored in the freezer for up to 2 months or at room temperature for up to 2 days.
- If refreezing, wrap cake well before storing in the freezer.
To Serve
Cake
- Unwrap cake and thaw covered and at room temperature (NOT in the refrigerator) for 1-2 hours per pound of cake.
- Serve at room temperature, or slightly warmed (~5 seconds in the microwave).
- Top with whipped cream, ice cream, berries, nuts, or your favorite garnish (not included).
- Serve & enjoy!
Cake Bites
- Thaw at room temperature for 30 minutes.
- Serve frozen, at room temperature, or slightly warmed (~5 seconds in the microwave).
- Top with whipped cream, ice cream, berries, nuts, or your favorite garnish (not included).
- Enjoy!
- Caramel Cream Cake – Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Cake Flour, Heavy Cream, Whole Eggs, Butter, Light Corn Syrup, Vegetable Oil, Brown Sugar, Water, Corn Starch, Baking Soda, Salt, Pure Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Carrot Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Carrot, Whole Eggs, Canola Oil, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Pineapple, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Pure Vanilla Extract, Nutmeg, Salt, Cinnamon. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Chocolate Birthday Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, High Fat Cocoa, Baking Soda, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Powder And Rainbow Birthday Sprinkles. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Peanut Butter, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Soybean Oil, Evaporated Milk, High Fat Cocoa, Baking Soda, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Cooked Coconut Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Coconut, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Pure Vanilla Extract, Baking Soda, Salt, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Double Chocolate Cake – All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Whole Eggs, High Fat Cocoa, Canola Oil, Pure Vanilla Extract, Cider Vinegar, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Double Chocolate Raspberry Cake – All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Seedless Raspberry Filling, Evaporated Milk, Whole Eggs, High Fat Cocoa, Canola Oil, Pure Vanilla Extract, Cider Vinegar, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Lemon Cream Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Lemon Juice, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Lemon Extract, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Old Bay Buttercream Cake – Cake Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Old Bay Seasoning, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Original Chocolate Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, High Fat Cocoa, Baking Soda, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Peppermint Gingerbread Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Confectioner’s Sugar, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Pure Vanilla Extract, Ginger, Salt, Cinnamon, Salt, Peppermint Extract, Crushed Candy Canes, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Cloves, Allspice
- Pumpkin Spice Cake – Pumpkin, Unbleached All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Canola Oil, Whole Eggs, Evaporated Milk, Baking Soda, Cinnamon, Allspice, Ginger, Baking Powder, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt
- Red Velvet Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Red Food Coloring (Red #40), Pure Vanilla Extract, High Fat Cocoa, Apple Cider Vinegar, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Strawberry Cream Cake – Cake Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Strawberry Filling (Water, Sugar, Strawberry Puree, Corn Starch, Citric Acid, Salt, Preservative, Artificial Flavor, Red 40), Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Vanilla Birthday Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, And Rainbow Birthday Sprinkles, Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk. May Contain: Peanuts and/or Coconut
- Red White & Blue Velvet Smith Island Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Red Food Coloring (Red #40), Royal Blue Coloring, Pure Vanilla Extract, High Fat Cocoa, Apple Cider Vinegar, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt Contains: Dairy & Eggs
- Birthday Cake Bites – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Cider Vinegar, Red Food Coloring (Red #40), Blue Food Coloring (Blue #1, Red #3). Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Carrot Cake Bites – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Carrot, Whole Eggs, Canola Oil, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Pineapple, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Pure Vanilla Extract, Nutmeg, Salt, Cinnamon Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Double Chocolate Cake Bites – All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Whole Eggs, High Fat Cocoa, Canola Oil, Pure Vanilla Extract, Cider Vinegar, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Original Cake Bites – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Soybean Oil, Evaporated Milk, High Fat Cocoa, Baking Soda, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Powder Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Red Velvet Cake Bites – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Red Food Coloring (Red #40), Pure Vanilla Extract, High Fat Cocoa, Apple Cider Vinegar, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt. *Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut8
- Pumpkin Cake Bites – Pumpkin, Unbleached All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Canola Oil, Whole Eggs, Evaporated Milk, Baking Soda, Cinnamon, Allspice, Ginger, Baking Powder, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk, May Contain Peanuts And/or Coconut
- Happy Birthday Chocolates – Belgian Unsweetened Chocolate, Sugar, Cocoa Butter, Soy Lecithin (An Emulsifier), Natural Vanilla Extract, Hydrogenated Palm Kernal Oil, Contains One Of More Of The Following: Titanium Dioxide, Fd&c Yellow #5 And 6, Blue #1and2, Fd&c Red #40 And Carmine. May Contain Milk. Contains Soy
- Red White & Blue Velvet Cake – Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Red Food Coloring (Red #40), Royal Blue Coloring, Pure Vanilla Extract, High Fat Cocoa, Apple Cider Vinegar, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt Contains: Dairy & Eggs
The Iconic State Dessert from Maryland's Eastern Shore
Smith Island Baking Company has been featured in USA Today, Wall Street Journal, Businessweek, People Magazine, Washington Post, and Washingtonian.
The Iconic State Dessert from Maryland's Eastern Shore
Smith Island Baking Company
93% love this shopStar Shipper
Crisfield, MDSince the 1800’s, Smith Island Cakes, Maryland’s State Dessert, have been a symbol of family, faith, and togetherness. As legend goes, when Smith Island watermen would set out for months on end for the autumn oyster harvest, their families would send them with Smith Island Cakes to remind them of the community they left behind. With alternating layers of super thin, made-from-scratch cake and frosting, Smith Island Cakes remain a delicious centerpiece for celebrations of all sizes and shapes.
In 2009, Brian and Joy Murphy founded the Smith Island Baking Company with the bold vision of sharing this iconic treasure with the world. They started a tiny bakery on Smith Island, an island with only 200 residents, located 10 miles off-shore and accessible only by ferry. Today, Smith Island Baking Company continues to act as custodians of this treasure from nearly Crisfield, called “the closest point to Smith Island without getting wet.” Each of their cakes are made with real, high-quality ingredients, and remain faithful to the oldest recipes and techniques. Popular cake flavors include Original Chocolate, Pumpkin, Lemon, Strawberry and even Old Bay along with samplers and irresistible Cake Bites, and they're all shipping nationwide on Goldbelly!
HOLIDAYS & OCCASIONS
Gifts for Every Celebration
GRADUATION
MEMORIAL DAY
FATHER'S DAY
BIRTHDAY
TOP 100 GIFTS
CORPORATE GIFTS
SYMPATHY GIFT
GET WELL
THANK YOU
CARE PACKAGES
NEW BABY
PRIDE
JULY 4TH
LABOR DAY
JEWISH HOLIDAYS
MID-AUTUMN FEST
DIWALI
HALLOWEEN
THANKSGIVING
HANUKKAH
CHRISTMAS
NEW YEAR'S
GAME DAY
VALENTINES DAY
MARDI GRAS
LUNAR NEW YEAR
PURIM
ST. PATRICK'S DAY
PASSOVER
EASTER
MOTHER'S DAY
Limited-Time Indulgences
Offers that won’t last
