FIRST-EVER THANKSGIVING SALE!
30% OFF TURKEYS, PIES, SIDES & MORE! SHOP NOW
Favorite
  • GIANT New York Cheesecake by Sarge's Deli
  • GIANT New York Cheesecake by Sarge's Deli - Alternate image 1
SERVES
12+
GIANT New York Cheesecake by Sarge's Deli
SERVES
12+
GIANT New York Cheesecake by Sarge's Deli - Alternate image 1
Sarge's Deli
93% love this shop

GIANT New York Cheesecake

Ships to U.S. & CanadaSome restrictions apply

Sarge’s Deli ships its delicious New York cheesecake nationwide on Goldbelly! Sarge’s signature cheesecakes are the largest you will ever see; they tower over 3" high with a diameter of 9" and weigh more than 7.5 lbs. Their recipe has been in the family for over 100 years and each and every day, dozens are baked right in the restaurant, using only the world’s finest ingredients.

This iconic New York Jewish deli has been the promised land of pastrami since Abe “Sarge” Katz, a retired NYPD cop, opened its doors in 1964. Step inside and you get a true New York deli experience — complete with signed celebrity photos hanging on the walls, Tiffany lamps, and the scent of smoky pastrami wafting through the classic diner booths. Sarge’s famous pastrami comes from an old family recipe and is cured in house — one of the last New York delis to do so. Thrillist named Sarge’s Deli one of the 10 Best Places to Get Pastrami in NYC.

This package serves 10-12 people and includes a GIANT New York Cheesecake

  • Each cheesecake measures 9"