• Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery
  • Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery - Alternate image 1
  • Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery - Alternate image 2
  • Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery - Alternate image 3
CHOOSE
1-5 lbs
Favorite
Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery
CHOOSE
1-5 lbs
Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery - Alternate image 1
Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery - Alternate image 2
Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own by Fortunato Brothers Bakery - Alternate image 3

Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own

81%Read Reviews
Freezer FriendlyFreezes beautifully, so you can enjoy it fresh or stock up for later.

Ships Nationwide in U.S.

Not eligible for shipping to Canada
Pignoli Cookies - Choose Your Own

These classic Italian pignoli cookies are crispy, crunchy, and come both plain and with pistachio and marzipan!

Fortunato Bros. Cafe & Pasticceria was founded in Brooklyn’s Williamsburg neighborhood in 1976 by three recent immigrants from Naples, Italy. They brought over their classic old-world recipes for Italian baked goods, and the bakery quickly became a beloved neighborhood fixture. The brothers can still be found at the shop today, and they’ve handed the reins to their children to bring their legacy into the future. Everything at Fortunato’s baked goods is still made according to the original recipes, made by hand from scratch with only the highest-quality ingredients.

This package includes your choice of 1-5 lbs. of Pignoli Cookies

  • Each cookie measures 2-3"
  • Each lb includes approx. 18-20 pcs.
  • Specialty ingredients imported from Italy

Options Include

  • Plain Pignoli Cookies
  • Pistachio Pignoli Cookies
  • Cookies arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, store cookies at room temperature or in the refrigerator (freezing not recommended).
  • Cookies may be stored at room temperature for 2-3 days or in the refrigerator for up to 1 week.
View Full Instructions
  • Plain Pignoli Cookies – Granulated Almonds, Egg Whites, Almond Oil, Sugar, Pine Nuts
  • Pistachio Pignoli Cookies – Granulated Almonds, Egg Whites, Almond Oil, Sugar, Pine Nuts, Marzipan, Pistachio
Product Image

Brooklyn’s Neighborhood Italian Bakery Since 1976

Fortunato Brothers is a neighborhood staple and has been featured in many local new sources.

Brooklyn’s Neighborhood Italian Bakery Since 1976

Fortunato Brothers Bakery
Fortunato Brothers Bakery
81% love this shop
Brooklyn, NY

Fortunato Bros. Cafe & Pasticceria was founded in Brooklyn’s Williamsburg neighborhood in 1976 by three recent immigrants from Naples, Italy: Salvatore, Mario, and Michael Fortunato. They brought over their classic old-world recipes for Italian cookies, biscotti, cakes, and pastries including cannoli and sfogliatelle, and the bakery quickly became a beloved neighborhood fixture. The brothers can still be found sipping cappuccino at the shop today, and they’ve handed the reins to their children to bring their legacy into the future.

Each of Fortunato’s baked goods are still made according to the original recipes, made by hand from scratch with only the highest-quality ingredients. They’ve also made some modern additions to the menu, like the now-famous Rainbow Cookie Cake. Fortunato Bros. is a true classic, and now it’s shipping nationwide!

Fortunato Brothers Bakery

Limited-Time Indulgences
Offers that won’t last