• Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 1
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 2
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 3
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 4
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 5
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 6
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 7
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 8
  • Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 9
Favorite
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 1
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 2
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 3
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 4
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 5
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 6
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 7
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 8
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack by Estes Park Pie Shop - Alternate image 9

Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack

90%Read Reviews
Freezer FriendlyFreezes beautifully, so you can enjoy it fresh or stock up for later.

Ships to U.S. & Canada

Some restrictions apply
Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack

Estes Park Pie Shop ships its legendary pies nationwide on Goldbelly! Enjoy your choice of two Estes Park Pie Shop pies, including blueberry peach, cherry, and caramel apple pecan pie. Estes Park’s sweet apple pie is a multiple Blue Ribbon winner! Granny Smith apples and cinnamon combined with brown sugar, oat crumble topping, caramel drizzle, and chopped pecans make this apple pie to remember. This apple pie is vegan.

Opened in 2006 by husband-wife team Rick and Val Thompson, Estes Park Pie Shop bakes pies from scratch using recipes and techniques passed down from generations ago. The bakers at Estes Park Pie Shop in Estes Park, Colorado, fill every one of their world-famous pies with 6 cups of bursting-with-flavor seasonal fruit like peach and blueberry (double the amount used by most bakeries) and never include any preservatives or canned fruit. Their signature crunchy sugar crumb topping seals the deal, adding a distinctive texture and crunch to their pies from strawberry rhubarb to apple to cherry.

FREE SHIPPING to Colorado

This package serves 16 people and includes 2 Pies, your choice

  • Each pie serves 8 people and measures 9"
  • Pies arrive in a reusable aluminum pie tin
  • All pies are vegan—naturally made with vegetable shortening and no lard

Flavor Options Include

  • Caramel Apple Pecan
  • Rhubarb
  • Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Dutch Apple
  • Blueberry Peach
  • Blueberry
  • Cherry Peach
  • Cherry
  • Peach
  • Apple Ginger Peach
  • Pies ship fresh and arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, place pies at room temperature, in the refrigerator, or in the freezer.
  • Pies last up to 5 days at room temperature, up to 1 week in the refrigerator, or up to 6 months in the freezer (if wrapped tightly).
  • Pies can be served at room temperature or warmed.

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 350°F.
  • Bake pie for 20 minutes.
  • Remove from oven, slice, and enjoy!
View Full Instructions

Fruit, Sugar, No Trans Fat Vegetable Shortening, Flour, All Vegetable Margarine, Corn Starch, Salt

Product Image

Colorado's Legendary Pies

Estes Park Pie Shop has been featured in Food Network, Denver Post and more.

Colorado's Legendary Pies

Estes Park Pie Shop
90% love this shop
Estes Park, CO
Opened in 2006 by husband-wife team Rick & Val Thompson, The Estes Park Pie Shop bakes their luscious fruit pies from scratch using recipes and techniques passed down from their great grandma. Filled to the brim with plump, juicy fruit, each pie has a signature buttery, sweet crumb topping that sends it over the top. It’s the pie you’ve been dreaming of, made from scratch by the Thompson family using the highest quality ingredients available. Also known as You Need Pie!™, these special pies would make grandma and great grandma proud.
Estes Park Pie Shop

Limited-Time Indulgences
Offers that won’t last