• Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's
  • Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 1
  • Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 2
  • Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 3
  • Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 4
  • Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 5
SERVES
14
Favorite
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's
SERVES
14
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 1
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 2
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 3
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 4
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie by Cootie Brown's - Alternate image 5

Gluten Free Key Lime Pie

95%Read Reviews

Ships Nationwide in U.S.

Not eligible for shipping to Canada
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie

Cootie Brown’s ships its gluten-free Key lime pie nationwide on Goldbelly Gluten-free foodies rejoice! This is the exact same recipe as Cootie Brown’s famous Key lime pie but made with a gluten-free graham cracker crust. You won’t even notice the difference. Cootie Brown’s makes small batches of gluten-free graham crackers then crumble them all up to deliver Key lime pie goodness to you in a gluten-free dessert. Sweet, tart, and truly unique, what more could you want?

Opened by the Vella family in 1999, Cootie Brown’s is an eclectic Johnson, Tennessee, restaurant that serves dishes inspired by fictitious Cootie Brown’s travels around the world. One of Cootie Brown’s most famous creations is its signature two-layer Key lime pie, a rich, silky, and tart masterpiece.

This package serves 14 people and includes a Gluten Free Key Lime Pie

  • Each 10" pie weighs 4 lbs.
  • Each pie arrives in a reusable pie tin!
  • Choose to add a T-Shirt!

T-Shirt Add On Options Include

  • Vintage Neon Sign Short Sleeve Shirt
  • Mystery Pick Tie Dye Short Sleeve Shirt
    • Size Options Include Small – X-Large
  • Pies are made fresh, frozen and shipped in custom made boxes with dry ice which may thaw partially or fully during transit
  • To serve upon arrival, allow pie to thaw in the refrigerator for 1-2 hours, or for 1 hour on a countertop
  • Pies can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 1 week, or in the freezer for up to 6 months
  • To serve from frozen, allow pie to thaw in the refrigerator overnight
View Full Instructions
  • Gluten Free Key Lime Pie – Cream Cheese, Sugar, Eggs, Key Lime Juice, Powdered Sugar, Sweeteend Condensed Milk, Garbanzo Bean Flour, Potato Starch, Tapioca Flour, White Sorghum Flour, Fava Bean Flour, Vegetable Shortening, Brown Sugar, Honey, Molasses, Milk, Salt, Gelatin, Vanilla Extract, Xanthan Gum

Cootie Brown’s GF Key Lime Pie is produced in a kitchen that uses wheat ingredients. The facility is not certified Gluten Free. A concerted effort is made to prepare the pie avoiding cross-contamination.

Product Image

Home of the Two Layer Pie

Cootie Brown's have won three first place ribbons at the 2025 American Pie Council National Championship for the Peach, Raspberry, and Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake. They also placed first with the Peach and Pumpkin in 2024. Their tamales have been featured in Food Network Magazine, Bristol Herald Courier, Johnson City Press, Kingsport Times News, Johnson City News and Neighbor. It has also been featured on the Daytime Tri-Cities Live Talk Show.

Home of the Two Layer Pie

Cootie Brown's
Cootie Brown's
95% love this shop
Johnson City, TN
Since 1999, Cootie Brown’s has brought bold diverse flavors and a bit of funk to Johnson City. From New Orleans Muffaletta and Caribbean Jamaican Jerk Chicken to Mexican Tamales and Memphis style BBQ, Cootie Brown has defined an experience quite unlike anything else. But it's their line of homemade desserts that really showcases their unconventional creativity—each pie is a double layer masterpiece. Their most famous Key Lime pie is handmade from scratch and features one tart key lime layer and a second sweet, creamy layer. It’s seriously a one of a kind!
Cootie Brown's

Limited-Time Indulgences
Offers that won’t last