• Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago
  • Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 1
  • Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 2
  • Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 3
  • Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 4
16
Favorite
Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago
16
Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 1
Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 2
Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 3
Classic Cookie Assortment by Cake Chicago - Alternate image 4

Classic Cookie Assortment

93%Read Reviews

Ships to U.S. & Canada

Some restrictions apply
Classic Cookie Assortment

Cake Chicago ships its famous cookies nationwide on Goldbelly! Cake Chicago’s “Damn Good Cookies,” “Jar’d” cakes, and more have delighted fans from all over the country, including Martha Stewart! The cookies of your childhood are perfected with top-tier ingredients, including Belgium chocolate, fresh cream, and European style butter.

When owner Mary Winslow left her publishing sales job and started baking in 2000, she never imagined she would end up becoming one of Chicago’s top resources for spectacular sweets. But like any great cake, her rise was slow and deliberate with outstanding results — she began by subletting a small area in a catering kitchen, but soon found herself in a bigger kitchen with a whole new line of pastries. Her chubby “Damn Good Cookies,” decadent “Jar’d” cakes, and “Ugly Truffles” have delighted fans all over the country, including Martha Stewart!

This package includes 16 Assorted Classic Cookies

  • Cookies arrive individually wrapped in a beautiful gift box with a ribbon

Flavors include:

  • 4 Chocolate Chip Cookies – crisp edges, chewy center with bittersweet chocolate chips
  • 4 Chocolate-Chocolate Chip Cookies – chocolate on chocolate on chocolate
  • 4 Oatmeal Raisin Cookies – chewy raisins, spiced oats, and vanilla
  • 4 Peanut Butterfinger Cookies – crunchy Butterfinger pieces rolled into peanut butter dough
  • Baked goods are individually wrapped and arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, place in the refrigerator or freezer to enjoy later. They can be stored in the refrigerator for 2 weeks or in the freezer for up to 3 months
View Full Instructions

Home of the "Damn Good Cookies"

Cake Chicago
93% love this shop
Chicago, IL
When owner Mary Winslow left her publishing sales job and started baking in 2000, she never imagined she’d end up becoming one of Chicago’s top resources for spectacular sweets. But like any great cake, her rise was slow and deliberate with outstanding results—she began by subletting a small area in a catering kitchen, but soon found herself in a bigger kitchen with a whole new line of pastries. Her "Damn Good Cookies," "Jar'd" cakes and more have delighted fans from all over the country, including Martha Stewart!
Cake Chicago

Limited-Time Indulgences
Offers that won’t last