Artisanal Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 6 Pints

Proper Ice Cream ships its legendary ice cream nationwide on Goldbelly! Proper Ice Cream’s ice cream is small-batch and handcrafted using only the finest available ingredients, zero artificial flavors or coloring. These ice creams have a luxuriously smooth, custard-like mouthfeel. And don’t even get us started on their variety of gourmet flavors! Proper Ice Cream will delight even the most discerning ice cream fan! This package gives you the chance to sample 6 of Proper Ice Cream’s exciting flavors like Strawberry Biscuits made strawberry jam and studded with honey biscuits.

After practicing law for 30 years, Rick Felberbaum decided to leave a sweeter legacy and dedicate his life to his true passion: ice cream. Founded in 2018, Proper Ice Cream in Delray Beach, Florida, makes small-batch ice cream using only the finest available ingredients and zero artificial flavors or coloring. Proper’s ice cream has a luxuriously smooth, custard-like mouthfeel. And don’t even get us started on their variety of gourmet flavors! From Strawberry Biscuits and Cream to Key Lime Pie, Proper Ice Cream will delight even the most discerning ice cream fan.

Flavors included are based on availability and are subject to change

More Details

This package includes your choice of includes 6 pints of Artisanal Ice Cream

Flavor Options Include

  • Banana Two-Pound Cake and Cream – Creamy fresh banana ice cream is swirled with our house-made vanilla cream and rich buttery two-pound cake. we call it two-pound cake because we double up on butter and sugars resulting in a very dense and flavorful pound cake.  
  • Blueberry Muffin Ice Cream – Fresh Sweet Cream base is mixed with Proper Ice Cream’s housemade blueberry muffins They then add a rich, slow-cooked pure blueberry compote and ribbon throughout for a taste of summer.
  • Boston Cream Pie – A traditional style egg custard base with pieces of homemade pound cake covered in dark chocolate with a swirl of Italian Meringue.
  • Butterscotch Cocoa Brownie – Authentic from scratch butterscotch ice cream mixed together with house-made cocoa brownies
  • Bread Pudding Ice Cream with Caramel -Brioche baked bread pudding is blended into our ice cream base. we then fold in pieces of bread pudding together with butter caramel.
  • Coconut with Chocolate and Nuts – Fresh coconut base with a swirl of dark chocolate and a mixture of peanuts, almonds, walnuts, sesame seeds, and pistachios
  • Dark Coffee with Peanut Butter Crunch – The richest Brazilian roasted coffee is used in the base of this ice cream which is then mixed with a super crunchy peanut butter fudge. The Flavors are off the charts.  
  • Deep Chocolate – Our Proper signature chocolate ice cream made with 100% Valhrona cocoa and Lindt 90% dark chocolate. The result is what we feel is the finest chocolate ice cream ever.
  • Fresh Strawberry, Biscuits and Cream – A sweet cream base is ribboned with house-made strawberry jam and studded with honey biscuits made right here in the Proper kitchen!
  • Glazed Doughnut Ice Cream – Housemade traditional glazed cake doughnuts are stirred and heated in the cream base which is then churned and frozen into this one-of-a-kind amazing ice cream.
  • Key Lime Pie – A key lime base swirled with Italian Meringue and pieces of our homemade pie crust
  • Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream – A sweet orange-based ice cream swirled together with our vanilla cream will take you back to your childhood in one lick!
  • Sweet Cream with Chocolate Covered Honeycomb – Our sweet cream base loaded with pieces of our homemade candied honeycomb covered in rich dark chocolate
  • Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate – Proper Ice Cream’s purest Vanilla Bean Ice cream is made with Madagascar Vanilla and old-fashioned malt and mixed with roasted Valhrona white chocolate.
  • Vegan Ceylon Cinnamon
  • Vegan Cookies & Cream
  • Vegan Deep Chocolate
  • Vegan Deep Chocolate Cookies & Cream
  • Vegan Roasted Coffee
  • Vegan Organic Peanut Butter

Flavors included are based on availability and are subject to change

Ingredients

  • Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate –  whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, madagascar vanilla beans,, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Fresh Strawberry, Biscuits and Cream – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, Fresh Strawberries, strawberry concentrate, baking flour, yeast, butter, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream – A sweet orange based ice cream swirled together with our vanilla cream will take you back to your childhood in one lick!
  • Banana Two-Pound Cake and Cream – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder,orange juice, orange concentrate, vanilla bean, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Deep Chocolate – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, bananas, whole wheat flour, baking flour, butter, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt
  • Dark Coffee with Peanut Butter Crunch – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, nonfat dry milk powder,100% black cocoa powder, dark chocolate 90% cocoa, vanilla bean, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Glazed Doughnut Ice Cream – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, whole wheat flour, baking flour, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Blueberry Muffin Ice Cream – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, fresh blueberries, blueberry concentrate, whole wheat flour, baking flour, yeast, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Butterscotch Cocoa Brownie -whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, brown sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, black cocoa powder, baking flour, butter, whole wheat flour, baking flour, yeast, coconut oil, vanilla bean,  extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
  • Bread Pudding Ice Cream with Caramel – whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, whole wheat flour, baking flour coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, nutmeg, cinnamon,  kosher salt.
  • Sweet Cream with Chocolate Covered Honeycomb – Whole Milk, Cream, Cane Sugar, Sugar, Skimmed Milk Powder, Coconut Oil, 100% dark cocoa powder, 90% dark chocolate, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Fresh Florida Honey, Kosher Salt, Baking Soda
  • Boston Cream Pie – - Whole milk, cream, cane sugar, sugar, skimmed milk powder, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, cocoa butter, chocolate, Kosher salt, yellow cream, cocoa, flour, egg white, starch, soy
  • Coconut with Chocolate and Nuts -Whole Milk, Cream, Cane Sugar, Skimmed Milk Powder, Fresh Coconut, Coconut Oil, Virgin Olive Oil, Kosher Salt, Chocolate, Cocoa, Cocoa Butter, Pistachio, Almond, Walnut, Peanut, Sesame
  • Key Lime Pie – - Whole milk, cream, cane sugar, sugar, skimmed milk powder, sweetened condensed milk, coconut oil, wheat flour, molasses, corn syrup, honey, lime juice. extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt, soy

Instructions / Storage

  • Ice Cream ships frozen with dry ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands!
  • May be stored frozen for up to 6 months
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Proper Ice Cream ships Monday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping.
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Florida

REVIEWS

Everything is always perfect. My friends love the gifts I send during this shutdown. Love getting packages of goodies.
Gwen E. - Camano Island, WA
04/29/20
The ice cream was fantastic. Go Proper Ice Cream! Thanks for the delivery, Goldbelly!
Amy b. - North Bellmore, NY
04/01/20
Our parents loved their ice cream...our mom loved the Blueberry muffin ice cream...the ice cream was delivered as stated. Our dad had a wonderful father's day! Happiness all around!!
Paul W. - Albuquerque, NM
06/15/20
The ice cream I sent was well packed and got to my clients frozen solid. They loved it!!
Marty G. - Miramar Beach, FL
09/02/20
The delivery arrived on time! We purchased ice cream for a very special birthday and it did not disappoint, the ice cream arrived super cold! This site is so awesome!
Jamie J. - Elkridge, MD
08/13/20
Received ice cream no issues this time. Good customer service, responsive. The owner of the company was very kind also.
Andrea M. - Cumberland, RI
08/12/20
The ice cream was delivered during a 5 day power outage due to tropical storm Isiasas, so I was nervous when I saw the box on my porch. It was packed so well it made it to my nearest friend with power and was still frozen when placing in freezer there. We enjoyed it a couple of days later.. it was delicious, fresh, and no ice crystals .. great job Goldbelly.
Amie G. - Long Branch, NJ
08/10/20
The orange creamsicle Ice Cream was and is simply fantastic!! Quite likely the best in America. What went well was the perfection of the ice cream!!
Ron B. - Plantation, FL
07/22/20
So delicious!!! So creamy!!! Will definitely order again!!! Thank you!!!
karen m. - Rehoboth Beach, DE
06/03/20
The packaging was perfect..ice cream delicious. You are the best!
Pamela W. - Chandler, AZ
08/12/20
From order to perfect on time delivery: it's why I keep coming back!
Cindy C. - Titusville, FL
04/17/21
The whole enterprise was smashing. Every transaction has been a joy.
Paul M. - Kissimmee, FL
03/27/21
Ice cream arrived when promised and was not even soft! Great service
Katherine C. - Austin, TX
03/26/21
Everything. The ice cream arrived in perfect condition and it's DELICIOUS.
arthur l. - Tallahassee, FL
02/27/21
Whole process was easy. Product arrived on time and was a big hit for the birthday boy.
Bob A. - Sebastian, FL
02/19/21
These ice creams were absolutely wonderful!!!
Kathleen D. - Reading, PA
01/07/21
Packages arrived on time and the items were well packed. On one package, the ice cream was still hard. My brother said the ice cream was fantastic! Well pleased with your service and will use again. On the other package, my friends said the kringles were delicious. Thank you for the great job you provided.
Exward C. - Macomb, MI
12/31/20
EVERYTHING!!
Brittany B. - Orange City, FL
12/22/20
Delivery was awesome, and I appreciate knowing when it shipped! Always perfectly packed and delivered to the door on time. I love being able to send goodies to people--this icecream was a gift for my 12 year old nephew who was going through a second difficult and painful surgery. I can't be there, so the next best thing is sending icecream. :)
Cole P. - Huntington Beach, CA
10/14/20
Everything went smoothly! Was a great way to send a gift!!!
Betty L. - Birmingham, AL
10/14/20
It was our first Goldbelly order. It was easy and great!
- ,
12/20/20
All the food looked great and was beyond delicious according to my sister who was the lucky recipient!
Betsy P. - Navarre, FL
12/08/20