Banana Pudding Ice Cream Sandwich - 8 Pack

(Customer Reviews)

This premium ice cream sandwich starts with fresh brown sugar cookies, with sweet and decadent banana ice cream swirled with vanilla waters and vanilla pudding in between. Banana lovers rejoice!

The husband-and-wife duo of Belgian native Xavier Meers and former Marine Hannah Pollack spent years working in fine-dining kitchens before realizing that one of Pollack’s star desserts — an ice cream sandwich — was so good that they could build an entire business around it, opening Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches in 2016. These modern ice cream sandwiches are made in Richmond, Virginia, by hand, from scratch, using only the highest-quality available ingredients. Nightingale’s ice cream is super-premium and 14% butterfat, and their cookies contain only real, wholesome ingredients.

More Details

This package includes 8 Banana Pudding Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • Each sandwich measures 5.25″ × 3.75″
  • Each sandwich serves 1-2 people
  • Each sandwich is individually wrapped in adorable branded packaging perfect for a gift!


  • Banana Pudding – Milk, Cream, Liquid Sugar (Sugar, Water), Corn Syrup, Whey, Nonfat Milk, Guar Gum, Mono- And Diglycerides, Polysorbate 80, Xanthan Gum, Carrageenan], Banana Puree [Bananas, Corn Syrup, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Honey, Caramel Color, Lemon Juice From Concentrate (Water, Lemon Juice Concentrate, Sodium Benzoate (As A Preservative), Sodium Metabisulfite (As Preservative), Lemon Oil)], Vanilla Wafers [Unbleached Enriched Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Sugar, Canola Oil, Palm Oil, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Whey (From Milk), Eggs, Salt, Leavening (Baking Soda, Calcium Phosphate), Mono-and Diglycerides, Artificial And Natural Flavor, Soy Lecithin], Pudding Mix [Sugar, Modified Cornstarch, Contains Less Than 2% Of Natural And Artificial Vanilla Flavor, Salt, Disodium Phosphate And Tetrasodium Pyrophosphate (For Thickening), Mono- And Diglycerides (Prevent Foaming), Fd&C Yellow 5, Fd&C Yellow 6, Bha (Preservative)], Glucose Powder, Glycerin, Non-fat Milk Powder, Palm Kernel Oil, Milk Protein.} Brown Sugar Cookie: [Brown Sugar, Wheat Flour Enriched (Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin Folic Acid), Malted Barley Flour, Palm Oil, Whole Eggs, Natural & Artificial Vanilla Extract, Salt, Sodium Bicarbonate, Baking Powder (Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Sodium Bicarbonate, Corn Starch, Calcium Sulfate, Mono Calcium Phosphate)] Contains: Milk, Wheat, Egg, Soy.

All Products Are Produced in a Facility That Shares Common Processing Equipment and May Contain Trace Amounts of the Following: Peanuts, Soy, and/or Tree Nuts (Walnuts, Almonds, Coconut, Pecans, Pistachios, Hazelnuts).

Instructions / Storage

  • Ice Cream Sandwiches ship frozen with dry ice
  • Do Not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival remove packaging and place immediately in the freezer
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches may be stored frozen for 9 months
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches arrive frozen solid and are best enjoyed after resting for 24 hours in the freezer
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Virginia


The delivery was on time and my ice cream sandwiches were well-insulated and packed with dry ice. They were still frozen solid in spite of sitting on my very hot and sunny front stoop for almost an hour before I realized they had arrived.
Misty W. - Loveland, OH
Everything! The ice cream was deemed delicious and the cookies (brownies really) excellent so the overall ice cream sandwich experience was a hit. The shipment went to my 92 year-old mother who was jonesing for ice cream while in lockdown in a nursing facility and she really enjoyed them (as did the staff -- she couldn't resist sharing).
Marilyn F. - Hamden, CT
My niece and her family Loved the gourmet ice cream sandwiches. Thank you!!!!
Maison S. - Rio Rancho, NM
The ice cream sandwiches arrived still frozen and the dry ice still had plenty of life left in it. The sandwiches themselves are absolutely fantastic!
Jamie S. - Carver, MN
The flavor was amazing! Hit it out of the park. Thank you for making my daughters party amazing
Vicki K. - Grafton, WI
Sent to my daughter because she’s pregnant and wanted her to have some treats! She said they were fantastic and furthermore we really like supporting small business. 👍👍
Amanda L. - Silver Spring, MD
The ice cream bars were excellent! I sent 2 orders to my daughter-in-law‘s and they loved them.
Kari G. - Dewitt, MI
Yummy ice cream sandwiches, arrived on time and packaged right
Yasmine F. - Prior Lake, MN
The ice cream sandwiches were the best we ever had! They were packed perfectly. They arrived hard as a rock. Very expensive but worth it.
Patrick A. - Flagler Beach, FL
Every flavor was delicious. They're pretty big size wise for sammies so that's always a plus! Very fast shipping as well.
Vivian Yu - Tempe, AZ
Shipping was perfect and the ice cream sammich' are a million times better than expected!
Ellen F. - Las Vegas, NV
Best ever!!! Whole family enjoyed afraid I will eat the whole box...Can't do that! Have to share....
Sharon Y. - Mint Hill, NC
everything! delivered on time and frozen!
Joan D. - Tilghman, MD
Perfectly packed & arrived completely frozen even in July in the deep south! Will definitely order again!
Laura M. - Slidell, LA
Ice cream sandwiches arrived quickly and fully frozen. They were delicious and will order them again!
Debra M. - Henryville, PA
We have tried 3 flavors. They all 3 tasted fabulous! I choose to order these because they were on sale. Goldbelly is kind of like a treat for my family when when have a little extra money.
Kathi H. - Springfield, KY
The order, delivery and the product was amazing! I’m so happy my daughter told me about this site. I never heard of this before! What a great site! A person can order whatever their fancy is!
Gloria H. - Fort Lauderdale, FL
Everything! It was on time. Package was packed with care! Thanks goldbelly! 😊
Monica Y. - Buffalo Grove, IL
These ice cream sandwiches are incredible! They arrived frozen and delicious...the whole family loves them.
MONICA P. - National City, CA
Everything arrived in great condition and exceeded our wildest expectations. I can see why Duff Goldman is so well known - perfection is delicious. Wow! Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches are the best ice cream sandwiches we have ever tasted. The cookie is not too sweet, not too soft, yet, not crumbly. How do they do it? The ice cream is rich and wonderfully flavored. These are definitely on our must have again list.
Bettyarlene R. - Gardnerville, NV
Still frozen ice cream & received quickly. It's Summer now and it was properly prepped for shipping .UPS DELIVERY was at 2 pm but scanned out for delivery @5am..... It was still frozen and in great condition. We had the best treat!
Kynesha L. - Atlanta, GA
Excellent delivery!! Ice cream arrived in perfect condition, and that was all the way from VA to TX in the middle of summer!!
Kimberly R. - Sheppard AFB, TX
Best ice cream sandwiches I’ve ever had! I logged in and ordered more!
Ann W. - Caledonia, IL
Order came quickly and the delicious ice cream sandwiches when totally frozen. Everyone should try the Nightingales.
Jane L. - Boydton, VA
Everything was delivered on time and in perfect condition. I worried because I had 3 different ice cream orders going to 3 different addresses in the 90 degree heat but all 3 orders were great and much appreciated. I have never had a problem with Goldbelly.
Dave H. - Williamsburg, VA
Everything! My 92 year old Aunt was so excited to get the ice cream sandwiches! She’s unable to get to the market. Thank you
Betty K. - North Hollywood, CA
Fast shipping, customizable order (with this particular item), tasty treats!
Amanda L. - Brooklyn, NY
Fast shipping, ice still frozen solid. Great ice cream sandwiches!
Brenda K. - San Antonio, TX
Absolutely delicious. Great hit at my family’s barbecue. Great unique flavors and big were they a mouthful
zanetta s. - Detroit, MI
The communication about shipping was awesome. And the quality of my purchase was outstanding!
Rea W. - Alexandria, VA
Everything went smoothly from the ordering process and the delivery. From what I understand the ice cream was spectacular.
Kevin Z. - Tacoma, WA
Ice cream sandwiches came frozen and were delicious. They were Nightingale brand. Second time I ordered them and they are a special dessert!
Linda F. - Cary, NC
Best ice cream sandwiches ever!
Tre P. - Suffolk, VA
I ordered ice cream sandwiches and they arrived late in the day on a very hot and humid day yet they were still frozen! Very relieved!
Michelle B. - Hanover Township, PA
This is the first time I have ordered the Ice Cream Sandwiches for me. The many times I ordered them for others they absolutely loved them! I did also. So creamy and flavorful!
ken G. - Clio, MI
Ordering was easy and fast. And Great Service by getting my order Delivered in a timely fashion. I will recommend Nightingale Ice Cream to family and friends. Thanks
Nicole G. - Deer Park, TX
The ice cream sandwich assortment arrived right on time and was completely frozen. I liked how tracking was provided. The ice cream sandwiches were on a whole different level of deliciousness.
Mary O. - Roscoe, IL
Delivered on-time in great shape. This is an outstanding product that we have bought numerous times. Great quality and delicious.
George S. - Scottsdale, AZ
Everyone LOVED these ice cream sandwiches! Thanks for having these available for us to order...Will buy them again!
Justine K. - Vacaville, CA
Product arrived in good shape and was delicious as usual. This is the third time I ordered from Nightingales since it is a family favorite!
Jason E. - Jackson Hts, NY
Delivery on time and my family said the ice cream sandwiches were really good…too good actually. Lol. It was hard to not keep eating them. I would definitely order them again.
Jeannine P. - Farmington Hills, MI
Was a gift for my dad -- he loved the flavors. Item arrived very well packaged. We were worried the ice cream might be melted due to unforseen weather delays but it arrived just perfect!
David O. - Houston, TX
On time, in perfect condition. I thought because I had ordered ice cream sandwiches, they might have been a little melted. They were perfect!
Talia S. - Charlottesville, VA
I have ordered these twice already and I really love them, very tasty and they do the trick when I’m in the mood for a sinful treat.
Louie G. - Flushing, NY
From the beginning of the order to the end when my order was sent out for delivery, everything was Perfect! The tracking was easy to follow! And it was delivered on the day they told me it would arrive. Couldn't have gone any smoother! Thank you Goldbelly!
Sean M. - Hyde Park, NY
Ice cream sandwiches were huge & delicious!!
ryan f. - Fort Mill, SC
You got ICE CREAM SANDWICHES in perfect condition from coast to coast for my friend’s birthday! Bravo!
Ann B. - Everett, WA