Choose Your Own Sampler Cheesecake - 9"
From The Nuns of New Skete

(
 4.9)

Calling all cheesecake lovers! For the first time ever you can choose 4 of your favorite New Skete cheesecake flavors in one cake!

This small monastery in upstate New York is producing what many believe to be the finest cheesecakes in the country all made by hand by the sisters. In between daily prayers, the nuns make a limited number of cheesecakes each day, just as they’ve done for nearly four decades. They’ve been featured on the Rachael Ray Show as well as The New York Times.

FREE SHIPPING to New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Vermont.

More Details

  • Each Sampler Cheesecake is approximately 9" and weights 4lbs
  • Cheesecake arrives pre-sliced in 16 slices
  • All flavors are subject to availability

FREE SHIPPING to New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Vermont.

Choose 4 slices from each of the following flavors:

  • Amaretto and Cream Cheesecake
  • Gluten Free New York Cheesecake
  • Chocolate Cheesecake
  • Chocolate Amaretto Cheesecake
  • Deluxe New York Cheesecake
  • Irish Cream Cheesecake
  • Key Lime Cheesecake
  • Raspberry Ripple Cheesecake
  • Raspberry Chocolate Cheesecake
  • White Chocolate Cheesecake
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake
  • Kahlua Cheesecake

Ingredients

May contain: milk, wheat, soy, egg, tree nut

Instructions / Storage

  • Cheesecakes are shipped frozen on ice packs and will arrive frozen or slightly thawed.
  • Cheesecakes thaw in refrigerator 2-4 hours or on the countertop for 1-2 hours.
  • Cheesecakes can be frozen for up to 6 months.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • New Skete Monastery ships Monday-Thursday of each week
  • FREE SHIPPING to New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Vermont. There is an additional ship charge for the rest of the country.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii will incur an additional charge of $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     

More from New York

  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     

(
 4.9) REVIEWS

It was a gift for my father, and he says that it was up to the exacting standards set by the nuns. He expects me to purchase one for him for every important occasion! Everything was perfectly done. The packaging was quite impressive!
Joseph H. - Cohoes, NY
08/21/19
Brandied Fruitcake was delicious! Best one I’ve ever had except grandma’s!
Bea P. - Las Vegas, NV
11/13/19
Nuns of New Skete variety cheesecake was packaged very well and the best cheesecake I have ever had! It arrived frozen with ice packs in a large cooler. Another nice feature was their use of parchment paper to separate each slice of cheesecake which made it easy to take a couple slices frozen for later evening and yet keep the rest frozen!
Vicki E. - Fayetteville, GA
11/18/19
Had a cheesecake before from the Nuns. Ordering again for Thanksgiving!
Margaret M. - Roslyn, PA
11/16/19
First fruitcake I’ve had in years that reminds me of those my grandmother and aunt used to make. They’re of course were perfect blends of cake, fruit, nuts and rum or brandy. These from the nuns of New Skete are very close. I love fruitcake and have tried dozens over the years. This one is definitely going to be ordered again for Christmas and beyond.
Lee F. - Windsor, CT
11/13/19
The cheesecake is amazing, the shipping is exactly as I want it to be - on time and with no damage to the packaging (and therefore to the food)!
Barb K. - Davenport, IA
11/01/19
I am giving a rating a 10 Excellent product and delivery, thank you!
Christina B. - Thomasville, PA
11/18/19
The flavor was fantastic. It had so many fruit and nuts all through the Fruitcake. Loved it!
Susie H. - Port Washington, WI
12/01/19
My order was delivered the day before Thanksgiving just as I requested. The cheesecake came precut so it was ready to serve. It was delicious.
Jane L. - Manchester, NH
12/02/19
Moist, loaded with fruits and nuts, I knew the fruitcake was a winner after I tasted it. Probably the best I've ever had.
Joseph G. - Southampton, NJ
12/19/19
Cheesecake was great, and have only had one of the three gourmet cheese spreads. Small batches made by the Nuns of New Skete are extraordinary. I had ordered a cheesecake for a friend as well. She loved it.
Judith A. - Essex, CT
12/02/19
The cheesecake from New Skete are the best I have ever tasted. I have been a fan of cheesecake for many years and when traveling, I frequently order cheesecake at the restaurants. Everyone who has a piece practically fall over themselves in giving praise for the flavor and texture of these cheesecakes. Do yourself, your, friends and family a huge favor by allowing them to experience these cheesecakes for themselves. My favorite is the chocolate raspberry. Ordering the cheesecakes through Goldbelly is easy. The cheesecakes arrived exactly on the day they were expected, carefully packed and ready to be enjoyed. I have given one to my fellow employees where I work, and they all quickly divided the cheesecake and took some home to their families.
Timothy P. - Cumberland, MD
12/18/19
The cheesecakes are GREAT!
Evie D. - Stowe, VT
12/27/19
I loved the cheesecake from the Nuns of New Skete. It is creamy and delicious. I love that I can refreeze it and enjoy it for weeks after. I served it at a Christmas dinner party and everyone loved it, too.
Glenda G. - Putney, VT
12/26/19
Prompt delivery to friends, Cheesecake from Nuns of New Skete was superb!
Father T. - Rancho Santa Margarita, CA
12/19/19
This was sent as a gift to a family member last year and she loved it so much, we sent it again this year to her.
MaryAnn N. - Van Buren Point, NY
12/28/19
Everything I have ordered from Goldbelly has been excellent! From cheesecakes, fruitcakes, pastrami, etc. Never had a problem with quality!
Alicia G. - Alpena, MI
12/22/19
It arrived on its due date, the shipping packaging was perfect! It arrived cold! And it taste GREAT !
Antonia P. - Walls, MS
12/26/19
Easy ordering process- lots of variety to choose from. Quick shipping. The actual cheesecake was well packaged/labeled, and the presentation is beautiful! Great product!! Will be ordering from Goldbelly again in the future.
Melissa L. - West Haven, CT
12/24/19
First fruitcake I’ve had in years that reminds me of those my grandmother and aunt used to make. They’re of course were perfect blends of cake, fruit, nuts and rum or brandy. These from the nuns of New Skete are very close. I love fruitcake and have tried dozens over the years. This one is definitely going to be ordered again for Christmas and beyond.
Lee F. - Windsor, CT
11/24/19
The cheesecake was delicious and fresh, ordering was easy, and delivery was prompt.
Edna S. - Staten Island, NY
02/06/20
Very good, creamy, not heavy. The Kahlua flavor was FABULOUS!!!
Deborah C. - Willow Grove, PA
02/09/20
Order arrived when expected and honestly, it was the best chocolate cheesecake I've ever tasted. It was purchased to celebrate a friend's birthday; and when she tasted it, she pronounced it "Fit for Jehovah!" Can't get much better praise than that. All things considered, the experience was a winner all around. Thanks so much for a truly exceptional treat!
Jean R. - Concord, NH
02/12/20
Absolute best cheesecake ever! Delivered on time, and packed to stay cold. I have already recommended this to friends. Will be ordering again soon.
Shelly W. - Sheridan, MI
02/19/20
This was one of the best cheesecakes we have ever eaten. Being from Jersey, we know cheesecake. The cake was for my sister's birthday and she loved it! No doubt, it's expensive, but you get what you pay for. So, most likely, will be using Goldbelly again for other good things from the northeast. So thanks to the Sisters for making great cheesecake and Goldbelly for making it so easy to have things shipped.
Susan S. - Davenport, FL
03/09/20
Delivery was right on time and the cheesecake was fabulous. The Nuns of New Skete make a wonderful product and my husband loved the cheesecake.
Sandra G. - Phoenix, AZ
12/14/21
Easy to use site with lots of choices for unique and hard to find food items
Katie H. - Harker Heights, TX
12/15/21
Customer service was excellent when I asked if my order was still on track for delivery. The rep explained the process for the pick up time at the New Skete Monestary, and when it would appear on my tracking. All went exactly as she explained and the delivery was prompt.
MacNiven F. - Los Angeles, CA
12/21/21
I sent Raspberry Ripple cheesecakes to many family and friends this Christmas, and all were unanimous in their over the top compliments! Now I'll never again be stuck without an idea for a gift....Just send the Raspberry Ripple...Problem solved!
Brian A. - Blairstown, NJ
12/31/21
It got delivered on time and was not damaged. Picture perfect and a lovely experience!
Dominic C. - Sparks Glencoe, MD
01/01/22
Very easy to order and the cheesecake was a huge hit! My family absolutely loved it.
Donna N. - Reno, NV
01/03/22
Everything arrived on time, and it was delicious. Everyone enjoyed the cheesecake and the fruitcake! Would highly recommend the Nuns of Skete!
Deborah M. - Branchburg, NJ
01/04/22
Cheesecakes are outstanding...delivery was perfect.
Kathy M. - Kinnelon, NJ
01/08/22
Arrived right on time in great condition. It was a birthday “cake” for my son and he said it is the BEST gluten free cheesecake that he ever tasted! Thanks so much!
Kathleen B. - Middletown, NY
01/16/22
The very best bakery products and was shipped very quickly.
Janet B. - Bowling Green, KY
01/31/22
The Nuns of New Skete are FANTASTIC!!!!!! We LOVE the Nuns!!!!
Anne C. - Sedona, AZ
02/12/22
The products are consistantly delicious and high quality.
Dolores P. - Uniontown, PA
02/10/22
The website was easy to use. The food descriptions were clear. The ordering process was easy. The cheesecake was fantastic!
Priya T. - Cleveland, OH
02/20/22
The product is delicious and arrived on time.
Bonnie C. - Naples, FL
03/13/22
Arrived exactly as stated. Ice packs still very cold.
Debra H. - Visalia, CA
03/11/22
Everything was the perfect temperature🌡️
Ian J. - Los Angeles, CA
03/09/22
Packaged very well to stay cold and without any problems. The cheesecake was the BEST I’ve ever had and I’ve had a lot. I’m sorry it’s finished and can’t wait to have another.
Margaret W. - Denver, NC
03/04/22
I was able (from Los Angeles) to send cheesecake made by nuns on the East Coast, to my mother in Iowa! So cool!
Diane F. - Council Bluffs, IA
02/28/22
Package arrived in perfect condition and my recipient absolutely loved it!
Vanessa M. - Oxnard, CA
02/18/22
It arrived precisely when promised, it was packaged well, and tasted deliciously fresh.
Amy H. - Hamden, CT
02/19/22