The Godfadda

Millburn Deli ships its famous The Godfadda nationwide on Goldbelly! While best known for their Jersey-style “Slopping Joe’s”, Millburn Deli’s almost-as-famous Godfadda sandwich is a show-stopper in its own right. Featuring breaded chicken cutlets, bacon, fresh mozz, and homemade Russian dressing on a grilled sub roll, this sandwich-meal hits the spot.

Since 1946, the Millburn Deli has been slinging legendary oversize sandwiches. Founded by Norbert Jacobs, the Millburn, New Jersey, deli is best known for their Jersey-style Sloppy Joe, a triple-decker sandwich with meat, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on rye bread.

More Details

  • Choose between 2, 4, or 6 Godfadda Sandwiches


Breaded Chicken Cutlets, Bacon, Fresh Mozzarella, and Homemade Russian dressing on a grilled Sub Roll

Instructions / Storage

  • Sandwiches arrive via next day delivery and should be placed in the fridge if not going to be eaten immediately
  • Enjoy within 2 days

Optional Heating Instructions

Oven (recommended):

  • Preheat oven to 350-F
  • Remove Godfadda sandwich from paper wrapping and wrap with aluminum foil
  • Heat on center oven rack for 15 to 18 minutes


  • Remove Godfadda sandwich from paper wrapping, place on a plate
  • Heat in the microwave for 60 seconds
  • If desired, heat for additional 15-second increments until desired temperature is reached

Shipping Details

  • Millburn Deli ships Monday-Thursday
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New Jersey


Luv Millburn Deli Sloppy Joe’s! It tastes like home.
Colleen B. - Granite Bay, CA
Millburn deli sloppy joes are the best!
Cheryl S. - Clarksville, TN
My sandwiches were just as I remembered them from chowing down in high school—PERFECT. They were cold, not soggy, and delish.
Judy M. - Jackson Heights, NY
Delivery as promised and my friends were surprised and thrilled. Thank you.
Catharine S. - Littleton, CO
Delivery arrived as promised, well packaged.
Francis C. - Pittsburgh, PA
Arrived on time as promised Great getting food from some of my favorite restaurants back home.
Arthur L. - West Palm Beach, FL
This is my second order from Millburn Deli. The first was sloppy joes for my family in NC (native NJ) and the second was to send sloppy joes to my Father, his wife and my sister in FL (all native NJ). This is a taste of home. Anyone who has not experienced a NJ sloppy joe should do so!
Christine K. - Mount Dora, FL
Sandwhiches were the real deal. Lasted three more days so I could spread out the joy.
James C. - Eastsound, WA
The Jersey Sloppy Joes were awesome! Both pastrami and corned beef were delicious, and not fatty or salty. I will order again.
Jason D. - Lytle Creek, CA
Everything went well! Easy ordering, delivery went smoothly! But then when I asked a question about getting extra russian dressing, Goldbelly referred my question to Andrew Morgan of Millburn Deli and he reached out to me on Facebook and said he will see what he could do! Bottomline I did receive my extra russian dressing 😁 Goldbelly and Millburn Deli went way above and beyond to make this woman very happy! MANY MANY THANKS!
Donna Z. - North Brunswick, NJ
A great trip down memory lane for my father who grew up in Millburn but hasnt had a "Joe" for 30 years. He loved every bite
Lance/Jan H. - Lake Mary, FL
Delivery on time, great customer service, food was perfect. The food was purchased as a gift and the surprised reactions from my family when they opened sandwiches they grew up with was by far the highlight of Christmas.
Julia P. - Pittsburgh, PA
Everything was excellent delivered on time, and my God the Millburn Deli sandwich just as I remembered. Nothing had changed with the Sloppy Joe sandwich.
Michele C. - Charlotte, NC