Little Pie Company now ships its legendary Key Lime Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! A food critics’ favorite, Little Pie Company’s sweet-tart Key lime pie is made from real Key lime juice. Smooth and creamy with a rich graham-cracker crust, this Key Lime Pie the ultimate taste of the tropics.
What started out as a side business for Broadway actor Arnold Wilkerson has since become a bona fide smash hit. This small pie shop first opened in NYC’s Theater District in 1985, but his baked goods were soon recognized as among the best in New York City.
More Details
This package serves 8-10 people and includes 1 Key Lime Pie
- Each pie measures 10"
- Product price includes additional labor + packaging costs that go into nationwide shipping
Instructions / Storage
- All pies from Little Pie Company should be refrigerated and enjoyed for up to 3 days or wrapped in aluminum foil and stored in the freezer for up to one month.
- Defrost overnight in the refrigerator.
To Serve
- Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
- Enjoy!
Shipping Details
- Little Pie Company ships Monday-Friday of each week
- Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
- Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii will incur an additional $35 charge for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
- Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Corporate Gift Orders
You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.
Recommended for you
More from New York
( 4.8) Little Pie Company REVIEWS
This cheesecake was one of the best cheesecakes we have ever tasted! And we have tasted a lot of cheesecakes! Arrived packaged very well in a lot of cold ice and still frozen! So good!
Jessica S. - Kingston, WA
10/27/22
You make an amazing pie. You deliver it when you say you will. And what’s not to like? Thank you. A great service for sharing comfort and sharing love when you cannot be there with a homemade pie.
Teri M. - Cicero, IN
10/27/22
The unsweetened apple pie was delicious. The apple pie was just right with very little sugar or no sugar. The pie 🥧 crust was soft . The apples in the pie was juicy and warm from the microwave.
Patricia D. - Brooklyn, NY
10/27/22
I ordered this for a friend’s birthday. She said they arrived packed securely and tasted delicious.
Elizabeth W. - Atlantic Beach, NY
10/27/22
Everyone enjoyed the pies. The sampler is a great way to taste several pies.
Tara W. - Greenfield, IN
10/27/22
My friends said it was delicious.
Mike S. - New York, NY
10/27/22
This pie is one of the most delicious pies I’ve ever had the pleasure of eating! So many apples and the top walnut crust is devine!
Patricia S. - Westerville, OH
10/27/22
Less sugar, excellent crust, lots of apples! Excellent!
Debra C. - Temple, TX
10/27/22
We enjoyed the quality of the dessert. It thoroughly pleased our palate!!
EDWIN C. - Louisville, KY
10/27/22
The Little Pie Company order arrived on time, perfectly packaged and a gift for an old friend who said it was delicious. I love Little Pie Company. They're my first choice when I want an excellent pie. This was a win-win situation, great pie, outstanding service from Goldbelly !
EMMA D. - Hempstead, NY
10/27/22
It was a gift for a friend, who said even the box smelled wonderful. What a great first impression. And, of course, it was delicious, and it arrived as promised.
Pat L. - Montauk, NY
10/27/22
I enjoyed the happiness my husband displayed when receiving his Happy Birthday Mississippi Mud Pie. He had requested this pie for his birthday this year. This was the third year that he has celebrated his birthday with a Mississippi Mud Pie! This marvelous pie brings much joy!
Sandra E. - Madison, GA
10/27/22
Hands down, best pie I have ever eaten!
Dawn W. - Hilton Head Island, SC
10/27/22
Absolutely everything from ordering (easy) to delivery (well packed and arrived fresh) and taste was perfect.
Pamela B. - Escanaba, MI
10/27/22
The pie was great! This is a tart pie, not overly sweet.
Norma P. - Rockwall, TX
10/27/22
This is my husband's favorite pie - I always get it for him on his birthday. Consistently great!
Tejal V. - Long Grove, IL
10/27/22
This has to be the best apple pie I have ever tasted. It is stuffed with apples and the perfect blend of spices. The crust is to die for. I am so glad to have ordered this and to share it. It is a huge hit!
Susan G. - Westminster, CO
10/08/19
It is a chocolate lovers dream come true, so delicious.
Dolores M. - Brooklyn, NY
11/11/19
Pumpkin pie perfection! 🙂👍🏻
Cary G. - Brooklyn, NY
11/07/19
Great pies. Excellent service
Rachel M. - Bellingham, WA
11/11/19
Shipping packaging was PERFECT! All of my southern friends said that it was the best that they had EVER tasted!
Scott C. - Charlotte, NC
11/11/19
Came packaged well. I'm glad as that was what I was concerned about, the handling by package delivery companies. The size was larger than I envisioned and that was wonderful. The pie tasted perfect
Sylvia W. - San Antonio, TX
11/05/19
The Mississippi Mud Pie was delicious and fresh.
Tanya F. - Birmingham, AL
11/03/19
"It was as if my grandmother made it, which is the highest praise I could give something. Their pie was delicious in every way, and was definitely the highlight of our Thanksgiving meal, which also happened to be my fathers 91st birthday! It was heaven warm with ice-cream, and the next day I had a piece chilled with whip cream... both were heaven."
Marla R. - Hawarden, IA
12/03/19
The pie was packed perfectly and arrived as scheduled. It was delicious warmed up with a dollop of vanilla ice cream.
Charlotte S. - Houston, TX
12/02/19
Every holiday I order this pie and am never disappointed. Delivery was perfect and everyone at my Thanksgiving loved it.
Greg K. - Arlington, TX
12/02/19
Customer service was great! Ordering was great, taste was great.
The F. - Norfolk, MA
12/02/19
The pie is always amazing, however, it was half the size from when I ordered probably a decade ago...so although the taste was magnificent, purchasing it no longer feels appropriate for the expense.
Chris K. - Gilbert, AZ
12/02/19
It is an excellent pie and it always puts a smile on my Honey’s face. It has a nice smooth filling and loads of pecans. it also has an excellent flavor.
Johnnie C. - Rock Hill, SC
01/23/20
Great products I can’t get anywhere locally. Delivered when promised and packaging in great condition.
Madelynn B. - Bear, DE
12/02/19
The pies were delicious and arrived on time and in perfect condition! We will order from you again very soon.
Joni K. - College Grove, TN
12/02/19
Super thin apple slices with sour cream and a cinnamon walnut topping to die for. Best apple pie ever and agreed by all. Served with vanilla ice cream. Worth every penny. It was scrumptious!!!!!
Deborah C. - Staten Island, NY
12/26/19
My son is a pecan pie connoisseur, and he loved the pie from Little Pie Company. He ate the entire pie himself, over a few days.
Mark/Rhiannon W. - Ridgefield, WA
12/26/19
The packaging is so stable not a break in the crust! I ordered this for Christmas and everyone loved the tartness of apples with the crumb topping and excellent crust! Will definitely order again!
Stephen M. - Southold, NY
12/26/19
Seriously good! Be sure to heat the pie up!
Jennifer F. - Rye, NY
12/28/19
Delivery as promised, directions clear and EVERYONE loved the Sour cream walnut apple pie!
Karen B. - Kemah, TX
12/24/19
The best apple pie I have ever had, I have ordered it several times always great! It’s what I look foreword to the most during the holidays.
Charles G. - Sonoma, CA
12/25/19
The order was sent as a gift. It arrived on time and the recipient thought it was great!!
Sean C. - Fruitport, MI
12/30/19
The sour cream apple pie was the absolute best pie we have ever eaten. There were four of us and we all agreed. The best ever!
James M. - Olympia, WA
01/06/20
The Mississippi Mud Pie was even better than advertised, and was so rich I couldn't finish the last bite. I'm a chocolate addict, but this was total chocolate immersion into another universe. Arrived here in perfect condition, when I was told it would, and exceeded my greatest expectations. Everything I ordered for friends blew them all away which pleased me to no end and want to thank all involved for your efforts, and know that you made a number of good folks very happy!
Douglas S. - Mulberry, FL
01/13/20
A chocolate lovers dream come true, so delicious
Joseph D. - Brooklyn, NY
11/21/19
Little Pie Company had the best homemade apple pie ever ♡
Christina D. - Lake Lotawana, MO
03/11/20
Delivery was as promised and the pies were delicious!
Tiffany Wu - Santa Monica, CA
04/06/21
Excellent quality of gluten fre pie! Enjoyed by everyone for Easter dessert, even though all did not need gluten free.
Glenn B. - Boynton Beach, FL
04/06/21
Delivery was just before Easter ,the taste was good especially the walnut and cinnamon topping!!!
Gloria E. - Oconomowoc, WI
04/05/21
Everything went well. The packaging was perfect. The pie was perfectly made, not to mention delicious. It was the perfect Easter dessert.
Geraldine A. - Coral Gables, FL
04/04/21
The pie came exactly when expected, came with instructions, a beautiful brochure about their other products and was DELICIOUS!
beth b. - Columbus, OH
03/25/21
The pie was delivered on time, I was notified in real time that it had arrived at their doorstep, and our donor family (I work for a math nonprofit and we wanted to thank them for their generosity) found it to be DELICIOUS!
Don B. - Corona del Mar, CA
03/22/21
Product was delivered on time and was exactly as expected.
Thomas P. - Cinnaminson, NJ
05/17/21
Oh my goodness, the whole experience!! The service was awesome, the shipping, the delicious food!! Thank you ever so much.
Dee M. - Anchorage, AK
05/13/21
The food was very delicious. It looked exactly as expected based on the picture. Quality was excellent. I will be buying again from others to try them out. Customer service was exceptional. They responded and resolved my issue quickly.
Wandra M. - Jacksonville, FL
07/25/21
Delivery on date requested and she loved the cheesecake. Best she has ever had- rich and creamy.
Korri R. - Ruidoso, NM
07/19/21
Great efficient packaging. Everything was still cool. And, it's Texas in July.
Bobbie M. - Mesquite, TX
07/13/21
Bam! Their Peach Pie never disappoints!
Seth M. - La Jolla, CA
07/05/21
Bought a gift for my father's birthday. He called to let me know the pies arrived and expressed not only how good they were but how impressive the packaging was.
John Jr - Mount Pleasant, SC
07/03/21
Almost everything went well. The product, itself, was up to its usual high standard. Before I discovered the Little Pie Company, the best apple pie I ever ate was that prepared by Helen Corbitt, the chief chef of Neiman-Marcus's Zodiac Room, the restaurant on the top floor of the original N-M founded in 1907 by Herbert Marcus and Carry Neiman in Dallas, Texas. All other apple pies I've eaten are too sweet, too watery, or the apples are mealy and mushy. But the Little Pie Company, like Corbitt, has somehow figured out how to avoid these problems. This is THE most consistent food product I've ever bought. It never varies in quality. Frankly, I don't know how they do it. You would think I'd get a clunker once, but you would be wrong if you thought that.
Tom G. - San Marcos, TX
06/26/21
Delicious foods and nice presentation when delivered. Super handy for gifts, especially when we are houseguests, nice to send the hosts the food for a thank you
Brenda B. - Portland, OR
06/26/21
Ordering was super simple, delivery was fast, and the pies were delicious!
Tanya A. - Newbury, OH
09/20/21
Delicious product and great delivery
Lexie F. - Elizabeth, PA
09/20/21
Cheesecake was delicious. I ordered late and needed it for a family event. From the order to tracking and receiving, all went perfect. I will definitely be ordering again.
Cathy L. - Evansville, IN
09/13/21
Everything was shipped and delivered on time. Food was great!
Tara K. - Goshen, IN
09/16/21
The pie arrived on time as expected and was perfectly packed as I had hoped. I would definitely order again.
Terry L. - Orinda, CA
09/13/21
Excellent packaging , food delicious , little pie co. Kept me posted as to my order, fast delivery . Love little pie co.
Patrice M. - Whitehall, PA
09/07/21
Delivery was prompt and this gorgeous apple pie was intact and orgasmically delicious!! 🤤 Will definitely be ordering again.
Pete S. - Calverton, NY
09/05/21
The pie arrived exactly on time and it was packaged better than any other item I have ever ordered. The pie was in perfect condition.
Claudia C. - Estero, FL
11/28/21
My order (salted caramel apple pie) came 2 days early so my son could have it on his 27th Thanksgiving Birthday and he said it’s the best he’s ever had!
Susan S. - Prospect, KY
11/28/21
The pot pies arrived on Time & were wrapped really well. I shared one with my neighbor. The pot pies were really delicious. Thanks so much
Randi R. - Ashburn, VA
12/13/21
First time ordering , my pies arrived on time and they where D-lish .. my family loved them , we will definitely order again... thank you guys, we love them ❤ keep up the fabulous job 👏👏👏👏👏
Elizabeth M. - Suffolk, VA
12/07/21
The packaging especially the apple 🍎 pie. The Little Pie Company is consistent with the quality shipping with ice pack.
EUNICE D. - Houston, TX
12/05/21
Everything! The pie was properly insulated, kept frozen with the ice pack, arrived on time…. My first experience was PERFECT!
Mrs W. - East Stroudsburg, PA
12/24/21
Ordering was easy, communication was great, shipped fast and the cheesecake was excellent!!! I will be ordering again!!! I highly recommend!!!
KRISTINA H. - Portland, ME
12/24/21
Everything went perfect from shipping and communication in between to The delivery being right on point and let’s not forget the amazing pie that everyone was moaning over while eating it at Christmas! Couldn’t have been better! 👍🏻
Nancy K. - Long Beach, CA
12/26/21
I send these pies to my Aunt Betty, who raves and says these are the best pies she has EVER had in her 78 years. She was so impressed with the REAL apples. Too cute. Will order again!
Betty R. - Millville, NJ
12/26/21
We loved the restaurant/bakery options. The whole process was so easy. The items were delivered early....and were fresh and in great shape. Great experience.
Melissa W. - Charlotte, NC
12/26/21
The pie was delicious! I can see why it’s an editor’s choice...
Gordon L. - Stockton, CA
04/18/22
I am so happy I discovered Goldbelly. They have a FANTASTIC selection of any kind of food you'd enjoy. Such an easy way to get different foods. Delivery was prompt and product was secure. I'm a customer for life!!!
Pamela R. - East Moline, IL
08/14/22
Sent as a present and was well received. Delivered on time.
Patrick C. - New York, NY
09/16/22
Delivery was on time and the recipient loved the pie.
Rebecca J. - Havertown, PA
07/09/22
The pecan pie was delicious!
Lori H. - Moreland Hills, OH
07/05/22
Ordering, delivery, quality of food -- everything was great. We love Goldbelly!
Dr. M. - Northridge, CA
07/03/22
Everything went very well. My recipients LOVED the Little Pies...
Loeber M. - Santa Fe, NM
07/02/22
Pies were delivered timely and in great shape. They are delicious also.
Saundra C. - Mount Laurel, NJ
06/25/22
The Chicken Pot Pies were AMAZING!!!!! The BEST we've had - and that's saying something as we've tried plenty elsewhere!! Worth every penny!!!
DICK W. - Naples, FL
06/21/22
From product quality to actual delivery, Goldbelly came through again. All outstanding!
Mary K. - Stonington, CT
06/20/22
Everything went well from placing the order, receiving the pie, great instructions for serving, delicious treat. Thanks to all along the way!
Leslie C. - Norwell, MA
05/30/22
Pies were delivered well packed and still cold!
Allison H. - Asheville, NC
06/05/22