Mexican Chocolate Pecan Pie + Ice Cream

La Newyorkina ships its Mexican Chocolate Pecan Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! Enjoy this take on an American classic, loaded with lots of pecans and a decadent Mexican chocolate filling and ice cream!

Fany Gerson launched La Newyorkina in 2010 in Brooklyn, New York, after an inspiring trip to her native Mexico. When she returned to New York, she knew she wanted to share and celebrate the amazing Mexican desserts she rediscovered on her trip. Sourcing the best possible ingredients from both New York and Mexico, Gerson first made paletas (Mexican popsicles). Now La Newyorkina makes a wide range of sweet Mexican treats, including cheesecakes, ice cream, and traditional panadería-style baked goods.

More Details

This package serves 10 people and includes a

  • 9" Mexican Chocolate Pecan Pie
  • 2 pints of Ice Cream, your choice
  • Each Pie weighs 3 lbs.

Ice Cream Options Include

  • Oaxacan Chocolate – For the chocolate lovers, this ice cream is made with delicious chocolate from Oaxaca and chunks of Mexican chocolate and a touch of cinnamon.
  • Chiapas Coffee – Deep coffee ice cream with salted goat’s milk caramel, great for coffee lovers!
  • Horchata – One of our favorite beverages from Mexico turned into ice cream!!! This flavor is made with toasted rice, almonds, and cinnamon.
  • Mexican Vanilla – Classic flavor made with vanilla beans from Papantla, Mexico.
  • Coco Choco – Toasted coconut ice cream with Belgian bittersweet chocolate “chips”
  • Tres Leches – Creamy ice cream inspired by traditional Mexican milk cake!


  • Mexican Chocolate Pecan Pie – Pecan, Mexican Chocolate, 60% Chocolate, Butter, Eggs, Milk, Flour, Baking Powder, Kosher Salt
  • Horchata -Heavy Cream, Cane Sugar, Natural Stabilizers, Milk Powder, Almond, Mexican Cinnamon, Carolina Rice, Kosher Salt
  • Oaxacan Chocolate – Heavy Cream, Cane Sugar, Natural Stabilizers, Milk Powder, 60% Chocolate, Mexican Chocolate, Mexican Cinnamon, Kosher Salt
  • Chiapas Coffee – Heavy Cream, Cane Sugar, Natural Stabilizers, Milk Powder, Mexican Coffee, Goats Milk Caramel, Kosher Salt
  • Tres Leches – Heavy Cream, Cane Sugar, Natural Stabilizers, Milk Powder, Tres Leches Cake (Wheat, Baking Powder, Egg, Milk, Cane Sugar, Kosher Salt, Condensed Milk, Evaporated Milk)
  • Coco Choco – Heavy Cream, Cane Sugar, Natural Stabilizers, Milk Powder. Desiccated Coconut, 60% Chocolate, 100% Chocolate, Butter, Kosher Salt, Baking Powder

Instructions / Storage

  • Pie + Ice Cream ships frozen with dry ice; may thaw in transit.
  • DO NOT remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival, pie can be kept frozen for up to 1 month
  • To serve, remove from packaging and allow an hour to thaw prior to cutting and serving.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • La Newyorkina ships Monday – Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


Delivery went well, food was delicious according to the person I sent it to
Mary G. - Saint Louis, MO
The goodies were good especially the chocolate matso.
Stefanie R. - Albuquerque, NM
We love Goldbelly! Easy to navigate website and fast check out! The items were nicely packaged and shipped super fast. Recipients were beyond thrilled and enjoyed it! Thank you!
Jeff K. - Eldersburg, MD
Arrived on time, great flavor
Mitchell R. - Loomis, CA
Arrived on time. Ice cream and churros traveled from nyc to Boston and all was perfect!
Russell Z. - Boston, MA
From start to finish everything was great. Site is easy to use, customer service and delivery! This was the first time using this service, would do it again! Ordered from La New Yorkina and that was simply amazing too!
Kayla R. - Bronx, NY
On time delivery. Was sent as a gift & the feedback was that the churros & ice cream were fantastic!
Familia L. - Midlothian, VA
Arrived when requested and frozen. The only problem were the lids for the ice cream were lose, but other than that - perfect!
Steve S. - Vienna, VA
The Rosca de Reyes was excellent.
Emily L. - Marblehead, MA
Everything! The ordering was easy. Goldbelly followed up with an order conformation. They kept me informed of when the package would arrive. It arrived on time well insolated and in excellent condition!
katie a. - Somers, NY
Delivered as expected and as always ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. Goldbelly connects us to the best of the best food experiences each and every time we order.
Maureen L. - Flintstone, GA
delivery was on time and cake was good
Lena R. - Ayer, MA
mary m. - White Plains, NY
the delivery was on time and the ice cream cake arrived perfectly !!
Olga A. - Miami, FL
Everything from easy ordering to the excellent delivery and packaging
Julie W. - Denver, CO
Timely delivery of all orders. Instructions for at-home preparations were easy to follow. Food was delicious
Natasha L. - Southbury, CT
Food delivered on time and in good condition
EMILY S. - Diamondhead, MS
Came as promised and the ice cream cake was wonderful
Richard S. - Port Clinton, OH
My 11 year old grandnephew ate 6 churros immediately on arrival. My nephew who was the recipient, along with the 14 year old both had the ice cream sandwich. It was a hit birthday present.
James J. - Lafayette, CO