Choose-Your-Own 4 Killer Brownies® in a Tin

+ Free Shipping

It’s not just a clever name; the Killer Brownie® truly is like nothing else you’ve ever tasted! In the mood for something big, rich, and chocolatey? This triple-layered treat is Dorothy Lane’s most popular sweet by far.

Their exclusive, multi-layered brownies are big (each weighs approximately 1/3 lb.), gooey, and rich — the ultimate treat for the most discriminating chocoholic.

More Details

  • This package includes 4 brownies in a wonderfully branded gift tin
  • Each brownie weighs approximately 1/3 lb.

Flavor Options Include

  • “The Original” Killer Brownie® features multiple layers of chocolate brownie; rich, gooey caramel; and chopped pecans.
  • “Peanut Butter” Killer Brownies® Picture an Original with peanuts and peanut butter added. Now, take a bite and savor!
  • “German Chocolate Killer Brownies® This is the only brownie in the Killer Brownie® family that is made without caramel. Instead, this one is topped with German Chocolate icing containing coconut, almonds, and pecans.
  • “Cookie Dough” Killer Brownies® They add extra chocolate chips to this form of the Original Killer Brownie and skip the nuts. Experience a homemade taste of chocolate chip cookies.
  • “Blonde Ambition” Killer Brownies Macadamia nuts, Heath mix, and white chocolate added to caramel and a blonde brownie make this one a winner!
  • The Salted Caramel Killer Brownie® sprinkles a touch of coarse sea salt in the center layer of rich caramel. This triple layer chocolate brownie is full of pecans and is finished with a dusting of decorative sugar and chocolate shavings.
  • Cookies & Cream Old-fashioned chocolate cookie mixed with the caramel flavors and sweet cream.
  • Confetti a blonde brownie infused with their signature layer of caramel with white chocolate chips and colorful sprinkles
  • Raspberry These are made with layers of mouth-watering caramel, white chocolate chips, and a generous layer of raspberry in the middle of chocolaty brownies.

Instructions / Storage

Each brownie is made-to-order, wrapped, carefully packed and picked up for immediate shipment. Depending on the season, this product may ship with ice packs, which may have partially (or fully) melted during shipment. This is normal. Store brownies in tin at room temperature for 3-4 days.

To freeze brownies, cover in plastic wrap and place in a freezer-safe container. Brownies will last up to 6 months. When ready to serve, place in refrigerator to thaw.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Orders placed by 10am Monday-Friday will ship same day.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Ohio


My son said the brownies were “earth shattering!” Can’t get better than that, can you?
Adam H. - Cedar Park, TX
Killer is the appropriate descriptor! These brownies are the best! They are rich and chocolatey and the caramel filling layer is awesome. They arrived fresh and very well packed. My faves!
Susan G. - Westminster, CO
AWESOME, Excellent Brownies. The best brownies I have ever had. Nothing compares.
Anthony B. - Coeur D Alene, ID
It was convenient and delivery was fast. I received my brownies in excellent condition!
Connie H. - Sacramento, CA
The convenience, the ease and the quality were very good! They were packaged very nice as well! I already have plans to send a few as Christmas gifts to friends!
Diane G. - Pensacola, FL
The service was great and the brownies were outstanding!
Mary G. - Childress, TX
The brownies were incredibly fresh and delicious. I highly recommend the Chocolate Peanut Butter ! Sinfully rich and perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate !
Brian R. - Dorchester, MA
Third time we have ordered these for different family members and friends, they all have gushed about how amazing they are!
Shane T. - Mount Vernon, OH
At my age, I have made and eaten many brownies, but none compare to this. I first bought some to have shipped to my brother for his bday. He was very impressed w/ the shipping, presentation and the actual product. Next I had some sent to my Mom for Christmas. In both instances I got the create-your-own 8 pack. They arrived in a lovely reusable tin. I cannot recommend these highly enough. Worth the money for any brownie lover in your life, including yourself. Great gift to a client as well. I can't wait to give these to my best friend for her next birthday. She loves chocolate so I know she will enjoy these.
Jill T. - Los Alamitos, CA
Sent this to our son-in-law for his birthday, and the response we got was "Ah. Ma. Zing."
Kevin L. - Loganville, GA
Veeeerrrryyyy chocolatey!!
Cathy K. - Westerville, OH
The brownies are excellent. Well-packaged. Promptly received. Very moist and sweet.
Kathryn C. - Indio, CA
The brownies are fantastic. Delivered as promised.
Tim S. - Pomona, CA
Order came a day early. Very delicious!
Mitzi F. - Hollister, CA
The brownies from Killer Brownie Co were amazing. Possibly the best brownies I've ever had. Shipment arrived as scheduled and was well packed.
Chase L. - Fisherville, KY
OMG !! The brownies were FANTASTIC!!! Moist and fresh. Arrived cool and quickly. I could not be happier !!!!!
John T. - Huntington Beach, CA
These are just sinful wrapped in chocolate and other assorted flavors! These arrived in a holiday tin just as you would use if you were giving it as a gift - which I purchased these as a gift. Some specialty bakers wrap each item before packing and honestly, it makes them appear no different than buying them from your grocer’s shelf. These decadent brownies were nestled tightly side by side in a beautiful tin, looking as if they’d been baked in your kitchen which added a nice touch. The hardest decision in purchasing was deciding which brownies - all were drool-worthy and there isn’t a bad decision in the bunch. Life is short; eat your killer brownie desserts first.
Susan S. - Marathon, FL
The brownies were so good, that I had to put them down! I haven't ever, ever, ever, ever, ever had a brownie this good!
Melissa W. - Wright City, MO
Fabulous brownies! Wonderful flavors and very, very rich! In fact, so rich that I served them in halves with ice cream. They freeze well too! They also came in a great tin, perfect for art supplies, etc.
Carole W. - Chicago, IL
Catherine T. - Los Alamitos, CA
Loved the freshness of brownies and the combination of flavors.
Nancy K. - Meriden, CT
It was a gift to my cousins in Florida. They loved the killer brownies!
Karen N. - Ruskin, FL
AWESOME, Excellent Brownies. The best brownies I have ever had. Nothing compares.
Anthony B. - Coeur D Alene, ID
The brownies were incredibly fresh and delicious. I highly recommend the Chocolate Peanut Butter ! Sinfully rich and perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate !
Brian R. - Dorchester, MA
The brownies are fabulous! I often will microwave one for 20 seconds for the caramel to melt a bit.
Debora L. - Augusta, ME
Brownies were AMAZING! Tasted delicious and packaged very nice. Did I mention they tasted amazing!
Elizabeth H. - Colebrook, NH
Brownies fresh and delicious !
Tracy C. - Forney, TX
I ordered this a couple months ago and set the delivery date in advance, and the shipment arrived as scheduled! The packaging wasn't overdone; it was compact, and also very cute and functional!
Christine O. - Cambridge, MA
The Killer Brownies were very rich and everything i hoped for.
Quinton R. - Milledgeville, GA
Quick delivery, fresh product, amazing item!
Ron C. - Long Beach, CA
Delivery and trying a new product s always dicey but your reviews/rating was spot on!
Andrew L. - Jackson, MS
Brownies were delicious and would recommend them to friends and family.
Chassity P. - Knoxville, TN
I purchase a dozen of your famous brownies (German Chocolate, Peanut Butter and Oreo Cookies). They arrived a day early, packaged securely and my daughter said they are delicious. I will be ordering some for me now.
Melinda M. - Cayce, SC
Everything-- the brownies were delicious-- thank you
Ellen G. - New York, NY
Great service great food
Stephanie G. - Carlsbad, CA
I ordered Killer Brownies for someone as a birthday gift. They raved about the brownies- how large and fresh they were! They loved each flavor in the variety pack. I had a question with the ordered that was shipped and was assisted by Vanessa in their customer support department. Her assistance and concern with my question was so amazing. She responded to my emails quickly and always courteously. Vanessa took care of my concern and went above and beyond what I even expected. Based on the Killer Brownies and the customer support they offer, I would definitely order from Goldbelly again and my friend who received the brownies said she will order these for herself as well as gifts. This was my first order from Goldbelly and you never know what will arrive from an online site, but I was more than satisfied with my experience and will definitely order from them again in the near future. Great job!
Wendy W. - Longboat Key, FL
Brownies were yummy and delivered as promised at a reasonable price
Mary W. - Manlius, NY