Choose Your Own Key Lime Pie - 2 Pack

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe ships its famous Key Lime Pie nationwide on Goldbelly! Local character and Key lime aficionado Kermit Carpenter bakes one of Food Network’s Top 10 Sweets in America. Kermit’s Key lime pies are made with their in-house Key lime juice and topped with fluffy whipped cream. These pies feature a traditional graham-cracker crust and rich, tart filling. Choose either the classic Key lime or strawberry flavor in this 2 pack!

When Kermit Carpenter opened his namesake Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe in 1993, he was on a mission to serve the best Key lime pie in Key West. Located near Mallory Square (where you can often find Kermit jokingly pretending to toss pies at tourists), Kermit’s Key lime pies and Key lime pie on a stick are the real deal.

More Details

This package serves 16-20 people and includes your choice of 2 Key Lime Pies

  • Each Pie serves 8-10 people and measures approx. 9"

Pie Flavor Options Include

  • Original Key Lime
  • Strawberry Key Lime


Key Lime Original Filling – Kermit’s Key Lime Juice, Sweetened Condensed Milk, (Concentrated Whole Milk And Sugar), Egg Yolks

Crust – Enriched Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine, Mononitrate (Vitamin B1, Riboflavin (Vitamin B2), Folic Acid, Vegetable Shortening, Partially Hydrogenated Soybean And Or Cottonseed Oils, Sugar, Graham Flour, Corn Syrup, Salt, Leavening (Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Monocalcium Phosphate), Molasses, Hydrogenated Vegetable Fat, Sugar, Milk, Proteins, Stabilizers, Sorbitol Syrup (E420Ii), Hydroxypropyl, Cellulose, Sodium Alginate, Emulsifiers, Mono And Diacetyl Tartaric Acid Esters Of Mono And Diglycerides Of Fatty Acids, Soy Lecithin, Salt, Flavoring, Color: Beta Carotene

Filling – Kermit’s Key Lime Juice (From Concentrate With Less Than 1/10 Of 1 % Sodium Benzoate As A Preservative), Sweetened Condensed Milk (Concentrated Whole Milk And Sugar)

Crust – Enriched Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B1), Riboflavin (Vitamin B2), Folic Acid), Vegetable Shortening (Partially Hydrogenated Soybean And Or Cottonseed Oils, Sugar, Graham Flour, Corn Syrup, Salt, Leavening (Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Monocalcium Phosphate), Molasses, Malt, Soy Lecithin, Cornstarch
Topping – Water, Hydrogenated Vegetable Fat, Sugar, Milk Proteins, Stabilizers, Sorbitol Syrup, Hydroxypropyl, Cellulose, Sodium Alginate, Emulsifiers, Mono And Diacetyl Tartaric Acid Esters Of Mono And Diglycerides Of Fatty Acids, Soy Lecithin, Salt, Flavoring, Color: Beta Carotene

Contains – Wheat, Soy, Milk, Eggs

Our Products Are Produced On Equipment That Also Makes Products Containing Tree Nuts, Soy, Eggs, Milk, And Wheat.

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies ship frozen with dry ice, may dissipate during transit.
  • Upon arrival, place pie in the freezer.
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands.
  • Frozen pie lasts up to 2 months in the freezer.
  • Once thawed, pie lasts up to 3 days in the refrigerator.
  • Pie can be refrozen if still cool to the touch.

To Serve

  • Thaw pie at room temperature for 20 minutes.
  • Slice, serve, and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe ships Tuesday through Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders cannot be shipped to Alaska or Hawaii. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Florida


Key lime pie fabulous such a treat!
Marilynn B. - Brick, NJ
Best Key Lime Pie I have ever had and my gift recipient thinks so too.
Caroline C. - Covington, TN
Delicious key lime pie!
Marty M. - Brooklyn, NY
Delivered quickly and safely. Love the profuct, kermits Key Lime Juice.
Manuel F. - Ellaville, GA
Awesome presentation and delicious key lime pie!
Jessica P. - Denver, CO
It was delievered promptly on the desired date and tasted fantastic (we weren’t the recipient but my sister in law was in food heaven!)
Anna R. - Argyle, TX
Everything! I have already told many people about how wonderful your pies are. They’re the best Key Lime Pies I have ever even. “ The Best “
Joann J. - Weaverville, NC
Delivery Quality of the food Eating it took my friends right back to their Honeymoon 35 years ago!
Randee M. - Rockford, IL
Found a favorite gift treat. Ordering was quick and easy. Gift arrived on time, in perfect condition. The recipients were so surprised and delighted. Thank you!
Patricia B. - Middletown, PA
I sent the items as gifts. The items were delivered in a timely, professional, and delicious manner. Everyone enjoyed their treats!
Joe B. - Sugar Land, TX
Orders arrived when expected. Easy to track. Great to give as a gift. Recipient said items were packaged very well & delicious.
Joe K. - Denville, NJ
Pie arrived a day early! Excellent! The quality of Kermit's Key West Key Lime pie was terrific.
Martha L. - Chevy Chase, MD
Pie arrived at the time it was supposed to arrive Loved receiving an alert so I could alert the recipient The pie was WONDERFUL
Debby D. - Greenwood Village, CO
Entire experience was smooth and seamless! I ordered a key lime pie from Key West to be delivered to NJ for my dad’s birthday. Arrived on the day it was supposed to be and was packaged well, cold and fresh upon delivery. Website experience was smooth and I appreciated the timely communications so I could track where it was.
John D. - Totowa, NJ
Everything! The ease of ordering, shipping/packaging/delivery, taste and quality have all been top notch!
Sarah R. - Gilbert, AZ
A single key lime pie arrived Thursday afternoon on my front porch, and probably sat there in the sun for about an hour or so before I moved it into the fridge. I kept it inside the box with it’s dry ice, then drove it two hours on Saturday evening before finally taking it out of the box and serving. The Key lime pie was so unbelievably perfect and it’s as if I had just picked it up from the store. Breathtaking look and flavor. Incredible
Gabrielle B. - Jacksonville, FL
I ordered & forgot about it until the day of delivery..right on time..still frozen...packed with the dry ice stuff & we enjoyed every last morsel of this desert.. Great items to chose from...easy right on time. YOU guys rock! Thanks, I will order again soon just because you have such great selections.
Elizabeth T. - Alpharetta, GA
The pie was delicious! A perfect balance between sweet and tartness!!
Brandon M. - Sugar Land, TX
It arrived in excellent shape. Our friend who is recovering from surgery, ABSOLUTELY loved and is loving it. His wife a Florida native....extremely happy!
Richie W. - Little Egg Harbor Twp, NJ
The best key lime pie ever!!!! Tart and creamy!!! Arrived frozen! Perfectly packed!!! Will buy again!!!
Pat A. - Nevada City, CA
The pie and pie bars were delicious!! As a Florida native, I had to get some for my parents 42nd wedding anniversary and they were so excited. It was wonderful! Best KeyLike pie ever!
Jennifer M. - Sherman Oaks, CA
The pie was still frozen, packaging was well done. Delivered when promised.
Tedy B. - North Attleboro, MA
Pies and bars were delivered on time and in perfect condition
Becky B. - Scottdale, PA
Order arrived quickly and in excellent condition.
Rosanne R. - Tuscaloosa, AL
Everything! Very easy process! Loved the way you can track your order makes it fun..
Alexandra B. - Machesney Park, IL
Ordering, delivery and the quality of the product
Dalton K. - Omaha, NE
This is my fourth or fifth order through Goldbelly and have never had less than an exemplary experience.
Patricia H. - Houston, TX
What a great treat… arrived easily and on time.
Stan P. - Laguna Beach, CA
Ordering was easy and pies arrived on time in beautiful shape! Thank you!
Debra D. - Woodinville, WA
The order arrived as stated, the packaging kept my order frozen and the dessert was as delicious as we had hoped
Terry L. - Orinda, CA
So impressed! Reported to me that everything was still frozen when it was delivered from Key West, FL to Nisswa, MN! And of course, the Key Lime pie was divine!!
Kip S. - Nisswa, MN
Pie’s were received in excellent condition and in the time frame sited upon ordering.
Diane M. - San Antonio, TX
Ordering was easy and delivery was on time. Everything arrived still frozen and in great shape. A lot to say when it was pies. Thank you.
Susan D. - El Dorado Hills, CA
Everything was magnificent.... Delivery was timely and items were perfect.
Thea S. - North Easton, MA
Came overnight, packaged with care. Delicious key lime pie
Sherry L. - Henderson, NV
Your customer service was excellent. I couldn’t believe I could actually talk with a real person, and also not have to be on hold for a long time. Thank you!
Katy S. - Denver, CO
Quick response to my missing item.
Sheila A. - Milan, TN
Easy to order, great product offerings. Product received when promised
Catherine W. - Newport News, VA
Excellent key lime pie. Used to live in Florida and this was exactly right
Bruce M. - Tucson, AZ
My Mom said it was the best Key Lime Pie she has ever had. Made her birthday celebration from afar very special. Thank you!
Carol H. - McKinney, TX
Ordering was very easy and we received are package in two days. That was awesome.
Valerie U. - Upland, CA
Delivered on time and raves from recipients.
Dean P. - Sandy Hook, CT
Easy ordering. Quick response from agents.
Alexandra K. - Philadelphia, PA
The Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe key lime on a stick with chocolate covering it was outstanding!
Sandi M. - Quogue, NY
easy transaction from the get go, arrived for my son on his birthday
christy f. - Lakewood, OH