Original Cheese New York Pizza - 2 Pack

(Customer Reviews)

Joe & Pats Pizzeria ships its famous pizza nationwide on Goldbelly! Put simply: this is some unbelievably delicious New York style pizza. The crust is thin and crisp but still retains a pleasing chewiness, and the toppings all intermingle into a perfectly balanced, slightly sweet, slightly gooey pool of sublimely saucy, cheesy goodness.

Ask any Staten Islander where to find the best pizza in the borough, and Joe & Pat’s, which has been serving up classic New York-style slices since 1960, will definitely come up in the conversation. The Pappalardos, who founded the restaurant and still run it today, are New York pizza royalty, and with good reason.

More Details

This package serves 4-6 people and includes 2 Cheese Pizzas (each 12")


Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Garlic

Instructions / Storage

  • Pizzas ship frozen with dry ice
  • Do NOT remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival immediatly place in freezer

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 500F
  • Place frozen pizza in the oven and heat for 3.5-5.5 minutes depending on your liking
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Joe & Pats Pizzeria ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


The price was great for the pizza I got (my husband’s dream- real Brooklyn style!) & was sooo delicious!
Amanda H. - Carson City, NV
Arrived fresh and on time . My pizza was delicious!
Glenn B. - Charlotte, NC
Never been disappointed. These pizzas are exceptional and so easy to add your own toppings
Jack W. - Jupiter, FL
I actually had an issue with my first order where there was no dry ice packed and the food arrived warm. I reached out to Goldbelly on Instagram and within 24 hours, customer service had reached out and sent a new package unprompted. The customer service is unmatched and the selection of foods is to die for. I'm really happy with my overall experience.
Tami C. - West Palm Beach, FL
The pizza from Joe and Pat's was amazing! I really like being able to schedule my delivery date.
Lisa C. - Yakima, WA
delivery on time and package great. I sent pizza to my family in michigan from NYC and they loved it. We were not able to spend the holiday together so we sent some NYC to them. Joe and Pat's was the best!
Erica, G. - Milford, MI
The order was an anniversary present to my parents (pizza from our hometown of Staten Island, NY) and the delivery was on time as promised.
Bettelyn T. - Lakeside, CA
We loved the pizza's we ordered ! It was simple and fast. Food arrived in perfect condition.
Deb R. - Los Gatos, CA
Delicious pizza came on time with perfect heating directions!
Martha H. - Dunwoody, GA
The pizza was packed very well...It arrived on time and it is so DELICIOUS!!! I am thoroughly enjoying my indulgence!
Pamela T. - Hillsville, VA
Best ultrathin crust. Tasty sauce and crisp.
Bob M. - Berkeley, CA
Customer service was excellent. They rectified a problem that occurred. I am a Goldbelly customer for life!
Timothy M. - Wadsworth, OH
Pizza was still frozen when we got it and delicious when we ate it.
Patricia M. - Simpsonville, KY
Great Taste and arrived rock frozen as well packed, correctly frozen excellant packing materals. I believe it was dry Ice. Best Pizza I have had from goldbelly and have had several.
Tina D. - Burke, VA
Great packaging, seamless shipping, food was excellent, will order again.
BART A. - Miami Beach, FL
Pizza was amazing! The crust was so thin and the toppings perfect match.
Deborah M. - Branchburg, NJ
The value was good and the pizzas were very good. There was an instruction list on how long to cook at what temp., very helpful.
phyllis t. - Covina, CA
Everything was great. Tried it and it's one of the better gluten free options out there for Pizza. Yum.
JENNIFER L. - Hillsboro, OR
The Vodka Sauce pizza was my favorite. These are a good gluten free, vegetarian option.
JASON D. - Lytle Creek, CA
Everything was well packaged and was still good even though the deliveries were delayed. It was great to receive vegan options from my hometown!
Esa M. - Ithaca, NY
Package arrived on time. Still frozen, despite the heat wave in DC and that I wasn’t home to immediate bring inside. Pizza was very good, tastes fresh. Difficult to find good vegan pizza.
Anne T. - Alexandria, VA
Super fast delivery, fresh & cold & ready to go.
Gina H. - Newington, CT
Delicious pizza and perfect delivery
Martha H. - Dunwoody, GA
Excellent experience. Great food and great service.
Steven S. - Iron Station, NC
The first pizza was very good. Sauce had good taste and cheese was the best vegan cheese we have had.
Lucie L. - Charlotte, NC
Delivered as scheduled and tasty.
George C. - Brecksville, OH
Packaging was wonderful!
Denise D. - Gainesville, GA
Pizza was great. Arived 5 hours before estimated time.
Kevin K. - Lake Stevens, WA
Shipped on time.
Iris A. - Dallas, TX
Orders received on time and excellent vendors!
Camilla R. - Marietta, GA
My family out west thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and cookies!
Frank L. - Prescott Valley, AZ
Almost everything. Good communication and updates via emails. Also provided a telephone number if needed.
Sean D. - Glendale, AZ
Ordering was easy. Mmm food from our favorite restaurant.
Elizabeth C. - Fredericksburg, VA
Great pizza. From New York to Texas.
Marc Z. - El Paso, TX
Great. Quality and service!
Donald D. - Pittsburgh, PA
Delivered right on time.
Joyce D. - Birmingham, AL
Excellent service.
Mark P. - Lewisville, TX
The pizza was delicious even 2,000 miles away
Hailey C. - Tucson, AZ
Abe R. - San Pedro, CA
Delicious pizza from a place where we used to live.
Dave T. - Howell, NJ
Pizza arrived on time and still frozen, good good. My son loved the pizza.
Jordan S. - North Bend, WA
The delivery and the fact I finally received some amazing pizza from NY and Miami! Thank you for making my birthday such a wonderful experience!
Tracie H. - Decatur, AL
Great food delivered quickly and efficiently…thanks GoldBelly, my belly runeth over…my pants! 🤦🏼🙈😂
Louie G. - Flushing, NY