American Cheese Assortment

Ideal Cheese Shop ships its famous cheese nationwide on Goldbelly! A hand-picked selection of American cheeses from the experts at Ideal Cheese Shop, including Jersey Girl, Humboldt Fog, and Grafton Classic Cheddar, is shipping straight to your door.

What started as a mom-and-pop butter and egg company in 1954 has evolved into a gourmet cheese shop in New York City. For decades, the old-school Ideal Cheese Shop has been the go-to spot for gourmet cheese in New York City. From rich, buttery Vacherin Swiss cheese to an amazing truffle Brie filled with mascarpone and summer truffles, Ideal Cheese stocks over 250 cheeses from 17 countries. Ideal Cheese Shop has been named World’s Best Cheese Shop by Forbes!

More Details

  • This package includes an assortment of American Cheeses & 1 box of La Panzanella Crackers
  • Choose between 3 or 5 cheeses
  • Each cheese is approximately 1/2 lb.

3 Cheese Assortment Includes

  • Jersey Girl – From Cooperstown Cheese Company is a raw cow’s milk Colby made with milk from Autumn Valley Farm in Worcester, NY is mild and creamy. Autumn Valley Farm is entirely grass fed so the earthiness of the cow’s milk is reflected in the deep yellow hue and rich hearty flavor of the cheese. Since the flavor of the cheese is so dependent on the availability of grass in the fields, the cheese is made in the spring and summer months so it is not always available all year long
  • Humboldt Fog – An elegant, soft, surface ripened cheese. The texture is creamy and luscious with a subtle tangy flavor. Each handcrafted wheel features a ribbon of edible vegetable ash along its center and a coating of ash under its exterior to give it a distinctive, cake-like appearance. An American Original!
  • Grafton Classic Cheddar – An outstanding mature cheddar cheese selected for its pronounced flavor and smooth finish. This two year aged cheese is excellent when accompanied with dried fruits and nuts, crusty breads, and big wines

5 Cheese Assortment Includes

  • Jersey Girl – From Cooperstown Cheese Company is a raw cow’s milk Colby made with milk from Autumn Valley Farm in Worcester, NY is mild and creamy. Autumn Valley Farm is entirely grass fed so the earthiness of the cow’s milk is reflected in the deep yellow hue and rich hearty flavor of the cheese. Since the flavor of the cheese is so dependent on the availability of grass in the fields, the cheese is made in the spring and summer months so it is not always available all year long
  • Humboldt Fog – An elegant, soft, surface ripened cheese. The texture is creamy and luscious with a subtle tangy flavor. Each handcrafted wheel features a ribbon of edible vegetable ash along its center and a coating of ash under its exterior to give it a distinctive, cake-like appearance. An American Original!
  • Grafton Classic Cheddar – An outstanding mature cheddar cheese selected for its pronounced flavor and smooth finish. This two year aged cheese is excellent when accompanied with dried fruits and nuts, crusty breads, and big wines
  • Point Reyes Blue – A creamier style, full-flavored blue cheese with definite hints of lemongrass and sea salt. For those of us who have fallen in love with Maytag Blue, sample Point Reyes Original Blue™ for a familiar yet distinctly different experience!
  • Midnight Moon – Aged one year or more, this pale, ivory cheese is firm, dense and smooth with the slight graininess of a long-aged cheese. The flavor is nutty and brown-buttery, with prominent caramel notes. The wheel is finished in a beautiful black wax

Shipping Details

  • Ideal Cheese Shop ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

REVIEWS

the French Cheese sampler was amazing. Such a great selection of cheeses. I could not help sharing it with friends even though I wanted to eat it all myself. LOL
colleen d. - Lake Mary, FL
12/10/19
Perfect delivery. Recipient of gift was thrilled.
James H. - West Palm Beach, FL
02/27/20
Ordering was very easy, product excellent
Josephine M. - Hamburg, NY
04/12/21
Great products and alerts about shipping/delivery.
Katie A. - Pittsburgh, PA
04/11/21
The cheese themselves tasted wonderful
David F. - Williamsville, NY
03/28/21
Everything! Delivered on time in excellent condition. Every cheese was tasty. The crackers were crisp and went well with the cheeses. (We're snacking on the goat cheese right now!)
Bonnie F. - Las Cruces, NM
03/12/21
Shipping was on time and perfect. My mom really enjoyed the cheese we sent for her birthday and I really enjoyed how the shop had descriptions of each cheese.
Margaret S. - Pasadena, CA
03/07/21
Went very well, my daughter in law again loved her gift from Goldbelly! I will order again from your company! Thank You, Darla
Emily U. - Charlotte, NC
02/22/21
Excellent selection. I usually spend a month in Collioure France each year. This selection was my substitute. For a bit it was like visiting.
MARY U. - Pen Argyl, PA
01/23/21
Love it - incredible choices.
Bob&Jeanne R. - Savannah, GA
01/15/21
My client loved the gift so much!
Charlotte B. - Los Angeles, CA
01/08/21
Ordering was simple and recipient was able to get e gift card immediately! A nice way to let loved ones know that you are thinking of them when we can't get together this Holiday season.
Rose F. - Hilton Head, SC
12/16/20
I was nervous about the ability to deliver to multiple addresses and coordinate delivery dates, but it was very easy to do! I can't wait to try what was ordered at our team event and I imagine I will be ordering from Goldbelly for other events in the future.
- ,
05/24/21