Lobster Pot Pies - 4 Pack
( 4.7)Brimming with Maine lobster meat in a sherry-splashed cream sauce, Hancock’s Pemaquid Point Lobster Pot Pies are wonderfully tempting. Lobster-shaped puff pastry decorations adorn the top of each pie, adding a touch of elegant whimsy to your meal. These award-winning pot pies are gorgeous, sumptuous, and delicious. Each lobster pot pie comes prepared in reusable, oven-proof ramekins.
For over 20 years, Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co. has been creating and shipping legendary Maine lobster experiences nationwide. Starting with family recipes that go back generations, we’ve continued to grow and expand our product line to include several award-winning meals. And while things have certainly changed over the years, our commitment to delivering a pure Maine experience is as strong as ever. Come see what it means to order from a small team with big values that insists on never hiding the taste of Maine lobster.
More Details
Serves 4 people
This package includes:
- 4 individual 7 oz Lobster Pot Pies
- Arrive in ramekins ready to bake
Ingredients
Lobster, Heavy cream, Puff pastry (USDA grade AA butter, unbleached flour, water, salt, lemon juice), Milk, Sherry (sulfites), Lobster base (cooked lobster, salt, maltodextrin, hydrolyzed corn protein, whey, lobster extract, butter oil, autolyzed yeast extract, tomato paste, onion powder, dehydrated potato flakes, paprika, natural butter flavor, spices, garlic powder, saffron), Modified food starch, Butter (cream, salt), Tomato paste (tomato paste, salt, spices, natural flavors, citric acid), Sugar, Paprika, Black pepper. Contains: shellfish (lobster), milk, wheat. Made in a facility that also processes: soy, egg, fish, tree nuts. May contain shell fragments.
Instructions / Storage
- Product frozen in a temperature-controlled shipper
- Ships Frozen with ice packs, may thaw in transit
- Thaw in refrigerator for 24 hours immediately before use
To Serve
- Preheat oven to 425°.
- Bake on sheet pan for 15 minutes or until pastry has begun to puff.
- Reduce heat to 350° and continue baking for another 5-8 minutes until pastry is golden brown.
- Remove from oven and allow to cool for 3-5 minutes before serving.
Shipping Details
- Hancock Gourmet Lobster Company ships Monday-Friday of each week
- Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
- Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
- Shipping Rates are as follows:
- 2-Day Express: $26.95
- Overnight: $49.95
- Priority Overnight: $59.95
- Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Corporate Gift Orders
You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.
Recommended for you
More from Maine
( 4.7) Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co. REVIEWS
Everything arrived on time, fresh and tasty. The buns were the best! Just the right amount of crumb and moistness, cut perfectly to hold right amount of succulent lobster.
Cynthia H. - Los Angeles, CA
09/27/19
Easy to order. Item was outstanding and we are originally From Massachusetts so we know lobster. Whoopie pies just like mom used to make. Oh and arrived in perfect, cold, fresh condition.
Helen D. - Lake City, FL
10/07/19
Fast shipping, great packaging and easy cooking instructions. The food was amazing and smelled so good baking in my house.
Nikki F. - Palmetto, FL
06/21/19
A TON of lobster meat and HUGE chunks of meat too! It was more than enough to fill up the bread rolls.
Rachel M. - South Haven, MI
07/02/19
I love lobster. Lobster rolls were wonderful. Tasted great and big pieces of lobster. Followed directions and I was in “ happiness heaven”. Thank you.
Ellen H. - Rochester Hills, MI
10/07/19
Considering the lobster took a 3,000 mile journey to arrive at my table, it was remarkably fresh and tasty. Chowder was good, too.
Todd K. - Stevenson Ranch, CA
10/08/19
Loved the ease with which it could be put together and the taste was excellent! I should have ordered more!
Robyn N. - Denver, CO
06/26/19
Huge selection overall and excellent pricing on lobster supper ordered, with tasty dessert included. Product arrived at best time on day requested via Fed Ex. No shipping cost was especially pleasing.
Wayne L. - Gainesville, FL
09/19/19
The Lobster mac was wonderful-not too thick or thin-just perfection in taste, quality and texture. Excellent job in packaging and safe shipping arrived fully frozen. So well done - BRAVO!
Jim S. - Palm Springs, CA
10/01/19
The Lobster rolls were excellent! It is pricey. I know lobster and shipping but well worth the treat.
Lori D. - Ballwin, MO
10/28/19
Delivery was on time and the lobster pot pies are delicious.
LISA R. - Indio, CA
01/13/20
EPIC! Taste, texture, directions! Just amazing! Even sent a styrofoam cooler that is big enough to use again! THANK YOU!
Elisabeth R. - Summerland Key, FL
12/02/19
Delicious but pricey
Susan B. - Denton, TX
12/06/19
Absolutely delicious, easy to prepare and the perfect portion size.
Nancy T. - Baltimore, MD
12/02/19
Arrived on time with rave reviews!
Kelly H. - Granby, CT
12/27/19
Family who received the seafood were so pleased! This was second order due to outstanding delivery & fantastic goodness! Will continue to place orders as gifts since receiving positive feedback . Thank you!
Steven S. - Weston, FL
12/27/19
Loved my meal, second time having it and definitely would order again!
Ashley W. - Mission Viejo, CA
12/28/19
My order was delivered on time and is one of the best lobster dishes in the country
Richard H. - Pasadena, CA
12/26/19
The lobster tartlets where easy to prepare like a pro. Really nice quality of flavors. It is obvious that only top shelf ingredients were used in the making of them. Surprisingly delicious pastry shells !!!
michael l. - Lake Oswego, OR
12/24/19
Great mac & cheese! Arrived when expected still frozen!
Melissa K. - La Grange, NC
12/29/19
From the packaging to serving portions, Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co. was amazing. Every bite had a piece of lobster and cook time was a breeze; 20-30 minutes.
Devon Q. - Albany, OR
12/29/19
The lobster meat and chowder were ice cold. They were packed with several ice packs in styrofoam container. There was a sufficient amount of lobster meat to fill the rolls that came with it. We loved them.
Celia M. - Village of Loch Lloyd, MO
01/15/20
Such a treat!! The lobster was fantastic, so fresh, not at all soggy! Best Clam Chowder I’ve ever had! At least as wonderful as going to a Great Seafood Restaurant in New England!
Bob B. - Palm City, FL
01/11/20
Lobster mac and cheese was absolutely delicious! I will order again and again and again!!
Tracy B. - Manassas, VA
01/29/20
The lobster rolls were very tasty with plenty of big chunks of lobster and the rolls were great too my girlfriend liked the whoopie pies I’m ready to order some more
Richard S. - Falmouth, KY
01/29/20
It was easy and the food arrived when scheduled, very fresh.
Rich D. - Boca Raton, FL
02/06/20
Order arrived right on time and the lobster was cooked perfectly and the clam chowder was awesome.
Terry S. - Escondido, CA
02/13/20
My son loved it!!
Amanda S. - St Augustine, FL
02/14/20
Arrived on time, well packed. And it was amazingly delicious!
Marybeth K. - Trevor, WI
02/17/20
Delivery was on time. Food was delicious!
Colleen B. - Fuquay Varina, NC
02/18/20
Arrived on time! I added an egg wash to the raw lobster pot pie dough before placing in the oven. They baked beautifully and tasted home made. My Valentine LOVED them. Excellent purchase from start to finish.
Teresa C. - San Mateo, CA
02/19/20
The meal was excellent tasting, the broth is so good to dip crusty bread into! Also very easy to prepare in grill or oven I the aluminum pack it comes in. I defrosted for 24 hrs in refrigerator.
Judy B. - San Diego, CA
02/19/20
Lobster arrived fresh and not frozen, chowder was still frozen but I unthawed as per instructions and it was ready to eat right on time and everything was so delicious.
Karlene D. - Eau Claire, WI
02/20/20
The lobster and Whoopie pies were delicious. We thoroughly enjoyed it.
Karl S. - Santa Fe, NM
03/02/20
Delicious Fresh plenty of lobster. Large pieces. Packed well.
Susan C. - Sonoma, CA
03/05/21
I order from you all the time. My entire family enjoys the surprises during the holidays. The orders arrive on time, cold and wonderfully packaged.
Amy H. - Indian Shores, FL
03/22/20
Good delivery. Still frozen upon arrival. Taste was amazing.
Mary D. - Haines City, FL
03/29/20
Fast delivery. Fresh and delicious! Huge chucks of lobster. Will order again!
Amy D. - Marshall, MI
03/29/20
The lobster was soooo delicious - juicy, chunky and perfect!
Linda T. - New York, NY
03/25/20
The lobster roll & lobster gazpacho we received from Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co was full of big lobster pieces, fresh & delicious.
Bill B. - Mesa, AZ
03/25/20
Easy to order, delivery went well, instructions were legible. I only didn’t give a 10 because the price is rather high.
Sandra R. - Moultonboro, NH
03/25/20
Super fast delivery. Frozen upon arrival
Lobster bisque was absolutely delicious!
No chunks, lumps more creamy / smooth
Taste was A+ Sandwiches were great! Very rich!
Roberta W. - Saint Joseph, MO
03/26/21
The Maine dinner was excellent and a great gift!
Jason/Shaina S. - Los Angeles, CA
03/19/21
It was such a surprise and treat for my college child to receive a great meal that was easy to assemble on his own.
Mitchell Mu - College Station, TX
03/19/21
The lobster rolls were outstanding and fresh!!
Karen C. - Tucson, AZ
03/18/21
Everything. I ordered the lobster mac & cheese for my cousin and her husband in Montana. I have ordered this for them in the past and really enjoyed it. I took my cue from her husband when he asked my cousin how they could get some more. He was very excited to get the new order.
Mary B. - Libby, MT
03/14/21
Sweet, fresh, perfectly cooked seafood dinner for 2! Thank you!
Pat B. - Olathe, KS
03/06/21
Although the pack was delivered late, due to the ice storms in the Northwest, our package arrived still frozen and in good condition. We baked up the dinner pack last night and it was delicious! Good work Hancock!
Ruth F. - Dallas, OR
02/27/21
Order was placed as a gift, arrived on time and fresh! Our family was very happy and enjoyed every thing they received.
Arlene V. - Kerman, CA
03/07/21
Our delivery was late due to poor weather on East Coast. Since it was seafood coming from Maine, we were concerned the products would be ruined, especially since it was also delayed by fed ex for no reason once it arrived on West coast within 35 miles of my home. Goldberg website efficiently explained how to know if product was ok to eat once arrived if delivery was delayed. Product arrived nearly 6 days after ship date and was packaged so well it was still fresh and cold, and some items still partially frozen. We loved it and gave us confidence for our next order in near future.
Pamela A. - Sunnyvale, CA
02/24/21
Delicious! Due to weather delays it arrived perfectly for Valentine’s Day. Not many sea food platters in Corrales, NM! Took us back to days of travel in the North East!
Gail H. - Corrales, NM
02/21/21
I ordered two lobster mac & cheese dinners for two of my kids for Valentine's Day & they raved how REALLY good it was! Next time I need to treat myself to the same!
Kristin O. - Los Angeles, CA
02/21/21
We have tried several things from their menu. So far, my favorite is the Lobster Mac and Cheese. The giant Grilled cheese and Lobster is also a favorite. This time we ordered the Crab Cakes, Lobster Ravioli and Lobster soups. I am looking forward to trying them. We have never been disappointed
Susan M. - Brooklyn Park, MN
05/17/21
The fresh lobster salad and Whoopie Pies were absolutely wonderful and would order from Hancock again! Everything was shipped beautifully and came in great shape.
Robert G. - Norcross, GA
05/11/21
We received the lobster dinner. We are in Maryland and our friend sent to us since we won't be traveling to our favorite trip to Maine. It was wonderful. Perfect instructions. We had a blast prepping it and eating it. Took pix we can share! Thanks so much.
Sandy - Frederick, MD
06/02/21
Delicious lobster rolls (with big lobster meat) and the whoopie pies were awesome! Delivered fresh and on time.
Kelly V. - Waterford, MI
07/26/21
I ordered some of the lobster grilled cheese for my son. He said they were delicious and quick to make.
Brandon S. - Yorktown, VA
07/25/21
My 88 yr. old mother is in Hospice. She suddenly had a "hankering" for Gazpacho which I tried to find - to no avail - in all of the Greater Minneapolis/St. Paul area. I found it on GoldBelly though! We both agreed... it's the best thing we've ever put in our mouths! It helped make a lasting memory for both of us, and as long as she is able, I'll continue to order it as a special treat - especially on the days she endures infusions.
Tierney P. - Hudson, WI
07/19/21
Delivery schedule from start to finish. Despite our delivery area being in the eye of approaching TS Elisa our shipment left on time from Maine via Boston via Philly via Raleigh via Wilmington NC and even while our weather here in coastal NC was starting to approach our shipment arrived ON TIME AS PROMISED!! AND THANK YOU UPS as well GREAT JOB as always!!!
Wiliam B. - Southport, NC
07/12/21
We sent the Dinner for Two to a friend as a graduation gift. He LOVED it! He said it was the best meal he’d had all year. I wouldn’t hesitate to do this again.
Donavon S. - Keyport, NJ
07/11/21
Package was cold and wonderful! Everything arrived frozen and the ice packs were even still frozen! Great job!
Roberta J. - Jupiter, FL
09/28/21
This is my 2nd go around with the lobster Mac and cheese and it is yummy. Had company for dinner and everyone raved about it. Will keep ordering
Candace R. - New Port Richey, FL
09/27/21
Easy to order! Delivered on the day it was supposed to be delivered. My granddaughter thought it was the best clam chowder she had ever had. Also the lobster.
Briar F. - Surprise, AZ
09/26/21
All went well with the two orders. One was delayed by a day but the food was kept cool and arrived fine.
Terry S. - Bellbrook, OH
09/23/21
The food was amazing...the service of Gold belly is a solid 10+++ for its excellent customer support. They know how to run a business that relies on being as close to perfect from ordering to delivering. Also, Hancock Gourmet Lobster is food perfection. Thank you all.
JOANNA W. - Pittsburgh, PA
09/19/21
everything. very easy to use and I love that you can pick the delivery date.
Patricia B. - King of Prussia, PA
09/19/21
The scrumptious Lobster Mac & Cheese arrived on schedule for dinner. Both families who were the recipients of the Gift package were pleasantly overjoyed by the Lobster Mac & Cheese!
Raved reviews......🦞
Lisa G. - Pittsburgh, PA
09/18/21
This is the 3rd time I have purchased from this vendor and every time it's great! The quality of the product and it arrives in a great cooler, ice packs still frozen so the product inside is cold or frozen. It's perfect!
Melinda F. - Columbia, MO
09/14/21
Received the Mac and Lobster right on time. It was very good and loaded with lobster. Will definitely order it again.
Glen B. - Sacramento, CA
09/13/21
Delivered as expected
Greg M. - Red Bluff, CA
01/24/22
Everything arrived on time and was delicious!!!
Susan S. - Liverpool, NY
01/24/22
Service was good, prompt arrival.
The many options and combinations available.
Ben Ra - Saint Peters, MO
01/24/22
I love the service.
Cathy S. - Levittown, PA
01/18/22
Delivered on time, food was good
Rich C. - Coos Bay, OR
01/22/22
Arrived as promised. Tasted great, just as promised.
Mary D. - Fairfield, PA
01/17/22
Food was delicious
S K. - Dublin, OH
01/18/22
Always wonderful!
Hunter D. - San Diego, CA
01/17/22
You have proven yourselves to be a very professional company; the products I selected were all given as gifts. Every person said they would definitely order from your company again. The food was all fantastic! There was one slight issue with packaging of one item & you responded promptly. I even received an account credit. Top notch service!
Kari L. - Corvallis, OR
01/17/22
Arrived on time, packed beautifully!
Laurie C. - Burien, WA
04/04/22
Everything was well packed. The crab mac and cheese is excellent!
Janice M. - Manchester, NH
04/01/22
Your service and quality were stellar! We will definitely be ordering again!
Beverly C. - Severance, CO
03/29/22
Perfect timing on delivery. Ordering was easy and price was right. Moreover the food was awesome. Service overall was excellent. Thank you so much.
Donnald L. - Laurel Hill, FL
03/27/22
Everything, ordering, using my points. Delivery, email confirmation, email tracking, etc. Have used Goldbelly since they started the service. Only once have I had a problem, which the issue was resolved to my satisfaction.
P R. - Jacksonville, FL
03/19/22
The shipping was without incident and our lobster tails were perfect! The packing of the container was also top notch!
Autumn S. - Lincoln, NE
02/22/22
All went well. It was delivered as promised packed securely and frozen. I have ordered the lobster Mac and cheese before and it’s delicious. I will order it again.
Candace R. - New Port Richey, FL
02/20/22
Our food order arrived on time, and was packed very securely and on ice - it made for a unique and special Easter Sunday luncheon that was easy and delicious and luxurious!
Rachel A. - Boca Raton, FL
04/19/22
Delivery true to promised. Product expertly packaged, arrived in excellent condition!
Linda A. - Red Bank, NJ
04/18/22
The lobster mac and cheese was delicious and got here in a timely manner!
Julie S. - Porterville, CA
04/18/22
The process went very smoothly! My son loved the lobster mac and cheese!!!!
Doug H. - Omaha, NE
04/17/22
Arrived on time tasted great and full of big chunks of Lobster! Excellent!
Tom D. - Jacksonville, FL
04/13/22
Expected guests for dinner the next night & prayed the food would be delivered in time. It did!! Thanks for giving me the confidence to know you will be there for me!
Gloria M. - Los Altos Hills, CA
04/11/22
Perfectly Packed and shipped
Lots of crab in every bite. Delicious!
Appreciate the sale!
Susan C. - Sonoma, CA
04/02/22
The coffee cake from Bread & Roses was phenomenal, as was the lobster mac & cheese from Hancock was AMAZING. They arrived fresh, and for the mac and cheese still completely frozen.
DONNA R. - Las Vegas, NV
03/28/22
Lobster tails and bisque were delivered on time and packed well. They were a gift but the recipient was very pleased with the freshness and quality of the lobster tails!
Cynthia C. - Buffalo, NY
02/17/22
I lived in Maine for almost 40 years and would recommend Hancock to everyone! I have ordered many many times and have never been disappointed!
Halie J. - Scotia, NY
02/12/22
EVERYTHING! shipping container with more than adequate ice insulation kept the lobster cold and fresh. Excellent quality lobster! Definitely again for ourselves and as gifts, will order again!
Eric W. - Ridgewood, NJ
07/17/22
The lobster was delivered as scheduled and was fresh and delicious! It was enough lobster for 4 lobster rolls. I never had a Whoopie pie before (which came with the order) and it was also delicious! Would definitely order again!
Bonita R. - Santee, CA
07/17/22
The lobster was amazing. It arrived quickly and was fresh and cold. It was absolutely delicious...couldn't have been better. Will be ordering again from Hancock Lobster Co.
Sharon D. - Saint Joseph, MI
07/15/22
Hancock never, I mean never, makes a mistake on their orders. They always deliver a quality product right on time. And the quality of their seafood is off the charts. It's always fun to eat. The Lobsterman's Catch is worth every penny.
Nicholas C. - Calera, OK
07/12/22
Everything! From preparation to the dining experience, we were thoroughly delighted with the product.
Michael A. - East Lansing, MI
07/12/22
I am very pleased with my order. I ordered on Tues and arrived Thurs on time and packaged well. My son was thrilled with the lobster rolls and clam chowder! He posted the pic on instagram to share with everyone! It looked fabulous! I will definitely order again, it was a big hit!!
Joseph H. - Austin, TX
07/10/22
I didn’t have to travel to get my annual lobster roll. Loved enjoying that authentic taste I love here in St. Louis, MO. The roll was 100% authentic Maine.
Joseph P. - Saint Louis, MO
07/10/22
The meal was very well packed and the instructions were very detailed. There was a lot of food--more than I expected for two people. It was quite tasty. We like the fact that it wasn't swimming in oil.
Karen A. - Bainbridge Island, WA
06/21/22
The Lobster was PERFECT! Tender and sweet, I wish I had got 2lbs instead of just the 1lb we ordered, just delicious!
Lisa P. - Chicago, IL
06/18/22
The packaging was phenomenal as I live in Arizona and temps are high this time of year. The food was great! I will use this restaurant again in the future!
Michael C. - Scottsdale, AZ
06/11/22
Lobster was outstanding. I am an exiled, but not hostile, Mainer and miss Lobster Rolls and Fried Clams in and around Bangor. This was a memorable treat. Thank you.
Charles D. - Ponte Vedra, FL
05/22/22
I’m a repeat customer. Hancock Lobster Rolls are my favorite. SO easy and delicious. ♥️ GOLDBELLY!
Brian M. - Alameda, CA
05/20/22
Very impressed with your much proved packaging and shipping of these Lobster Grilled Cheese Appetizers. All were still frozen and your container freezer box is very impressive. Will now be encouraged to order these again. They are delicious and so easy to prepare. Thanks!
Marjorie J. - Dillon, MT
05/16/22
This was a gift for my dad for his 92nd birthday and it arrived in a timely fashion and was packed very well. He had a lobster pot pie right away and said there were nice large pieces of lobster in it.
Tom M. - Bloomfield Hills, MI
05/15/22
Gourmet food ordered online—how perfect! I ordered, it was sent & arrived in time and beautiful!! The pictures made my mouth water but the reality—still dreaming of the yummy taste!
Jo M. - Omaha, NE
05/10/22
Shipping came on time and everything was cold, the lobster tasted so fresh it was amazing! High quality lobster with lots of knuckle and claw meat. The clam chowder is also delicious, it tastes like you’re at the east coast.
Elizabeth S. - Bartlett, IL
05/10/22