New York Cheesecake

$56

With secret recipes that span three centuries, this fifth generation family-owned bakery continues to handcraft Italian desserts from the same location in NYC’s Little Italy since 1892.

Ferrara’s specialty NY cheesecake is smooth and creamy with a classic graham cracker crust.

More Details

  • Each Cake is 8" in diameter and serves 10-12 people

Ingredients

PRODUCED IN A FACILITY WHERE NUTS, MILK, EGGS, SOY & FLOUR ARE PRESENT

Instructions / Storage

  • Each cake ships on dry ice
  • Each cake can be refrigerated for up to 4 days (preferably in an airtight container) or frozen for up to 6 months. Defrost in the refrigerator one day in advance, or at room temperature for 3 hours.

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Ferrara Bakery ships Monday-Thursday of each week
  • No deliveries Saturday, Sunday or Monday
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from New York

(
 4.7) REVIEWS

Quality cookies and Panettone delivered in perfect shape, on time, and delicious. Have ordered these as a gift several times; they are always well received.
Eileen L. - Charlotte, NC
08/21/19
All arrived in perfect condition, with great instructions. Delicious too! Worth every penny since I cannot get these items in Florida.
Gerri R. - Vero Beach, FL
04/02/19
Gelato was delicious and packed extremely well. Survived June in Phoenix!! Can’t wait to order more!
Amy L. - Mesa, AZ
06/18/19
Sent it to my son for his birthday. His favorite dessert is tiramisu. He told me it was the best tiramisu he’d ever had!
Nancy A. - Raleigh, NC
07/01/19
The cake came on time and it was delicious! It was semi-frozen and I just needed to place it on the counter before serving.
Lisa S. - Orrs Island, ME
08/18/19
Ordered this for my bro & sis-in-law anniversary; they are chocolate lovers and raved about this cake!
Frederic S. - New Boston, NH
09/11/19
Arrived at the designated time, the product maintained its freshness… It was still frozen when it arrived. And the Cake was delicious. My daughter enjoyed it with friends for her birthday! It even came with candles!
Dolores B. - Pittsford, NY
10/04/19
I was so excited that I was able to order a dessert from my very favorite 'happy place' in Little Italy. And more that- it was a present for a very dear friend.
Jenn E. - Durham, NC
09/10/19
I ordered gelato and it was shipped during a hot spell and it arrived in perfect condition and was so delicious my guests and I thoroughly enjoyed every morsel!
Jocelyn B. - Nashua, NH
07/08/19
Easy to order & had choice of delivery dates to the west coast! Arrived exactly on time and I was notified when it was shipped and when it arrived!
Louise K. - Redlands, CA
10/17/19
Everything was fresh, shipped quickly! Everyone loved the cookies. Everything was spot on!
Sherry D. - Norwich, NY
10/17/19
It was fantastic. Arrived in great frozen condition. Everyone loved them!
Lori H. - Pickens, SC
10/16/19
I sent it to my mother for her 91st birthday. She was thrilled with the cake taste and she said the presentation was very nice.
Carole H. - Tarentum, PA
10/09/19
I love the fact that you can find items from anywhere across the country. I live in Texas and a lot of the things I love from growing up in CT and NY they just don't have here or the quality is not good. Honestly, everything was great of the things I have ordered.
Maria A. - San Antonio, TX
10/02/19
We can not find struffoli in Virginia and it is my husband’s holiday favorite. Thanks to Goldbelly, we can have the BEST struffoli and Italian cookies from Ferrara’s shipped right to our door!
Susan K. - Nellysford, VA
11/27/19
The chocolate truffle cake was to die for - excellent!
Jane M. - Thornwood, NY
11/25/19
"My husband, a native New Yorker, was delighted! Seems they just don't make those pastries right in western rural Pennsylvania! In addition, when he lived in NYC, Ferrara's was actually the bakery he used to visit! The pastries are just as he remembered, and he enjoyed them very much!"
Lori D. - Jeannette, PA
12/10/19