Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches - Choose Your Own 16 Pack

Cream + Sugar ships its artisanal ice cream nationwide on Goldbelly! These mini ice cream sandwiches are the stuff of sugar-filled dreams! The ice cream is made from cream and milk from regional farms. The cookies for their signature ice cream sandwiches are still baked daily. Everything is still made and packed by hand. We dare you to just eat one!

What started as artisanal ice cream on the dessert menus of Fine Dining Restaurant Group’s Jackson, Wyoming, restaurants has turned into a small-batch ice cream company making ice cream in fanciful flavors like huckleberry, salted caramel, and chocolate. With overwhelming demand for this ice cream, owner Gavin Fine decided to open a home for Cream + Sugar in 2017. Under the leadership of Chef Chad Horton, Cream + Sugar makes ice cream using cream and milk from regional farms and hand-makes mini ice cream sandwiches with cookies baked fresh daily.

More Details

This package includes your choice of 16 Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • Mini Sandwiches come in packages of 4

Flavor Options Include

  • Huckleberry – If Jackson Hole was ice cream, this would be it. A native berry to the area, the huckleberry has become a mainstay in local cuisine. Cream + Sugar starts with a blend of huckleberries and wild blueberries, which they then wrap in a hug of sweet cream ice cream. Tangy, sweet, colorful, our Huckleberry ice cream is an iconic mountain town treat.
  • Mint Chocolate Chip – This delivers a mint punch straight to the mouth with a combination of fresh mint and pure mint extract. Semi-sweet chocolate pieces are thrown in to give a great crunch and an added bite of flavor.
  • Salted Caramel – Salty, sweet – it’s the couple that shows opposites do attract, and often in really tasty ways. Cream + Sugar starts with our sweet cream ice cream, adds in house-made vanilla sea salt and swirls in caramel made by their loving hands using sweetened condensed milk that’s been boiled for 8 hours. The result is a frozen creation that’s perfectly balanced and ready to convert even the most simple ice cream lover.
  • Vanilla – We’ve all heard it before – mediocrity described as vanilla. Cream + Sugar believes the flavor’s gotten a bad rap and that their vanilla will change your mind. It all starts with Singing Dog vanilla, rich cream and lots o’ love. One bite and you’ll never describe something mundane with the term again.
  • Pumpkin – Winter seasonal ice cream sandwich made with pumpkin ice cream & orange sprinkles!
  • Peppermint – Winter seasonal ice cream sandwich made with candy canes and red & white sprinkles!


Contains: Egg, Dairy

Instructions / Storage

  • Ice Cream Sandwiches ship frozen with dry ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival, freeze immediately
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Cream + Sugar ships Monday -Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Wyoming


Easy order. Delivered on time. Amazing Cream & Sugar treats arrived in perfect condition.
Kelley O. - Petaluma, CA
My order was delivered as promised on the date requested and perfectly packaged.
Kay L. - West Point, VA
Easy, efficient and on time!
Catherine S. - Newport Beach, CA
Item was delivered on time. Frozen food was frozen!
Jessica F. - Davis, CA
Arrived on time in excellent condition!
Dawndi R. - Salt Lake City, UT
Ordering arrived when said and always so good!!
Julie M. - West Caldwell, NJ
Arrived on time even with bad weather!!
Christine H. - Louisville, KY
Ordering was easy & shipment on time!
Patty G. - Branford, CT
Got there on time and great products offered!
Ken C. - Bluffton, SC
Great experience and fast shipping!
David S. - Warren, MI
Easy to order. Food came exactly on the day I indicated I wanted it. I ordered ice cream and was concerned it would be melted, but the dry ice and styrofoam container kept it nice and hard. After I put it in the freezer for a day, I tried some and it was delicious... very creamy!
Deborah K. - Newark, CA
The ship time was great! The ice cream arrived in perfect condition and there was still ice left. My friend in Maine loved her birthday treat. Thanks.
Sue M. - Stockton Springs, ME
Fast delivery frozen solid ice cream
Marcellla F. - Tomah, WI
delivered on time. Was delicious. Great gift!
Bunny O. - Wellesley, MA
Arrived on time in excellent condition
Dawndi R. - Salt Lake City, UT
On time as usual and great products.
Holly C. - Toms River, NJ
Easy to order, arrived on time
Shelly k. - Pinellas Park, FL
The product was delicious. Arrived when they said it would and made my nephew so happy!
Dana K. - Huntersville, NC
My gift recipient loved the ice cream sandwiches!
Aiden L. - Park City, UT
Surprise treat to celebrate summer was a real success!
Jamie M. - Nashua, NH
Received the product earlier than expected. Didn't have to worry if my planned party would have the stuff I wanted.
Leilani F. - San Jose, CA
The taste is great!!! Awesome Birthday Present!!!!
Greg S. - Ocala, FL
Shipment was perfect and delivered in good time - thank you!!
Gary M. - Centralia, MO
ice cream was frozen. arrived when told.
gail h. - Bismarck, ND