Cotton Blues Cheesecake - Choose Your Own 2 Pack

Choose your two favorite Cotton Blues cheesecakes. These cheesecakes are rich and luscious on their own, but even better when swirled with blueberry, strawberry, or sea-salted caramel.

Cotton Blues is a beloved Hattiesburg, Mississippi, restaurant, a family-owned destination renowned for its Southern hospitality and its menu of down-home Southern goodness. Pastry chef Shaun Davis’ magnificent cheesecakes, however, are what put it on the map. Cotton Blues’ cheesecakes are handmade with only seven ingredients (including Philadelphia cream cheese and pure vanilla extract), and they clock in at four pounds each.

More Details

This package serves 16-20 people and includes your choice of 2 Cheesecakes (10" each)

  • Each Cheesecake serves 8-10 people and weighs 4 lbs.

Cheesecake Flavors Inlcude

  • Original
  • Blueberry Swirl
  • Strawberry Swirl
  • Sea-Salt Caramel Swirl

Ingredients

Philadelphia Cream Cheese, Sour Cream, Fresh Whole Eggs, Graham Cracker Crumbs, Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Pure Vanilla Extract. Scratch-made swirling sauces, if applicable.

Instructions / Storage

  • Cheesecakes ship frozen with dry ice
  • Do Not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival, place in the freezer
  • May be kept frozen for up to a year
  • Refreezing after thawing is not recommended

To Serve

  • Thaw in the refrigerator, unwrapped, for about 5 hours or until fully thawed.
  • Serve chilled for best results!
  • Refrigerate unused portions for up to 5 days
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Cotton Blues Cheesecake Company ships Monday – Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Mississippi

REVIEWS

Came perfectly in 116 degree weather. Was packed in a fitted foam cooler with dry ice. It was simply delicious. And shipped on time both times we ordered. Absolutely delicious.
Lee B. - Lake Havasu City, AZ
07/30/20
The shipping was on time. The food was excellent. My friends thought it was the best cheesecake ever. It was well packed and still very cold or frozen.
Byron H. - Hot Springs, SD
08/19/20
Fast delivery! Cheesecake was FABULOUS AND DELICIOUS & WILL ORDER AGAIN!
Virginia L. - Hutto, TX
02/21/21
Great communication. Great packaging. Great delivery service. Extraordinary cheesecake!
Gregory M. - Corolla, NC
03/14/21
Delivery was on-time but I wish it was overnight like Amazon! Sea salt cheesecake is AMAZING!!!
Susan G. - Woodbury, NY
03/05/21
It was delicious and the way it was packed was super. This town has a complicated mail delivery system. I was worried that the cheesecake would be ruined by 2 overnights in the PO, but it was perfect. Nice job.
Janice H. - Jackson, WY
02/15/21
Ease of site to use; fantastic variety of foods; bucket list offerings; tried and true vendors; on time; safe and sure packing; best cheesecake I''ve ever tasted; 2nd order; will order again!
Rebecca G. - Lanett, AL
02/06/21
Perfection! From the ease of shopping. Updating me on the order shipping, tracking the order, and then its arrival. Not a crumb out of place! And talk about fresh!!! It was so special to make a birthday wish come true with a bakery order that was shipped from over 5,000 miles away. It’s my go-to order-place for gifts!
Barbara L. - Bellevue, WA
02/06/21
Cheesecake was in excellent condition. Box inside of a bigger box... really protected it. Dry ice kept it frozen. The blueberry swirl made it even better (gasp) than my mom's cheesecakes.
Annette B. - Cottage Grove, TN
01/29/21
It arrived on time. The packaging was wonderful and my son said it was the BEST Cheesecake he ever had!!
justin S. - Lakewood, CO
01/25/21
The cheesecake arrived on time and was FAST!! Also...the cheesecake was FABULOUS!! Best cheesecake I’ve ever had!! Thank you 😊
Mary P. - Laurel, MS
01/16/21
I have sent two cheesecakes to family members, who said that they were the best ever!
Sheila D. - Westwood, MA
01/07/21
From ordering to shipping to taste - worth every penny! As recommended in the details of the cheesecake I ordered 3 days before I wanted it delivered and it showed up on time. This cheesecake was a birthday cake for my boyfriend and although I'm not a cheesecake-lover like him, I LOVED this cake. The flavor was perfectly balanced and it was so rich that a small piece was all you needed. 10/10 would order again.
Marryssa P. - Victorville, CA
01/22/21
Totally happy with the whole order and delivery process. And the cheesecake is the best I've ever ordered.
Kirk C. - Titusville, FL
04/26/21
Fast delivery of Cotton Blues cheesecake. The best cheesecake I've had in a long while. Arrived frozen and perfect!
Luanne F. - Prescott, AZ
05/03/21
The delivery and cheesecake were on time. The cheesecake was outstanding.
Bryan H. - Mishawaka, IN
07/25/21
On time, and was delicious
Colt S. - Sallisaw, OK
07/25/21
Easy to order. Delivered on time and in perfect condition.
Vannessa I. - Glasgow, KY
07/18/21
There were so many different varieties and quality products. The delivery was on time and the cakes were in perfect conditions.
Mr./Mrs. K. - Hattiesburg, MS
07/19/21
Cheesecakes delivered frozen and exactly when promised.
Barry B. - Boca Raton, FL
06/20/21
Everything, on time shipping, great quality product.
Richard K. - Farmington, CT
06/18/21
Delivered on time and is delicious according the person I sent it to,
Dottie H. - Deland, FL
05/17/21
Fast shipping, arrived on the eta date. Wrapped well, no damage !
Chelsia Z. - Palmdale, CA
05/17/21
Delivery was perfect and everyone loved the cheesecake
Tanya W. - Middleburg, FL
05/12/21
Packaged well and cheesecake was delicious!
Cindy C. - Los Angeles, CA
06/13/21