Cookies - Choose Your Own 12 Pack

“There’s nothing quite like coming to our shop in Santa Monica and standing in front of our bakery case filled with cookies in all sorts of fun flavors and textures and colors; the scent of fresh-baked cookies teasing your nose as you carefully create a cookie selection that fits your specific flavor palate…and personality. While we haven’t (yet) figured out how to send the aroma of cookies through the internet, we can still put you in front of a virtual cookie case where you can choose away from the following six cookie flavors: Birthday Cake, Caramel-Pretzel Chocolate Chunk, a cereal cookie (flavors change monthly but range from Apple Jacks to Cap’n Crunch to Cinnamon Toast Crunch), Chocolate Chip, Goldbelly Sugar Cookie (Goldbelly exclusive), and S’mores.”

Cookie Good is a family business run by Melanie & Ross Canter, with help from their 20-something kids, Mia & Gabe. Ross was a Hollywood screenwriter who loved to bake, and during the 2008 writer’s strike, he started selling cookies out of his house. The business quickly grew, and Cookie Good was born! Cookie Good uses only the best ingredients in all of their fun and nostalgic baked goods: chocolates from Callebaut & Van Leer, Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla, and AA sweet creamery butter.

More Details

This package serves 6 people and includes your choice of 12 cookies.

  • Each cookie weighs 1.7 ounces and measures 3" – 3.5" (depending on the cookie)
  • Recommended serving size is 2 cookies per person (factoring in your appetite and willingness to share, of course!)
  • Choose to add Gift Packaging!

Cookie Flavor Options Include:

  • Birthday Cake: Our ‘cake batter’ cookie is flecked with rainbow jimmies and bits of creamy white chocolate ‘frosting’.
  • Caramel-Pretzel Chocolate Chunk: Our best seller. Chocolate chips, dark chocolate chunks, caramel, pretzels, and a sprinkling of crunchy pretzel salt – it’s a salty/sweet, chewy/crunchy, and just plain awesome cookie.
  • Cereal Cookie: We LOVE cereal-flavored cookies and change our flavors often; we’ll include whichever cereal cookie is in stock when you order (Flavors range from Apple Jacks to Cap’n Crunch to Cinnamon Toast Crunch…or pretty much anything you’d eat while watching cartoons)
  • Chocolate Chip: Everybody makes a chocolate chip cookie; we’ve gone the extra mile with ours, creating a deeply caramelized dough and adding in big chunks of rich, dark Belgian chocolate (these are not your grandma’s chocolate chip cookies…although we’re sure your grandma makes a perfectly fine chocolate chip cookie).
  • Chocolate Glazed Donut: Our nutmeg-spiked donut cookie dough gets a schmear of rich, chocolate glaze and a splash of colorful sprinkles
  • Goldbelly Sugar Cookie (Goldbelly Exclusive): Our thick & chew Just Plain Sugar Cookie trades in its crackly sugar crust for a light vanilla glaze and a cover of gold sprinkles and sparkly, gold sanding sugar
  • Red Velvet: Based on the Southern classic, this cookie is deep, crimson red with hints of cocoa and big chunks of creamy white chocolate
  • S’mores: A graham cracker dough is loaded with milk chocolate chips and chunks and topped with fire-toasted marshmallows
  • CHEETOSⓇ: The sweet/cheesy/salty/chewy/turn-your-finger-tips-orange goodness of this Cheetos Cookie is pretty darn special


Birthday Cake: Flour, Butter, Sugar, White Chocolate, Sprinkles, Eggs, Sour Cream, Corn Syrup, Vanilla, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

Flour, Chocolate, Caramel, Butter, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Pretzels, Eggs, Vanilla, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

Cereal (This One’s Apple Jacks): Flour, Apple Jacks Cereal, Butter, Sugar, Eggs, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Cinnamon. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

Chocolate Chip: Chocolate, Flour, Butter, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Eggs, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Vanilla. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

Chocolate Glazed Donut: Flour, Butter, Sugar, Chocolate, Sour Cream, Powdered Sugar, Eggs, Sprinkles, Vanilla, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt, Nutmeg. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

Goldbelly Sugar Cookie: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Sprinkles, Vanilla, Eggs, Powdered Sugar, Salt, Vanilla, Baking Powder. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

Red Velvet: Flour, White Chocolate, Butter, Brown Sugar, Sugar, Cocoa, Red Color, Vanilla, Cider Vinegar, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda. Contains: Eggs & Wheat.

S’mores: Milk Chocolate, Flour, Graham Crumbs, Butter, Brown Sugar, Sugar, Marshmallows, Eggs, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Vanilla. Contains: Milk, Eggs & Wheat.

CHEETOSⓇ: Flour, Butter, Sugar, CHEETOSⓇ Puffs, Cheddar Cheese Powder, Eggs, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Vanilla

Instructions / Storage

  • Items ship without coolant and arrive ready to eat!
  • If you have more will power than we do and have decided to freeze some of your cookies or bars, getting them back to “fresh baked” is really easy. Follow the directions below! 

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  • Place (still frozen) treats on a cookie sheet (if you’ve got parchment paper to line the cookie sheet that’s always helpful; not a problem if you don’t). 
  • Bake for 5 minutes and then let them cool on the cookie sheet for about 10 minutes.
  • Enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Cookie Good ships Monday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from California


Bought as a gift and they said the cookies they got were delicious and much better than any store bought cookies!
Craig H. - Punta Gorda, FL
Item arrived quickly and was delicious.
Jaime M. - Cold Spring, NY
My mom was SO EXCITED when she recieved this, and said they were so delicious!
Julie M. - Aptos, CA
Everything was super simple, streamlined, and very user user friendly!
Annette E. - Tucson, AZ
timely delivery, cookies were excellent!
Rebecca R. - Westmont, IL
The cookies were amazing! Another great experience with Goldbelly!
Brenda A. - Claremont, NH
Great Mothers Day Gift! She loved the flavors and delivery was on time!
Barbara G. - Green Mountain Falls, CO
My Mom loved this..arrived on time and she said the cookies were absolutely delicious !!
Joan M. - Broomfield, CO
The recipient said the cookies were delicious. Yay
Ann D. - Emeryville, CA
Everything. Selection. Website. Tracking. And items enclosed in package. Love it!
Kenneth S. - Dayton, NV
This shipment was done perfect. They care that went into packaging the brownies was 👍. Everyone enjoyed them & it was a nice dessert to my wife's birthday dinner
George L. - Enoree, SC
Delivery - on time Easy ordering Items arrived well packaged Contents received rave reviews of each item. Thank you.
Jeffrey C. - Studio City, CA
Perfect color and taste! The rainbow cookies were delicious.
Lori H. - Wayne, PA
Cookies were perfect and shipped well packed.
Jonathan S. - Cordova, TN
Cookies were delivered on time. Wrapped perfectly and in great condition. We shipped them to our daughter in college OH for her birthday. She said they were yummy and wonderful! She's a huge fan of anything red velvet. Thank you!
Sydney H. - Kent, OH
Everything! Cookies, brownies and popcorn were delicious! Items delivered as promised.
Amy T. - West Chester, OH
Love the cookies and will order a lot more!
Richard B. - Mount Gilead, NC
delivered on time, delicious!!!
Jack T. - Chantilly, VA
Cookie good is Amazing. Best Blondies ever!
Sam C. - Canyon Lake, TX
Those were some kickazz cookies baby
nicholas c. - Calera, OK
Everything! Incredibly prompt delivery and everything was well packaged.
Sally J. - Orange, NH
Cookies arrived in good condition.
Susan W. - North Potomac, MD
Delivery of cookies to my cookie obsessed mother for Mother’s Day!
Robyne F. - Mesa, AZ
My mom loved the cookies!
Judy B. - Southlake, TX
Shipping was fast & well packaged. The cookies were delicious, me and my family really enjoyed them. Will have to visit next time I am in Los Angeles.
Erik G. - Austin, TX
Great experience! Lovely and helpful customer service rep! Thank you!
Gary V. - Stratford, CT
I have ordered from Goldbelly for years! It is the most favored gift of all my family members! Two thumbs up!
Shannon K. - Hood River, OR
The cookies were delivered on time and in good condition. The recipient said the cookies were delicious.
Ryan K. - Philadelphia, PA
Delivery was great. Food quality was excellent.
Pamela C. - Scottsdale, AZ
The cheeto cookies are always a hitt. Thanks so much for these cookies :)
Steven C. - Oklahoma City, OK
Gluten free option, arrived on time, unique gift.
Candice T. - Peyton, CO
Arrived on time. Packing was amazing, treats were delicious. This was a Thanksgiving gift for my girlfriend and her family.
Gail W. - Blue Bell, PA
Cookies were delivered as expected and were fresh and delicious. Would definitely order again!
Bonita R. - Santee, CA
Delicious food and on time delivery!
Les B. - Keystone Heights, FL
Order arrive on time and was a BIG hit with everyone!
West F. - Southlake, TX
Order was easy, communication on delivery was awesome.
Frisco M. - Fernley, NV