Shepherd's Pie

A pie that we all know and love has really become a local favorite here on Cape Cod. This pie is made with seasoned ground beef sauteed with onions (just the right amount), topped with corn and creamy, buttery mashed potatoes. And just in case that doesn’t sound great enough, we then top the mashed potatoes with a sprinkle of parmesan cheese.

In 2009, longtime friends Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley decided to leave their careers behind as a deputy sheriff and a banker to open a pie shop. But not just any pie shop. The Pie Ladies, as they’re now known, are handcrafting some of the best pies in the nation. At the top of their list of fans is none other than Oprah who discovered Centerville’s pies while on the Cape several years back and helped to elevate their pies to celeb status with a feature on her show as one of her favorite things.

More Details

This package serves 6-8 people and includes a Shepard’s Pie

  • Each pie measures 9"
  • Pies arrive uncooked

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies are unbaked and shipped frozen with dry ice, may dissipate during transit.
  • Upon arrival, place pie in the freezer until ready to enjoy.

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 350°F.
  • Remove plastic wrap and place pie on a cookie sheet.
  • Bake pie on the bottom rack for 90 minutes or until golden brown (internal temperature should reach 165 degrees).
  • Remove from oven and allow pie to cool.
  • Slice and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Centerville Pie Co. ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!

We will do everything possible for timely delivery but cannot be responsible for damaged or compromised product due to the following:

  • Delayed deliveries due to weather or other “Acts of God”
  • Incorrect addresses. We ship to the exact address you enter at checkout. Please ensure that the address is correct before finalizing your order.
  • Please notify recipient of the pending arrival of perishables! Surprises are fun, however if there is a remote chance that the recipient will not be home, he or she must be notified of the gift arrival to avoid product spoilage. We are unable to resend gift shipments sent to recipients who are out of town or otherwise unavailable to receive their shipments. All of our orders are shipped signature release – No signature is required. This means, if no one is there to receive the order from our carrier the driver will leave the order at your door. This signifies acceptance of the order the same as a signature. We recommend that someone be there within the designated time frame to accept the order and properly freeze it.
  • When you/your recipient receive the pie order, please inspect your package immediately upon receipt. All claims must be filed within 24 hours of receipt. We want to be able to respond quickly and address any possible issue at that time.
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Massachusetts


The chicken pie was amazing!!! Most delicious I ever tasted!
Carolyn L. - Dallas, TX
This was the most delicious pie *ever*, filling and pastry both unbelievably good.
Dennis C. - Cedar Grove, NJ
Arrived on time, food in perfect condition, love the chicken pot what I liked was everything.
Barbara W. - Las Vegas, NV
Delivered on time....still frozen....great packaging. These pies are delicious.
Carol A. - Chillicothe, MO
Huge variety of foods to choose from. Good photos and descriptions. Delivery date options is terrific. My pies arrived on date expected, in excellent condition, still frozen, attractive, and easy heating instructions.
Ernestine R. - Fort Myers, FL
Variety of items. Promptness of order delivery. Price, while high, can let me obtain items from my past history. It's less expensive than air fare. I would have to travel to gets these items...
Andrea K. - Gainesville, FL
The Chicken Pie is VERY TASTY, and it serves 4-5 people, so it's well worth the price. Also, the Goldbelly Service Representative was EXTREMELY friendly, and very helpful in resolving a delivery issue I had with my order. I plan on ordering more in the future.
Debbie M. - Little Rock, AR
Package arrived as expected. Meat pie was as good as if we drove to the Cape and bought it ourselves. A great taste of home to enjoy in CA.
Susan R. - Pacheco, CA
Shipping was impeccable and on time. Pie was delicious!
Marisa B. - Peoria, AZ
The pies tasted good, just nothing special. The shipping was awesome, got here on time.
Lynette S. - Porterville, CA
Great service. The pie was to die for! The price was high but it was worth it.
Michael S. - Canton, GA
I ordered the spinach feta pie...and I think God made it! Don’t walk, run to order this. Or any of their pies. Because their pie crust is divine. I was practically weeping.
Kimberlee N. - Easton, MD
I loved that I could send a comfort food meal to a friend on the other side of the country because I can't take over a home-cooked meal in person. Friend was thrilled.
Mr. C. - Las Vegas, NV
The pies are fabulous the Crust are wonderful and there are no vegetables just big chunks of chicken and very little gravy it’s truly a gourmet pie
Kathleen K. - Newport, KY
A great pie with service to match. Centerville Pie Co. helped make our Christmas evening dinner extra special!
Jim E. - North Hollywood, CA
Packaged well. Beautiful pies. Delicious!
meghann c. - Reidsville, NC
The chicken pie was great. Tasty, FULL of chicken
ELIZABETH F. - Salt Point, NY
Quick ship! Delicious! Shepard's Pie was the best I have ever had.
Maryann M. - Roseville, MI
This was the most delicious pie *ever*. Filling and pastry are both unbelievably good.
Dennis C. - Cedar Grove, NJ
The chicken pie is delicious! FULL of chicken - wonderful flaky crust!
Lisa D. - Sylvester, GA
Huge variety of foods to choose from. Good photos and descriptions. Delivery date options is terrific. My pies arrived on date expected, in excellent condition, still frozen, attractive, and easy heating instructions.
Ernestine r. - Fort Myers, FL
Delivered on time....still frozen....great packaging. These pies are delicious.
Carol A. - Chillicothe, MO
I've ordered this product before; my first time ordering the pie it came half thawed; everyone was perfect about getting the situation rectified. Clearly did not stop me from ordering again. The company and pie are amazing
Shannon S. - Fairfield, CA
We have been buying these pies for awhile. Easy to bake and taste the best.
Arlene C. - Pompano Beach, FL
The chicken pot pie is always so amazing, my mom orders them to all of my siblings and I for Thanksgiving each year and it is such a hit. The packaging is great, zero damage to the pie in any of the years I've been receiving it. Highly recommend!
Casey M. - Denver, CO
I have enjoyed Centerville Pie Co. chicken pie and this time I also ordered the pulled pork (BBQ) pie. I've ordered the chicken pie several times over the years. These pies are too large for just my husband and I, but great when family comes over. I've also ordered for family to be in their freezer when they return from a long trip or out of the country trip. Something special about returning home, putting a meal in the oven that is ready and filling when you've had a few minutes to unwind, turn on/up the heat, even bathe or shower and then eat.
Jean W. - Turlock, CA
The Shepard's Pie was delicious.
Rick S. - Atlanta, GA
Centerville pies are so delicious. The shephard pie is unbelievable!! Yummy!! I plan on trying them all!!
Julie A. - Danville, CA
pie was on time greatest chicken pie excellent crust
Michael s. - Venice, FL
On time, tasty
A&C F. - Rancho Mirage, CA
The Centerville chicken pot pie was excellent. It was well packed and still frozen when we received them. It was part of a birthday gift for my sister and she was very pleased.
Patricia H. - Brooklyn, NY
Everything went perfectly. Great description and prep instructions online for consideration in gift decisions. Receipt and Status updates. Delivery, careful packaging, perfect instructions, delicious.
Steve C. - Sun City West, AZ
The pie was packaged carefully, the product was delicious and the ordering and subsequent post order communication was perfect!
Rob C. - Escondido, CA
Easy to order, arrived on time and recipients were thrilled to get their delicious chicken pies from Centerville Pie Co.
Marilyn S. - Chappaqua, NY
Everything!! Arrival to CA FROM MA was in a very timely fashion. The recipients were thoroughly happy with the chicken, and Shepard's pies by the girls in the cape......☺️
Edward I. - Oceanside, CA
Arrived well packaged, on time & sooo delicious 😋 We all loved it! Loaded with yummy chicken & great tasting crust 🙂
Lameko L. - Hayward, CA
Easy ordering, all products were packaged really well and arrived on time. Oh, and did I mention they were delicious?? Well they were!
Pamela B. - Orleans, MA
This pie was the best! The crust was flakey and the potatoes, veggies and everything instead was delicious. The only thing I added was brushing the mashed potatoes with butter before baking - lots of butter!
Susan M. - Brooklyn Park, MN
Delivered on time and recipient LOVED the food!
Pat H. - Lady Lake, FL
I found the sight easy to use. I ordered food which people enjoyed - so it was a success. I think Goldbelly is a great service - I know our family in CT has used it extensively throughout the pandemic.
LORRAINE D. - Jupiter, FL
Best chicken pot pie ever!! I didn’t even miss the vegetables it was so savory and tasty!
Cecile F. - Santa Fe, NM
Yummy food...delivered fast and packaged well...I’m a fan 👍☺️
Leslie W. - Easton, MD
Delivery when we wanted AND when they promised. Selection was incredible.
Alan S. - Los Angeles, CA
Everything from ordering to delivery to the quality. Thank you
cheryl s. - Reisterstown, MD
Our spinach pies arrived on the date promised. They were well packed in dry ice so they arrived frozen - not easy since we live in Florida
LORRAINE D. - Jupiter, FL
Everything was great! Product . Product shipped with no damages.
CARLYN D. - Wales, WI
OMG! Best Chicken Pot Pie we've ever had!!!! Amazing crust, filled with chicken pieces...flavor galore!
Cheryl G. - Hampton, NH
Simple online line ordering process. Good email delivery updates. The package arrived when scheduled & the dry ice was still partly frozen.
LORRAINE D. - Jupiter, FL
Excellent customer service and outstanding food items.
John Z. - Harrison, NY
the pie itself quality flavor quality freshness
Carol H. - Newhall, CA
Everything Was delivered as promised
nancy a. - Farmington, MI
Food is delicious and quickly shipped
Elizabeth N. - Plymouth, MA
Packaged well, arrived frozen, simply delicious.
Mary H. - Greenwood, IN
shipping delivery, quality of product excellent
philip j. - Panama City Beach, FL
Vast selection, ease of ordering, delivered on time and well packaged
Chris Z. - Little Egg Harbor Twp, NJ