Toll House Cookie Pie


Carousel Cakes takes their flaky cookie crust and fills it to the top with chocolate chip cookie dough, walnuts, and brown sugar. Served warm or at room temperature, this treat is definitely complemented by a scoop of ice cream.

Carousel Cakes’ recipe for success may be straightforward, but it’s also nearly impossible to duplicate: First-class ingredients, five decades of expert baking skills, and the extra effort of mixing everything by hand and with love go into every cake and cupcake. They have been featured by Oprah on her “O” List and by Barbara Walters and friends on “the View”, they have also been featured by Instyle Magazine, Time Out, New York Magazine, and ABC News.

Kosher Certified

More Details

This Package serves 8 people and includes a 10" Toll House Cookie Pie


Allergens: Wheat, Dairy, Eggs, Nuts, Soy
Kosher Certified

Instructions / Storage

  • Baked Goods ship with dry ice, may thaw in transit
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • All products from Carousel Cakes should be refrigerated upon arrival
  • Enjoy within one week after arrival or store in your freezer for up to 3 months.

To Serve

  • For maximum enjoyment, remove from your refrigerator a few hours before serving (a little longer if frozen).

To Enjoy Warm

  • Preheat oven at 350
  • Bake for approx 10 minutes
  • Remove and let sit for 10 minutes before slicing
  • Enjoy!!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Carousel Cakes ships Monday – Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


It was absolutely delicious. The chocolate mousse was so rich and creamy. The chocolate cake was so moist. The icing was delicious. I would definitely purchase this cake again.
Kathleen B. - Fly Creek, NY
The "Oprah's Favorite Blue Velvet Layer Cake" was fabulous!! Very moist and a delicious flavor!!! And the icing was yummy!!! Will definitely buy again!!!
Cathie F. - Middle River, MD
Oprah's Favorite Blue Velvet Layer Cake - This was the best tasting cake I had ever eaten! It arrived on time and still tasted amazing even though it had been frozen and defrosted in the fridge. The texture was amazing, it was Mario moist and fluffy and the blue velvet was just beautiful.
Renee P. - Castaic, CA
It arrived still frozen witch was good. When we ate it was was like it was freshly made.
Gary C. - Pasadena, CA
Quick service. Good product. Fun items. Can’t wait to try something else.
karen m. - Wolcott, CT
Shipped on time and cupcakes looked prefect! They were a gift for my 101 year old grandma’s birthday and she loved them!
Bea L. - Santa Barbara, CA
Delicious, arrived fresh and on the appointed date. Huge hit surprise for the blue-loving recipient to cut into it and discover the awesome color.
Laurei K. - Columbus, OH
AMAZING!!!!! Not only did as look as good as the picture tasted even better. It didn't last the first night...we devoured it!! Thank you
Wendy F. - Nashville, TN
The Blue Velvet Cake was everything and awesome!!!!
Tracy W. - Washington, DC
Blue velvet cake is amazing - who knew?
anne B. - Austin, TX
Delicious cupcakes that looked too good to eat but we did anyway! They were scrumptious! I will order from Carousel again.
Susana V. - Orlando, FL
It is the best cake I ever had in USA
Roy B. - Plantation, FL
Beautiful and yummy. The cake was very moist
September S. - San Angelo, TX
This blue velvet cake with the cream cheese frosting was the best cake that I have ever eaten!! It was moist and absolutely beautiful!! The convenience of having a super delicious melt-in-your mouth cake delivered directly to my door is absolute heaven!!
Lisa G. - Newton, MA
All was delivered as promised. The cake was very delicious and looked wonderful. Excellent service, excellent product!
Jerry M. - New York, NY
I sent it as a gift to a friend who could be a Judge for a chocolate cake contest! He said it was the BEST chocolate cake he ever had!
Greg B. - Indianapolis, IN
Fresh delicious and got excellent reviews from everyone at the Hanukkah Party!
Barbara E. - Melville, NY
The order of 12 Carousel Cupcakes were sent to my sister who lives in Louisville, KY and was celebrating her special 70th birthday. She loved them, told me they were yummy, and was so surprised! Thanks so much! Will order again.
Sheila J. - Louisville, KY
The Blackout cake was moist and delicious. Will definitely be getting another one!
Pamela E. - Worcester, MA
The party ate every last bite!
Ellie D. - Sausalito, CA
It was a special Birthday gift. Arrived on time. Loved the blue velvet cake
Barbara K. - Fort Myers, FL
My daughter said that the red velvet cake I sent her for her birthday wa some of the best that she’s ever had. She said it was moist and the frosting was scrumptious. Very pleased with my choice.
Casey L. - Santa Paula, CA
The cake arrived in perfect condition. I got it for my daughter's birthday and she was so excited! She said it was one of the best cakes she had ever eaten!
Andrea M. - Auburn, AL
The cake was great! I ordered it for my own birthday, people acted like that was so sad, no one to get me a cake. But once it was cut, they all wanted more and the info on how to get it. My grandson decorated the top because it came without flower. I will order again & so will everyone that had a piece.
Jennifer M. - Egg Harbor Township, NJ
I was hesitant to order yet was intrigued with comments I read from others who have ordered. The Chocolate Mousse Cake was a gift to a friend going to undergo surgery and rather than send flowers, she, a chocolate lover, would much prefer something tasty to enjoy before and after her surgery. The cake was delivered within a few days just as the company stated and she said it is DELICIOUS! I am very pleased and would order this or other items again. It is refreshing to receive a quality product that is advertised as such.
Georgia T. - Pittsburgh, PA
Cake arrived on time and was delicious, just as advertised
JamesAudreyLogan C. - Columbia, MD
Husband said his birthday Carousel chocolate mousse cake was delicious, and he is pretty picky about chocolate mousse.
Teri K. - Laguna Niguel, CA
The cupcakes were delivered on time and they were absolutely delicious! They are a little pricey but for a special occasion definitely worth it! I will use Goldbelly in the future!
Carrie B. - Pittsburgh, PA
The cake arrived just as stated. It was a hit for my husband's Valentine. The cake was fresh and moist and he didn't have anything but good things to say about it. It was the best Red Velvet ever. We will highly recommend this cake!!
Judyette R. - Birmingham, AL
I ordered Oprah’s favorite red velvet cake and had it sent for my son’s 21st birthday. He is away in college over 5hours away and I wasn’t able to see him on his birthday. The cake arrived when it was supposed to and my son says it’s the best Red Velvet cake he’s ever had!
Rameen Jr - Indiana, PA
Delivered on time and still frozen.
Marianna F. - West Orange, NJ
This was a surprise birthday cake and it arrived on the afternoon of the celebrant's birthday. She was completely surprised and said the cake came perfectly packaged and was delicious! I will definitely order again from Carousel Cakes.
Sr. C. - Rockville Centre, NY
Cake arrived on the anticipated date, in perfect condition. GREAT packaging as always.......just wonderful to get these delicious treats so far from their local sources!
Polly N. - Palm Harbor, FL
Excellent quality, excellent taste, fast shipping, packaged well.
Darla S. - Asheville, NC
Package received on time and in pristine condition! Cake & pie I ordered were delicious!
Christina B. - Pelham, NY
Ordered a birthday cake for my sister. It was easy to order and the lovely cake arrived on her birthday.
Lorraine S. - Canton, GA
The Blue Velvet cake is delicious and was delivered as stated.
ANGELA J. - Winchester, TN
Sent cupcakes to Massachusetts for nephew’s high school graduation. Was told they were “the best cupcakes we’ve ever had.” Good job, Goldbelly!
Davis R. - North Andover, MA
Beyond delicious ~ it was a hit at the party!!! Really rave reviews from some deep foodies, perfect!!! People are still raving ~ best one we've ordered ~!!! My brother will most likely be on your list !!
Mary S. - Minnetonka, MN
Everything went well. The delivery was made on the date requested for a graduation party, the package was packed perfectly, nothing was damaged in transit, and the cupcakes ordered were beautiful and delicious!
Cheryl G. - North Bellmore, NY
The cake came perfectly packaged, and was delicious. It is hard to find a good tasting cake that is not chocolate. (I cannot eat chocolate)
Gwen H. - Hebron, CT
Delivery on time!! Was a gift and my daughter and friends loved the cake !! Fresh and delicious!!
Lauren S. - Woodstock, GA
Everything! I live in Florida. An elderly friend in West Nyack, NY was celebrating her 95th birthday this year on.April 21. I ordered a Chocolate Outrage Cake from Goldbelly, and it arrived on time, in good condition, and with instructions. She had friends over for cake and coffee and tea, and they all said it was the best chocolate cake they have ever eaten. You can be sure they will be buying the Chocolate Outrage Cake in the future.
Louise S. - West Nyack, NY
Easy to order, arrived as promised in good condition. My grandchildren loved the cupckes
Madeleine Z. - Littleton, CO
entire order...cake arrived in perfect condition due to solid carton it was packaged in...Baileys is my favorite liqueur and this moist cake oozed with its flavor...the buttercream frosting finished off this light, decadent cake! another winner from my #1 go to food site online!
Joseph D. - Plainville, CT
packaging was excellent and cupcakes arrived in perfect condition. They were fresh and delicious
JoAnn S. - Evans City, PA
Delivery & product: absolutely perfect. Goldbelly & their portfolio of food vendors have NEVER let me down. Bravo!
Francine R. - Dayton, OH
Everything! Order was placed. Delivery told us when to expect. Food arrived and it was delicious. Can't wait to do it again.
Marcia K. - Wayne, NJ
Prompt delivery, easy tracking, great website and my son said his cake was delicious!
Drew C. - Washington, DC
Everything from the ordering pricess online to the delivery which was delivered on time and in perfect condition. I am so thrilled.
Carmen C. - Fort Myers, FL
Everything!! From ordering, to delivery when promised! And the cakes.......OOOohhhhh those CAROUSEL CAKES!!! I would absolutely recommend Goldbelly, and I use them multiple times in the year!
Tracey P. - Warwick, NY
My grandson said that the red velvet cake was the best that he’s ever had. The cake arrived cool and in perfect condition.
Zachary C. - Cambridge, MA
The packaging was perfect. Our cake arrived chilled and in perfect shape. Best of all, it was as delicious as I had hoped.
Claudia B. - Snowmass Village, CO
It arrived perfectly packaged. I was nervous because of the 100 + degree we've been experiencing, but it was perfect.
Pamela G. - Alamogordo, NM
Everything. Placing the order was simple and my cakes came quickly and not a single ounce of damage in sight. I am very happy!
Michelle R. - Yonkers, NY
My cake came on time and well packaged. I will definitely order again.. Thank you
Daphnay J. - Leominster, MA
arrived on time and in perfect condition
Kelli D. - Trumbull, CT
Huge variety of items from which to choose; easy to order; delivery as promised
David H. - Baltimore, MD
delivered on time, recipient loved the cupcakes, life is good, goldbelly is good. thank you!
Paul G. - Lansdale, PA
Everything went well. Everything was delivered on time and in perfect condition. Everything was delicious and fresh.
Amy H. - Hillsborough, NJ
everything- packaged well- ice inside- arrived perfect!
Michal M. - Naperville, IL
Easy order, good customer service, order arrived on time!
Heather K. - Washington, IA
The delivery was perfect timing and the cake was great!
VISHAL L. - Edgewater, NJ
This coconut snowball cake was amazing! Everything about it was perfect for my husbands birthday and our 3yo grand daughter loved it too! Thank you- carousel cakes!
Lisa B. - Edgartown, MA
The recipient that received the cake absolutely loved it she said it was very fresh and tasty!
Cindy D. - East Falmouth, MA
Ordering process went smoothly, mail deliveries right on time. Food was great, well packed and delicious.
Brenda P. - Highland Lakes, NJ
I have ordered cakes twice as a gifts. The recipient was thrilled with the presentation, messaging and quality!
Ginny F. - Medford, OR
I ordered a chocolate cake shipped from NY to CA as a birthday gift and was worried the shipping would be late or delayed. But it wasn't! The cake arrived safely on the exact date requested and it was thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated!
Angelo V. - Daly City, CA
The recipient loved the quality. Delivery went well, also.
Joseph O. - Pitman, NJ
Arrived on time and just as described. The packaging kept the cakes frozen. And the cakes are delicious!
Karen K. - Perry Hall, MD
Delivery was as promised. Cake arrived in perfect condition. My daughter loves her cake. It’s for her birthday! Will definitely order again in the future.
Lytetia T. - Germantown, MD
The cake was delivered fast and was packaged great. Bought for my husband’s birthday and was seriously the best birthday cake we’ve ever had! Carousel Cakes did a fantastic job!
Brandee P. - Berlin, NH
The online order process is easy. The selections are bountiful. And the product ordered - black and white mousse cake from Carousel Cakes was delicious.
Brian P. - San Diego, CA
The mousse cake from carousel cakes was absolutely delicious! What a wonderful service to deliver the best food to my children who are spread out all across the country!! I have discovered a wonderful opportunity to surprise them and share the best food from the best restaurants!
Brad A. - Huntersville, NC
Everything, I ordered for my daughter's birthday kind of late and was sooo pleased with product and delivery. Even during a snow storm.!! Cupcakes were amazing!!!
Marlene S. - Hanover Township, PA
Delivered as promised. Both cakes were absolutely delicious!! Can’t wait to order other special treats!!
Linda J. - Leawood, KS
The way the cake was delivered was superb And the cake is delicious. I was looking for a coconut cream layer cake. I found it. I will be ordering another!
Marie C. - Port Orange, FL
2nd order..cake was delivered at reasonable time and was still cold Was delicious..not overbearing with just one flavor...tasted banana peanut butter and chocolate in every bite. Thank you! Will order again.
Elizabeth D. - Port Ewen, NY
Arrived on time and perfect! My Brothers Birthday and He LOVED IT 👍👍👍
Gary C. - Tumacacori, AZ
Timely delivery and my daughter said the cupcakes I ordered for her birthday from Carousel Cakes were the best she ever had.
Krista P. - Lawrenceville, GA
The best red velvet cake that I’ve had in a long time. Will definitely be ordering another at some point in the near future.
Donald P. - Dudley, MA
Delivery was on time Cake was delicious
Miriam M. - Boca Raton, FL
Dependable delivery. Items arrived in great condition.
Karen S. - Scottsdale, AZ
Delivery was timely. Cake arrived in perfect condition…and tasted great.
Barbara T. - Howell, NJ
Fresh and delicious!
Elise O. - Staten Island, NY
It arrived on time & was the best coconut cake I’ve ever had… & I’ve had plenty.
Stephanie M. - Winchester, VA
Everything, excellent cake
Donna K. - Forked River, NJ
Purchased the cookies at Thanksgiving from Ferrara and as just as last time, the cookies were delicious. The Classic cupcakes from Carousel were a gift for someone but was told that they were delicious.
Theresa S. - Staten Island, NY
The Brooklyn Blackout cake was delicious!
Ryan B. - Staten Island, NY
Easy to order. Many choices. Cake arrived in excellent condition
Joshua S. - Chattanooga, TN
Delivered on time and the food was excellent. Overpriced but good.
Harold T. - Durham, NC
Delivery was right on time. Quality was superior to any I could have obtained locally. The cake was splendid.
Cynthia R. - Fort Mohave, AZ
Everything…. The food, the service and the delivery
Matt, T. - Oceanside, NY
Everything went well, cake was delivered in beautiful condition, on time and was delicious‼️🤗
Judith M. - Hamilton, NJ
The Cakes were absolutely Delicious!! They came in perfect condition.
Grant G. - Cambridge, MA
All deliveries on time and in perfect condition.
Roger B. - New York, NY
Food great, delivery great.
SHIRLEY M. - Union, ME
Cake came on time! And tasted yummy
Dara G. - New York, NY
The Carousel Cake, Ebbinger's Blackout Cake, was the favorite cake of our friend when she was growing up in Brooklyn. We sent her this for her 88th Birthday and made her day!!
Sr. C. - Rockville Centre, NY
Everything my mom loved it
Janice G. - Ocala, FL
The Chocolate Outrage from Carousel Cakes was deemed the "best cake ever" by the chocolate loving recipient who's eaten more Chocolate cakes than most. Delivery was right on time
Doug H. - Jacksonville, FL
The Carousel Cakes red velvet cake was absolutely delicious! I have had many red velvets cakes and this one tops them all!
Angela A. - Sea Isle City, NJ
The red velvet cake was delicious. It arrived moist and fresh, the day after it was ordered. Everyone loved it.
Jessica W. - Lake Wales, FL
Arrived as schedules very well packaged. My wife loved cake order for her birthday. Rich flavor.
John I. - York, PA
Delivery was as promised. Delivered in a wonderful bag that was like a present in itself. The Baileys Cream Cake was perfect in its presentation. My daughter, in Miami, said that this Bailey's cake was even better the second day when it became infused with the Espresso Bean flavors. Moist and Delicious!
Isis T. - Miami Beach, FL
The delivery went according to plan, with routine updates during the delivery process. The cake was expertly packaged and arrived in perfect condition. We followed the simple serving directions and the cake was DELICIOUS! It was for Father’s Day and mousse cake is my husband’s favorite. It was the best we’ve ever had!!! We will absolutely order again!
Geri B. - Henderson, NV
Everything. From ordering to delivery was seamless. Plus the cake was delicious.
Marc S. - Blanco, TX
The whole experience as good: online ordering, good selection, on time delivery, pretty packaging, arrived fresh, family gifted said red velvet cake and cupcakes were delicious. Thank you!
Madison F. - Ann Arbor, MI
The cake arrived on time as promised and was delicious. Everybody loved it.
Phyllis S. - Temple, TX
The cake ordering was so easy. I was able to track my package in real time. The delivery was on time on the day I requested. The cake came well boxed. The taste was very fresh and very good. We enjoyed this cake for my husbands birthday!
Bimala H. - Calhoun, GA
The perfect Red Velvet Cake was delivered for my Daughter’s Birthday!
Kaylan P. - Matthews, NC
My whole experience with goldbelly was AMAZING! my order arrived on time and was very fresh. The cupcakes I ordered from carousel cakes were so delicious and yummy. I will definitely be ordering again with Goldbelly.
Amani H. - Dania Beach, FL
Everything went well. Well, everything went perfectly. Delivered EXACTLY on time and my mom said she never never tasted anything like it in her 80 years on the planet.
Janet L. - Nehalem, OR
The cake arrived with the dry ice and I put it in the fridge to thaw for Mother's Day. It was moist and delicious. Blue Velvet cake loved by all.
Candace S. - Memphis, TN
Cake was in one piece, beautifully decorated and was absolutely delicious ! I sent this cake as a birthday surprise and it was a big hit. It was delivered on the day promised.
Marie W. - Staten Island, NY
Ordering was easy. Delivery was on time. Recipient very pleased with the cake and shared with others and froze some for himself to eat into the summer. A great experience all around.
Michael J. - San Francisco, CA
The outrage cake is fantastic. I ordered it last year for a very elderly friend, and she was hoping I would send another one this year. She said it is the best chocolate cake she has ever had.
Louise S. - West Nyack, NY