Cider Roasted Apple Pie in Double Cheddar Crust

LA Weekly rated this pie as the Best Pie in LA! The whimsical bakers at LA’s Cake Monkey are reinventing our favorite childhood treats and making them even better than we ever imagined. To make the savory crust, Cake Monkey cuts shreds of cheddar cheese into the pie dough before it’s rolled out. Sweet Pink Lady and tart Granny Smith apples are then roasted in Vermont cider jelly, brown butter and vanilla bean to make the filling for this unconventional, but completely satisfying pie.

More Details

  • Each pie is approximately 9-inches in diameter and serves 8-10 people


apples, butter, cider jelly, sugar, flour, cheddar cheese, cider vinegar, baking powder, water, salt

Instructions / Storage

  • Remove the pie from the insulated container and bring to room temperature.
  • Each pie is delicious at room temperature
  • For best enjoyment, reheat the room temp pie in your oven for 10 minutes at 325 degrees
  • The pie does should not be kept in the refrigerator and will keep at room temp for 3 – 4 days.
  • For longer storage, you may keep it in the freezer for up to 2 weeks.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Cake Monkey ships Monday-Wednesday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from California


Cake Monkey has the most delicious sweet goodies I have ever tasted. The only problem I have when I order these heavenly bakery items is that I eat them before bringing to my friend's homes. 😟🤣
Julie A. - Danville, CA
First time ordering the little cakes from Cake Monkey. They were excellent and a big hit!! Arrived in perfect condition too.
Karen R. - Los Olivos, CA
Neatly wrapped, tasty, chocolate did not melt, seemed fresh out of the oven. 
Alison R. - New Port Richey, FL
Everything was so delicious. It was packed well so nothing was smashed. I would feel good about sending this as a gift.
Donnelle F. - Hoffman Estates, IL
I ordered the Cakewich gift pack for my family and they loved that the cakes were not overly sweet. The cakes are the perfect size to indulge but not overindulge.
Malynda D. - Vancouver, WA
What can I say about eating the most delicious sample cakes from Cake Monkey, other than I hate them for being SO DELICIOUS!!! I LITERALLY hide a few from family members (sorry, not sorry😒), so I can secretly come downstairs late at night and savor these unbelievable tasty cakes, you will never want to buy a pop tart or any dessert from supermarket or bakery after eating from Cake Monkey. I bake, and I am very particular about my desserts. The cake-like yodel from when you were young in the sampler pack is beyond delicious, forget Hostess or any Entenmann's, these cakes and toaster pastries are so amazing!! They come so fresh and are so delicious!!
Julie A. - Danville, CA
I purchased the sampler box. Every single item in the box was out of this world delicious!! I will definitely be ordering again. The packaging was awesome too!
Jill B. - San Diego, CA
It came as scheduled and was such an unexpected gift for my step-father who is the hardest person to buy for. He has already dug into the pies and said they were out of this world!
Lindsey L. - Houston, TX
I ordered cakewiches to my parents' cabin in Pennsylvania (that's in a pretty remote area mind you, I'm talking like a few steps short of off-the-grid) for my mom's birthday, and these unique deserts came all the way from Southern Cali. They showed up on time, still cold, and my mom was completely surprised. She was tickled and everything worked out perfectly. Can't thank you all enough!
Andrew B. - Spring Grove, PA
Wow!!! Fast as lightning getting to my home from California to Connecticut, ice packs still frozen in this ungodly heat and humidity. The cakes were perfect. Fresh and in perfect order. Definitely going to purchase more through you!!!!
Victoria R. - Coventry, CT
Very fresh cakes, a 12 pack, 3 different types of cakes. Super rich, even though they may appear modest in size, one cake lasts the day because it is so rich - one or two bites is plenty and decadent. It was definitely a treat I would not have thought of getting myself, but have really enjoyed as a birthday gift. I would recommend it to anyone that wants to give the gift of more than one kind of treat!
Shaun M. - Concrete, WA
As good tasting as it was tastefully packaged.
Patricia B. - Scottsdale, AZ
Cake monkey flavors are first rate! The Gluten free cakes and cookies are so incredible you don't miss the gluten! Truly Masterful!
Brian W. - Atoka, TN
On time delivery and professionally packaged. Food/baked goods was excellent. Website easy to navigate and search.
Chris S. - Canton, GA
Delivered exactly on time, fabulously delicious, made my granddaughter’s birthday so special. Thank you
daisy S. - Moultonborough, NH
Package tracking and delivery notifications were helpful. The order from Cake Monkey was a surprise so I was nervous about sending a box of cakes from California to New Jersey. I had nothing to worry about. They arrived carefully packaged and were delicious! Great experience overall.
JENNIFER R. - Joint Base Mdl, NJ
Great delivery , cakes were still intact and well frozen. Absolutely stunning mini cakes with beautiful frosting. Great packaging and delicious cakes! Would order again and was a hit for my small party!
Sandeep S. - Yuba City, CA
Fast shipping and my daughter said the items were delicious!
Rebecca S. - Novi, MI
The pop tarts were wonderful. The packaging was beautiful and everyone loved them. Thank you and we'll be ordering again soon.
Lynda L. - San Francisco, CA
Everything! Ease of purchase, Speed of shipment, Customer service throughout, FollowUp survey. Oh yes, Cake Monkey cherry almond pie was DEVINE! The unusual crust made it a special birthday treat.
CALI M. - Leavenworth, KS
The dessert was a gift. The receiver was raving. Orders are always delivered on time. Thanks
Frances P. - Morganville, NJ
Items arrived on time to the person I shipped them too. The note I sent was included and they loved the pastry I sent them!
Joshua L. - Acton, MA
The recipients of each of the gifts sent photos and raved about the lovely packaging as well as the tasty treats.
Lori O. - Seaside, CA
Recipient loved the products. Beautiful presentation and very tasty dessert treats. Very fresh
Lisa K. - Rancho Cucamonga, CA
Cake Monkey was excellent, and the individually wrapped deserts were excellent.
James G. - Ponte Vedra Beach, FL
Great selection of tasty goodies, and speedy delivery. The product actually arrived 2 day earlier than expected.
Doug W. - Fresno, CA
Arrived as scheduled, and recipient said it was delicious.
Revia C. - Madison, MS
My order arrived in perfect condition and the cake rolls were delicious!!
Amy H. - Chesapeake, VA
Delivery on time all the way to Hawaii!
Grace J. - Waialua, HI
They loved it! I’ll definitely be gifting more Goldbelly in the future!
Dads C. - Ruskin, FL
As always everything from ordering to eating was awesome. One of the best services online. Every time we send someone something its always followed by it was the best we ever ate!
Joan E. - Pleasant Hill, IA
The cake rolls are divine! Total heaven in every bite!!!
Sherry N. - Katy, TX
Excellent shipping and handling! Arrived on time & in perfect shape! Product tasted yummy!
Tammy W. - Port Orchard, WA
User friendly web site Quick and accurate date (requested delivery date) of delivery Quality product
cindra m. - Ordway, CO
Pie delivered on time and recipient said it was delicious.
Steven G. - Thousand Oaks, CA
I'm always impressed with how well the goods are packaged. It's like Fort Knox in those boxes.
Brooke C. - Baton Rouge, LA
Delicious mini cakes!!
Tammy M. - Marble Falls, TX
My order came on schedule. Products were perfect.
Alexys P. - Grants Pass, OR
great product and delivered as arranged
Asher C. - Tacoma, WA
This was a birthday gift. She LOVED it! She emailed me every day with what she had tried (devoured). This sampler was a hit.
Ginny M. - Troy, ID
Food arrived on time and every bit was delicious as promised.
Jennifer O. - Fairfield, CA
Quick delivery. Product was even better than pictures. Absolutely perfect!!!
Ashley M. - Yorktown Hts, NY
Order arrived quickly. It was packaged perfectly and everything arrived in great shape. All of the cakes are wrapped individually, so everything arrived fresh. Everything was delicious. I would definitely buy this again.
Stacy G. - Weeki Wachee, FL
Delivery was great, my daughter loves her cookie sampler.
Lauren G. - Los Angeles, CA