Peanut Butter Buckeyes - 8 Pack

(Customer Reviews)

Butter Maid Bakery ships its famous Buckeyes nationwide on Goldbelly! Buckeyes are a super-popular Ohio delicacy, but the secret is out! These chocolate-covered peanut butter fudge balls were named after the state tree, the Ohio Buckeye tree. No machine produced factory candy here; these are all handmade with simple ingredients!

Butter Maid Bakery is one of the Midwest’s longest-running bakeries, going strong since founder Dimitri Naumoff emigrated from the Old Country to Youngstown, Ohio, in 1903 and brought his ample baking skills with him. After several moves and name changes, his son, Nicholas, opened Butter Maid Bakery in Boardman in 1955, and today it’s run by fifth-generation Naumoffs, who use the freshest, highest-quality ingredients they can find to turn out a huge variety of baked goods and sweets.

More Details

This package serves 6 people and includes 8 Peanut Butter Buckeyes.

  • Each box of Buckeyes weighs 12 oz.
  • Buckeyes arrive in branded packaging


Pure Cane Powdered Confectioners Sugar (Cane Sugar, Cornstarch), Cocoa Confectionery Wafers (Sugar, Partially Hydrogenated Palm Kernel And Cottonseed Oils, Nonfat Dry Milk, Cocoa, Milk, Glyceryl Lacto Esters Of Fatty Acids, Soy Lecithin, And Salt), Peanut Butter, Butter. Allergen Warning: Contains Peanuts, Milk & Soy. Our Bakery Uses Wheat, Tree Nuts & Eggs.

Instructions / Storage

  • These products arrive ready to enjoy
  • For optimum freshness, freeze Buckeyes upon arrival and thaw at room temperature overnight, or several hours before serving.
  • Buckeyes will last in the refrigerator up to 14 days, or frozen up to 6 months.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Butter Maid Bakery ships Monday through Friday each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Ohio


Delectable items shipped right to my door. Can't ask for better than that!
Anthony H. - Christiansburg, VA
Everything was packaged well and every product was delivered completely in tact. Nothing was smashed or broken.
Cynthia B. - Beloit, WI
Delivered in a timely manner and everything in tip top condition! Thank you
Marie F. - New City, NY
Everything was received with JOY and HAPPINESS. Only complaints I got were "YOU ARE TRYING TO FATTEN ME UP. AS EVERYTHING WAS CONSUMED WITH JOY"
Mason P. - Wellington, FL
We're on COVID lockdown ....Goldbelly was such a great way to try new foods from shops we probably never thought of visiting. We think the prices are high, but at our age, something deliciously unique makes a wonderful gift. We bookmarked your site so we can be ready for the next big occasion. Also like that shops can be regionally accessed so we can support folks closer to our area, too! Thank you!
ER P. - Monaca, PA
Arrived on time as scheduled. It was a gift and the person who received it loved it! Said the buckeyes were delicious.
Melissa B. - Mesa, AZ
Everything went very well! I have not been disappointed yet! From the packaging to the product to the shipping, all seems to be top notch!!!
Megan B. - Walpole, NH
I've had VERY FEW probs with shipments from Goldbelly and have always had a quick and satisfactory resolution to the few I have and I do a a LOT of business with these guys!!
steph h. - Bensalem, PA
High quality, reminded me of my grandmothers house!
eric m. - Saint Louis, MO
Delivery on time, product fantastically packaged, food delicious
- ,
The cookies were so good. My daughter about ate them all. We will order these again.
Sharon W. - Warner Robins, GA
Ordering was easy as is finding things. Only problem is that everything looks scrumptious. Shipping is cool. I am now very familiar with the site. Oh, and I like the rewards, though I wish they were dollar for dollar, like Schwann's. Will still use you after the pandemic for specialty items. It's your fault, I'm hooked.
Joseph I. - Georgetown, PA
We ordered a poppyseed and walnut nut rolls and they are delicious. There was a lot of filling in them and hey were very fresh. Our son came to Easter dinner and surprised us with a duplicate order so they are in he freezer for another day.
Jacquelyn V. - Apex, NC
Ease of ordering, well packaged items, on time delivery, exceptional products.
Jessica C. - Chandler, AZ
Product looked and tasted just like my grandmothers.
germaine l. - Saint Louis, MO
I left Boardman over 20 years ago and this is the first time I've had kalochi that was as good as my grandmother used to make. Will be recommending it to all my family!
Jim D. - Seattle, WA
My father loved it! We’ve moved from WI to VA and my father will never travel here. I’wanted to send him some of the tastes I love from the south. I got to share my new home experience in a creative way.
Larry S. - Stevens Point, WI
Excellent food!
Craig K. - Palm Coast, FL
Great food and delivery
Craig K. - Palm Coast, FL
Quick shipping, I bought a Kolachi it was excellent.
Dianne G. - Spring Hill, FL
Site was easy to navigate… smooth process. Delivered in good time in good condition.
Michael N. - Irvine, CA
It was delivered promptly, and beind vacuum seales, they appear to be VERY, DELICIOUS.. I will be ordering more. They remind me of the ones my Grandma would make me
Gary C. - Gresham, OR
The delivery was great with every cookie in tack. My granddaughter loved them and her friends loved them also.
Amelia C. - College Station, TX
Package arrived on time. Excellent product. Definitely order again.
Teri C. - Warren, OH
I received my orders from Butter Maid and Joey Bats as expected, and they were delicious! The selection and purchase processes were simple.
Kendra M. - Marietta, GA
The person taking the order was very courteous, thorough, & respectful. He made sure everything was correct before hanging up. Delivery was fast & the order received was correct & packaged well.
Maryann D. - Boulder, CO
I got the order so fast. I had ordered it from the company and got the run around. I got it to my boys for Christmas and they loved it.
Judith W. - Temple, TX
Arrived well packaged--vacuum packed--and in a timely manner. The nut roll was delicious!! My mother-in-law used to make these at Christmas and my husband was delighted that we could get one as good as hers. I am glad that I ordered three.
Janis A. - Charleston, WV
Everything went well! Great communication, well packaged, and product was GREAT! Will definitely order this product again!!
Deborah A. - Eden, NY
I was told by both recipients that the pumpkin roll was very delicious and delivery was right on target
Lynn W. - Grayslake, IL
Placing the order was very easy and shipping was fast! Cute packaging with handwritten packaging card, a very personal touch!
Katie B. - Pasadena, CA
The selection of products available is so extensive, and I was able to find a special birthday treat that was exactly right. It was delivered on the selected date, and the baked goods were fantastic!
Thomas D. - Cincinnati, OH
Everything was great, packaging!!!
GARLAND D. - Thornton, CO
Shipping, delivery, and packaging.
Joan H. - Murrells Inlet, SC
You provided quaility items that were delivered on time
John K. - Clarkdale, AZ
Our kolachi were delivered on time, in good shape, and were delicious. Also, the enclosed instructions for serving and storing were helpful.
Arlene S. - Arlington, VA
All is wonderful! My products are exceptional and so so tasty. I have found my new baker. I have already recommended you to friends. I thank you for being so good at what you do so I will be back for more orders. Thank you so much.
Regina G. - Pittsburgh, PA
Everything came is great condition.
Helen C. - Orem, UT
Delivered on time and in great condition
Raoul B. - Beaverton, OR
Product was fabulous
Brenda R. - LAKE WORTH, FL
Very good cookies.
John D. - San Francisco, CA
It was delicious and arrived on time.
Kevin G. - Portland, OR
Tasted delicious!
Sally S. - Seagrove, NC
Delivered on time and delicious and I got it for 20% off
Maria A. - Brick, NJ
Perfect. And the taste was fantastic.
Laura G. - Sikeston, MO
Kolache rolls were fabulous, but very pricey.
Christina N. - Lakeland, FL