Gooey Butter Cookies - 6 Pack

Blue Owl Bakery ships its famous cakes nationwide on Goldbelly! These St. Louis gooey butter flavor cookies are inspired by gooey butter cake. Blue Owl’s gooey butter cookies are super moist, buttery-flavored cookies.

Everyone in the tiny town of Kimmswick, Missouri, knows Mary Hostetter’s Blue Owl, founded in 1983, is the spot for a delicious, country-style meal, and word of her famously tall, flaky-crusted Levee-High Apple Pie quickly traveled around the world and made her down-home Blue Owl Bakery a source for a true slice of heaven. The bakery’s famous Caramel Apple Pecan Levee High Pie was named one of Oprah’s Favorite Things.

More Details

This package includes 6 Gooey Butter Cake Cookies

Each cookie serves 1 person and measures 4"

Ingredients

Butter, cream cheese, vanilla, eggs, yellow Pillsbury cake mix, powdered sugar, egg

Instructions / Storage

Cookies ship frozen with ice packs and may thaw in transit
Cookies can be kept at room temperature for 1-2 weeks
Alternatively freeze in a sealed bag for up to 6 months.
Best served at room temperature

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

Blue Owl Bakery ships Monday-Thursday of each week
Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!

Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

(
4.7) Blue Owl Bakery REVIEWS

The two pies were....glorious. I know the apple pie was expensive, but what is the price of a great tah dah moment? It would make a spectacular gift.

Linda S. - Los Angeles, CA

12/02/19

Gooey Butter Cake is amazing!

Jackie B. - Malden, MA

11/28/19

Arrived frozen in perfect condition. Thawed within 6 hours. We had wonderful fun making the Levee high pie. Was a real family event. Lots of laughs and photos.

April H. - Port Saint Lucie, FL

11/21/19

Best chocolate cake ever!

Stuart K. - Waxhaw, NC

02/17/20

The cheesecake was in great shape when it arrived, and was still frozen.

Christine P. - Olney, MD

10/11/20

Delivery was great, right on time as usual and product met all expectations! The pie was a birthday gift and he was very pleased!

Tom B. - Dayton, OH

09/30/20

The whole experience couldn’t have been easier! The cake was so fresh that my niece could smell it before she even opened the box! Will definitely use again and recommend to others!!

Paige P. - Eugene, OR

09/29/20

The chocolate cake was loved! Great quality & moist. Hard to find in a cake. Thank you. I’ll be back. Living in CA & getting birthday cake to grand daughter in MT can be done!!

Piper D. - Bozeman, MT

09/18/20

The Ooey Gooey Cake was DIVINE!! I will be making that luscious cake myself next. Thanks for introducing it to us!!!

JANET O. - Marietta, GA

09/15/20

Another awesome and yummy special occasion cake delivered by Goldbelly!!! We loved it and it arrived the day it was supposed to! It made my Dad's 96th Birthday all the better!! Thank you so much for such wonderful memories and beautiful tasty treats for us to enjoy always!!! You guys ROCK! Will be back! :)

Lynne F. - Newport Beach, CA

09/10/20

The cake I ordered was delivered when promised and in perfect condition. The cake was delicious and just like the description.

Rebecca S. - Janesville, WI

08/27/20

Cake was delicious! Arrived in excellent condition. Very fresh and beautiful.

Cassandra J. - Lake Charles, LA

08/03/20

Shipment arrived on date specified and in good condition. Was a nice and different birthday gift from Blue Owl and person was very surprised and happy. Thanks.

Mrs. G. - Blakely, GA

03/25/21

My family LOVED the Mile high apple pie! I bought it for my Brothers 60th birthday. (He loves apple pie)...Would definitely buy again.

Patricia L. - Martinsville, NJ

03/21/21

Shipping was perfect, just as expected. When my 77 year old dad saw what his birthday cake was, and where it came from, he got a little teary because it brought back treasured memories. It was a hit!

Leeana T. - Palmdale, CA

03/21/21

I'm hella impressed with the fact that the cake was in perfect condition despite being shipped, I really wasn't expecting that. I was very excited to be able to send a birthday cake to a friend halfway across the country since I couldn't visit and bake him one myself this year because of covid

Andrew T. - Huron, SD

03/11/21

Cake was perfect, though a day late because of blizzard! Next time will order a day ahead. Cake was packed in dry ice and arrived in perfect condition! A Birthday for an adult was eagerly eaten. Delicious!!!

Sally M. - Duluth, MN

02/21/21

Everything!! I’ve ordered 3 different desserts and they all arrived when they were supposed to and they were all DELICIOUS! Gold belly is awesome!

Amie H. - Lumpkin, GA

02/19/21

It was wonderful experience. The cake was amazing. I sent it as a gift and my friend couldn’t stop raving about it for her birthday. I definitely would order it again. Thank you Blue Owl.

Debbie F. - Prescott, AZ

02/11/21

Everything! Delivery time, freshness, taste. This is a pie my husband and I remember eating as children and I was delighted to be able to find one for his birthday.

Brooke G. - Dearborn, MI

01/24/21

My first order ever from Goldbelly was for a lemon cream cake from Blue Owl. The cake was delicious and it arrived in excellent condition. I liked the cake so much, days later I ordered the same cake as a gift. I plan on ordering another lemon cake as a gift in a few days. Now that I had such a nice experience with Goldbelly, I will be ordering for myself again.

Trudy B. - Clifton, VA

01/16/21

Really great customer service. Since it was a surprise gift, I was nervous about the recipient's availability, but it arrived exactly as planned --- even during the pandemic.

Jamie O. - St Simons Island, GA

01/10/21

Arrived exactly on time in perfect condition, and was utterly delicious!

Jennifer B. - Collinsville, AL

05/23/21

The cookies and gooey butter cakes are so dense, moist and delicious!!!

Sherry N. - Katy, TX

05/24/21

This experience was perfect compared to the last one. Choosing the product was easy and the delivery was perfect.

NORMA M. - Somerville, MA

05/14/21

First Blue Owl Lemon Cream Cake was outstanding! How it is packed with such care so you get perfect cake is incredible!

Jean S. - Park Ridge, NJ

05/11/21

Everything expertly packaged beautiful presentation and according to my precious Sister the best pie she’s ever eaten thank you so much

Carol R. - North Hollywood, CA

05/10/21

The ordering process is amazing and the selection is unmatched. I told everyone (here in Alaska) that we can even get things here in 48 hours.

Karen V. - Anchorage, AK

04/26/21

Everything went perfect, my daughter loved her cake. The Blue Owl Bakery is Awesome! Cake was just like the picture, packaged perfectly, delivered on time, tasted heavenly my daughter said. Ordering through GoldBelly is fantastic, super easy and makes finding food treasures fun.

Mindy M. - Stafford, VA

05/08/21

The cake was packaged well and was delicious!!! It’s probably the best carrot cake we’ve had!

Nicole L. - Coconut Creek, FL

04/21/21

The order arrived promptly and was securely packaged. It gave me the chance to try a regional dessert I was unfamiliar with.

Mark E. - Monona, WI

04/17/21

Cake was absolutely delicious!!! We love the convenience of Gold Belly and everything is as advertised. Blue Owl Bakery is one we will be recommending to friends and family.

Melissa M. - Wentzville, MO

04/06/21

The cake we ordered was beautiful and so yummy! Ordering was easy, shipping was fast and delivery was without any problems. The cake arrived on-time and still cold in the packaging. We would definitely order again!

Paula P. - Canyonville, OR

03/16/21

We received our package (The tall, awesome apple pie) early and everyone loved it! The amazing apple pie has definitely brought attention to the Blue Owl Bakery and GoldBelly and both will be used again! Thank you!

Mike B. - Milford, MI

03/12/21