Handmade Ice Cream Sandwiches - 24 Pack

Anderson’s Frozen Custard ships its famous ice cream sandwiches nationwide on Goldbelly! Perfect for satisfying any sweet tooth, these handmade ice cream sandwiches are made in small batches with Anderson’s homemade, hand-spun, award-winning vanilla ice cream, at their flagship store in Kenmore, New York. This package includes 24 Anderson’s ice cream sandwiches: 12 vanilla ice cream sandwiches with sprinkles and 12 vanilla ice cream sandwiches.

For decades, Anderson’s Frozen Custard has been the place in New York State to savor indescribably rich and creamy frozen custard, handmade ice cream, and Western New York’s regional specialty “beef on weck," thinly sliced roast beef, beef jus, and freshly grated horseradish on a Kimmelweck roll. Founded by Carl and Greta Anderson in The Bronx, New York, in 1946 and relocated to Buffalo in 1947, Anderson’s Frozen Custard is still a family-run diner-style destination that continues to appeal to food lovers, who delight in the savory beef on weck and soft, creamy frozen custard made in small batches with hormone-free products.

More Details

This package serves 24 people and includes 24 Anderson’s Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • 12 Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches with sprinkles
  • 12 Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches


Andersons Hard Ice Cream Mix – Pasteurized Grade A Milk And Cream, Sugar, Non Fat Milk Solids, Corn Syrup, Vanilla Extract, Natural And Artificial Flavors, Mono And Diglycerides, Cellulose Gum, Guar Gum, Polysorbate 80, Carrageenan And Caramel Color.
Chocolate Sandwich Wafers – Wheat Flour, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Shortening (Partially Hydrogenated Soybean Oil) Caramel Color, Soy Flour, Corn Starch, Baking Soda, Soy Lecithin, Cocoa, Salt, Natural Vanilla Flavor. Allergens – Dairy, Wheat, Soy
Sprinkles – Sugar, Corn Starch, Partially Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil (Soybean), Soy Lecithin, Confection’s Glaze, FD&C Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5 Lake, Blue 1 Lake, Blue 1, Red 3, Yellow 6 Lake, Natural and Artificial Flavor, and Carnauba Wax.

Allergen info: Made in a facility that processes nuts, gluten and dairy.

Instructions / Storage

  • Ice Cream ships frozen with dry ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival remove packaging and place immediately in the freezer until ready to enjoy
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Anderson’s ships Monday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


Easy to order - hot dogs came packed in refrig packing - ice cold from NY to Texas - I'll never be without my favorite hotdogs - what a great service for so many of us that miss our hometown favorites! Will definitely order again soon and tell others! Thanks - happy customer
Gail R. - Conroe, TX
It was easy to order and have food from out of town delivered. I am not sure how it happened that I had 3 orders instead of one, but Goldbelly easily corrected the mistake.
Anne F. - Wellington, OH
The recipients said it was even better than when they dined in person at Anderson's! That's how fresh everything was. And they send an abundance of ingredients to make the sandwiches. The packaging was pretty wasteful. Lots & lots of plastic bags IN plastic bags. We understand why -- they prep ingredients for the smallest number of sandwiches you can order and multiply out when you buy the larger size. But the amount of plastic in the order would make us reconsider ordering again. It was just way too wasteful (esp for an environmentally conscious household).
Lisa B. - Charlotte, NC
I received Andersons and it was incredible. The best of the best and not one single flaw.
Susan W. - Blakeslee, PA
Hometown Buffalonian....Food was fresh, delicious, and consumed in two nights. We have a Friday Night Supper Club with usually 10 people, the hometown beef on weck is a favorite we’ve had many times!! Thankful you deliver to the Vineyard!
John H. - Edgartown, MA
Free shipping! The beef on weck kit was excellent in all of its components and very generously sized for our family.
Patricia B. - Columbia, SC
Easy to order. Came quickly without overnight delivery charge. Moved away from Buffalo and can still have Buffalo food. Third time ordering and will again. Told all my family to do same. Packed well.
Susan P. - Vestal, NY
We moved from Lockport (Buffalo area) and miss having beef on weck sandwiches - these were so good. Definitely reminded us of our former home. The food was excellent and the delivery time was exceptional.
Carole K. - Fruitland Park, FL
Sandwiches were excellent and potions were fine. Tasted like being there, easy to assemble. Since the meat was frozen hard it would have been impossible to use the day it arrived. Customers should know that.
Brian F. - Painesville, OH
Nice Packaging and 'easy to put ALL together' so that we felt we were eating directly at the restaurant....so GOOD!!!
Betty M. - North Barrington, IL
Living in Florida now it was great receiving this gift from our son. We love Andersons. It was one of our favorites.
Scott C. - Tavares, FL
Great service! Everything arrived on time and in perfect condition! My grandchildren were thrilled to get ice cream for Easter, their favorite place when they come to Buffalo.
Dan M. - Bluffton, SC
Delivery was good. Packaging worked perfectly. The frozen custard was to good to be true. Everyone went back for seconds. THANK YOU for such a great service.
Debra H. - Washington, IL
Everything! I treated myself, and so glad I did! It was all soooo delicious! I will definitely order from Anderson's again! OMG The chocolate fudge! ❤
linda o. - Ventura, CA
This is my second time I've ordered from Anderson's. I was told from both recipients they enjoyed the ice cream and beef sandos. I think it is time I order one for myself.
Tina B. - San Francisco, CA
The order arrived precisely on time, packaged so that the contents arrived in perfect condition and contained very clear prep instructions. Most importantly, the product ordered was delicious and enjoyed by my family. We will definitely order again from Goldbelly and Anderson's Frozen Custard.
Beatrice E. - Pittsburgh, PA
Ordered Anderson's Frozen Custard for an out of state family birthday. Ordering was easy. Shipment arrived on time and in excellent condition.
Millie H. - Hillsboro, OH
Everything arrived perfectly!!
Amanda B. - Johnson City, TN
The recipient loved it! From a place we all went to in our childhood, can now be delivered to their door because of Goldbelly!
Robert S. - Jacksonville, FL
The meal was delicious and well-packaged.
Carol S. - Powell, OH
This is the 3rd time I have ordered from Anderson’s. I am hooked on the convenience of making beef on weck at home.
Barbara S. - Arcade, NY
On time and food was properly prepared and tasty.
Harry C. - Eatonton, GA
Order delivered so quickly from NY to AZ that everything was still frozen! The beef-on-weck was excellent and authentic.
Judith T. - Tucson, AZ
Food arrived frozen and fresh!
DARRYL D. - Great Lakes, IL
Food was fresh and delicious. Everything arrived in perfect condition.
Barbara S. - Arcade, NY
The food -- even the ice cream -- arrived on time and in pristine conditions. The instructions were clear and everything tasted great.
Hilary K. - Middletown, RI
Arrived frozen and cooked up great. We ordered for a celebration of life and everything was amazing.
Heather S. - Lancaster, CA
Delivery on time. Cake absolutely delicious!
Franklin W. - Commack, NY
Product arrived on time and frozen custard was still frozen even though over 90 degrees out.
Jeanine C. - Brentwood, CA
Well packed with clear instructions. The frozen custard was wonderful. Fudge sauce and ice cream scoop was a nice touch.
Suzanne I. - Bow, NH
Delivered on time and still cold after 24 hours in 90+ degree temps.
Margaret D. - League City, TX
I ordered 6 pints of Anderson's Custard... my hubby's favorite for his birthday. The package came the day before his birthday as requested and was beautifully packaged. It is amazing that they can ship frozen custard in the heat of the summer and have it arrive fully frozen.. which it was! My hubby was thrilled and we all are enjoying it. Thanks!
Robin G. - Laurel, MD
Our gift to our son’s family was perfect. They really enjoyed a taste of Western New York. We will definitely order again.
Michael O. - Sandy Spring, MD
Food was well packaged and the order was perfect.
Jonathan K. - Walnut Creek, CA
This is the 4th time I’ve used Goldbelly and for the 4th time, they did not disappoint! The ice cream cake arrived from Anderson’s in perfect condition and it was delicious- definitely a hit for our daughter’s 18th birthday.
Nicole D. - Gilbertsville, PA
Flawless ordering, flawless delivery, food was fresh - brought back memories of "home"
Judith D. - Cornville, AZ
Totally ordering from this company again. Everything was perfect.
Kate R. - Coarsegold, CA
I'm from Buffalo, and the quality of the food was authentic.
John K. - Tarpon Springs, FL
Excellent! From the packing to the quality! The sandwich’s were great and the frozen custard was best I had! I will def ordered again ! Thank you !
Richard G. - Astoria, NY