Coconut Cream Pie

+ Free Shipping

Wendy and Dave Achatz have been concocting some of the nations best pies since 1993, when they started baking in their Victorian home in Armada, Michigan. This Coconut Cream Pie features coconut pastry cream topped with whipped topping and toasted coconut.

More Details

  • Each pie is 10" and serves 8-10 people
  • Package includes separate bags of Whipped Cream Topping and Toasted Coconut


Whole Milk (Milk and Vitamin D3), Whipped Topping, Sugar, Unbleached Pastry Flour (Wheat), Palm Oil, Sugared Egg Yolks (Egg Yolk, Sugar), Coconut, Water, Unsalted Butter (Cream [Milk]), Modified Food Starch, Stabilizer Blend (Sugar, Corn Starch, Carob Bean Gum, Agar and Salt), Vanilla Extract (Water, Alcohol (35%), Sugar, Vanilla Bean Extractives), Coconut Flavor (Organic Sunflower Oil,Natural Flavor), Sea Salt.

Contains: Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nut (Coconut), Wheat

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies are baked fresh, flash frozen and shipped with an ice pack. They arrive frozen
  • Upon arrival, place in the refrigerator or in the freezer to serve later. Allow pie to thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving
  • Pies can be stored in the refrigerator for 4 days or in the freezer for up to 1 month
  • Whipped topping is best used within several days of receiving
  • To serve, pipe whipped topping onto thawed pie (for best results, test out topping on separate surface before piping onto pie). Sprinkle the rest of the toppings and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Pies ship Monday and Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Michigan


Fantastic pie. Not too sweet but just right. Good stuff.
Marlin T. - Eagle, ID
Delivered right on time. My brother loved it. The whipped cream was still cold and spread great on the pie. He told me it was delicious.
Laila B. - Hope, RI
Free delivery is such a treat. The strawberry rhubarb pie was something I really enjoyed during my summer trip to Michigan. However, Goldbelly doesn’t offer the crumble/streusel top. The double crust was definitely more tart, but allowed me to recreate a great summer memory. Thank you!
Allie C. - Fresno, CA
Pie was delicious first of all. Company and website were easy to do business with and shipping was off the charts quick. Mother in law loves pie and now she loves me too.
Rocco P. - Verona, PA
The northern spy apple pie is the best... The crunch is amazing and warmed with coffee ice cream... It was the hit of the birthday party!
Carole G. - Warwick, RI
This was by far the BEST cherry pie I’ve ever had! Natural ingredients made with fresh cherries! It was slightly tart, just perfect! Generous amount of filling and a great crust. The pie was large. I just ordered the blueberry pie to try! I shared a piece of cherry pie with my brother and he thought I made it!
Carolyn R. - Sterling, MA
Great pie! It wasn’t overly sweet, and it had a great fruit flavor. The crust was perfect too!
Patricia C. - Longwood, FL
Great texture, great crust, not too sweet. We enjoyed this pie very much. We do wish it had more coconut flavor. 
Dana C. - Brentwood, CA
I love the quality of the Achatz pies and the free shipping. It is better than an Edible arrangement.
Pamela I. - Portland, OR
We ordered a Cannoli Pie and it was out of this world. I can’t even describe how delicious it was. Extremely fresh and better than any Cannoli I’ve ever had. Yummy!
Molly M. - Johns Creek, GA
Quick delivery and pie to die for! Yum OH!!
Dennis F. - Jacksonville, AR
Oh my goodness, my husband ate the whole thing by was a treat for days and I tasted it as well. The pecan layer was and carmelized and just perfect; the pumpkin layer was a little more subtle (I'd like it to have just a touch more spice) but never in a million years did I think they'd go together...which they did. The whipped cream topping was so easy to pipe since they included a piping bag and it looked like a professional pie. We will most certainly order again.
Elizabeth G. - Canton, GA
Excellent products, and delivery is always on time!
Lori L. - Redding, CT
Omg these pies were delicious as well as the highlight of Thanksgiving dinner.
Barbara K. - Buellton, CA
Absolutely yummy, and the delivery was excellent. We won the Thanksgiving potluck with these pies, though admittedly the uncooked green bean casserole wasn’t much competition.
Ron D. - Las Vegas, NV
Pro packaging. Fantastic fresh ingredients. No additives. Delicious.
James G. - Parkville, MD
My employer provided the pie for free so there's that, but its flavor was fantastic! I never had a pie like that. I believe it was the Multi-Berry, but what ever the name was my only regret was that I ran out.
Alejandro C. - Orlando, FL
We look forward each year to our company, Agile-Defense, ordering a homemade pie to be delivered to our home before Thanksgiving. The pies are simply perfect and delicious! not too sweet, not too tart. just perfect. The large size is very nice as well. Thank you!
Donetta P. - Stafford, VA
Dilvered on time and you took car to put it in z plastic bag because it was raining. Thank you. Birthday pie for my 30 yr old son. I miss him much and Michigan 4 berry pie brings us a little closer.
Johnathon K. - Livermore, CA
If this berry pie is any indication of how good the other Achatz' pies are, I'm there. Delicious all 'round!
Glenys C. - Mountain View, CA
Best pie I've ever eaten. Turnaround on order was great. Pie was packaged so well that not a crumb was broken.
Max M. - Tucson, AZ
I was especially impressed with the pie. It was packaged very well, and the presentation was lovely. Even though it arrived a day late, it was still well-chilled.
Wendy M. - Greene, NY
Good service, and a great source for wonderful Pies from ACHATZ, a hometown staple here in MI!!
Lou S. - Stuart, FL
Everyone I send the mixed berry pie to - at least ten each Christmas - thoroughly loves them and enjoy serving them to guests. We always order at least one for ourselves, as well. Also, all of the pies arrived on time.
Chrissy A. - Canton, GA
Pie with caramel and nuts - what's not to like? One of my mom's friends claimed that the pie from Achatz and mom's homemade almond rolls are the two best foods she's ever eaten.
Marlene O. - Iowa City, IA
Coconut Cream Pie was a gift and loved by my 3 friends........
Karen M. - Fort Myers, FL